The treatment landscape for borderline personality disorder (BPD) has changed dramatically over the past few decades. A condition that was once considered a life sentence is now recognized as one of the most treatable disorders in psychiatry. Several evidence-based interventions, including dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), mentalization-based therapy (MBT), transference-focused psychotherapy (TFP), and good psychiatric management (GPM), have consistently been shown to reduce symptoms and improve functioning.
One of the newest additions to this group of evidence-based treatments is BPD Compass, a modular intervention developed to personalize treatment based on the personality processes driving an individual’s symptoms. In an initial randomized controlled trial, participants receiving BPD Compass showed significant improvements in BPD symptoms, depression, anxiety, and the personality traits associated with the disorder after just 18 sessions of once-weekly outpatient therapy.
Why Was BPD Compass Developed?
Although existing treatments for BPD are highly effective, they can be difficult to access. Most of these interventions were originally developed for individuals at the highest levels of clinical need and are, therefore, long-term (usually at least a year), intensive (usually twice-weekly), and delivered by clinicians with specialized training. These programs remain critically important, particularly for patients with severe and persistent suicidal behavior.
At the same time, access to this level of care remains a challenge. Many specialty programs have waitlists that stretch six months to a year or longer, and some communities have few clinicians trained to deliver complex BPD treatments.
Another challenge is that BPD is one of the most heterogeneous disorders in psychiatry; in fact, there are 256 combinations of the diagnostic criteria that can result in a BPD diagnosis. Two people can have this condition while sharing only a handful of symptoms. For example, one person may struggle primarily with overwhelming emotions, another with unstable relationships, and a third with impulsive behaviors that interfere with important life goals.
These issues (accessibility and heterogeneity) raise an important question: Is it possible to personalize treatment for BPD so that clients receive the level and type of care that fits their symptoms?
BPD Compass was developed around the idea that treatment may be more efficient when it targets the processes maintaining each person’s difficulties, rather than assuming every client needs the same skills delivered in the same order.
How Does BPD Compass Work?
Unlike traditional treatments that organize care around the diagnosis itself, BPD Compass begins by identifying the personality processes most responsible for an individual’s symptoms. BPD Compass is the first intervention based on a more modern approach to understanding personality disorders, the Alternative Model of Personality Disorders (AMPD), which conceptualizes personality disorders in terms of maladaptive personality traits rather than symptom counts alone.
From this perspective, the symptoms of BPD are thought to emerge from three broad personality-based risk factors: emotional sensitivity, interpersonal dysfunction, and impulsivity. Although most people with BPD experience challenges in each of these areas to some degree, one domain is often more central than the others.
Consider a person with BPD who experiences difficulties with substance use. They might be using substances to escape from negative emotions—driven by the emotional sensitivity risk factor. Or, they might be using substances because it feels good in the moment—more of an impulsivity process. Knowing what’s driving symptom expression is crucial for providing the most personalized, efficient care.
Rather than teaching every client every possible skill, BPD Compass allows for the selection of the modules that are most likely to address the underlying processes maintaining a particular individual’s symptoms.
What Makes BPD Compass Different?
BPD Compass was designed to fit within the reality of today’s mental health system. The program consists of 18 once-weekly outpatient sessions, making it easier to integrate into routine clinical practice than some longer treatment models.
Borderline Personality Disorder Essential Reads
It was also designed to be delivered by generalist clinicians, not just BPD specialists. In the initial clinical trial, many of the therapists providing the treatment were trainees with relatively little prior experience treating BPD.
There are simply not enough specialty providers to meet the needs of the millions of people living with this condition. Expanding the number of clinicians who feel equipped to treat BPD has the potential to improve access to care while allowing intensive specialty programs to focus on individuals who require the highest levels of support.
The Future of BPD Treatment
BPD Compass was not developed to replace DBT, MBT, TFP, or GPM. Each of these interventions has a strong evidence base and continues to play an important role in helping people recover from borderline personality disorder.
Instead, BPD Compass represents another promising evidence-based option within an expanding treatment landscape. As our understanding of personality pathology continues to evolve, treatment is becoming increasingly personalized. Rather than asking which therapy is universally “best,” researchers and clinicians are beginning to ask a more useful question: Which evidence-based treatment is the best fit for this individual?
That shift toward personalized care has the potential to make treatment not only more effective, but also more accessible to the millions of people living with BPD.
To find a therapist, please visit the Psychology Today Therapy Directory.