Image: Push Square
10 new games are being added across PS Plus Extra and PS Plus Premium this month, but compared to August’s super strong offering, I can see September’s lineup being met with some criticism.
Honestly I’m not quite sure what the headline act is for Extra this time around. Co-op survival RPG RuneScape: Dragonwilds launches straight onto the subscription service — and it’s highly rated on PC — but I can’t see it appealing to everyone.
It’s followed by WWE 2K26 (hope you like wrestling!), the dangerously addictive Ball X Pit, and crazy romance-’em-up Date Everything. An interesting mix of genres at the very least.
Elsewhere, Ninja Gaiden: Ragebound is a certified side scrolling banger, and Slitterhead is weird — but in a good way, if you can look past the jank.
You also can’t really go wrong with Sniper Elite: Resistance, the latest effort in Rebellion’s eternally solid shooter series, and Dungeons of Hinterberg is an enjoyably chill indie adventure.
So while I wouldn’t say there are any stinkers in September’s selection, I do think it’s lacking star power — and that might be enough to sway opinions in this poll.
As for PS Plus Premium, Mega Man X: Command Mission is a turn-based excursion that can definitely scratch a certain nostalgic itch, and Metro Redux is well worth checking out if you’re yet to sample the post-apocalyptic Metro franchise.
But what do you make of September’s PS Plus Extra and Premium offerings? Vote in our polls, and then be brutally honest in the comments section below.
Are you happy with your PS Plus Extra games for September 2026? (352 votes)
Yes, very happy7%Yeah, mostly happy15%Meh, they’re okay24%Nah, they’re disappointing18%No, it’s a crap selection24%I don’t have PS Plus Extra11%
Which PS Plus Extra game for September 2026 are you most looking forward to? (364 votes)
Ball X Pit12%Date Everything2%Dungeons of Hinterberg2%Ninja Gaiden: Ragebound11%RuneScape: Dragonwilds10%Slitterhead10%Sniper Elite: Resistance2%WWE 2K265%None of them, to be honest33%I don’t have PS Plus Extra12%
Are you happy with your PS Plus Premium games for September 2026? (290 votes)
Yes, super happy3%Yeah, I’m happy8%Hmmm, they’re fine14%Nah, not really17%No, it’s a terrible lineup28%I don’t have PS Plus Premium30%
Robert (or Rob if you’re lazy) is an assistant editor of Push Square, and has been a fan of PlayStation since the 90s, when Tekken 2 introduced him to the incredible world of video games. He still takes his fighting games seriously, but RPGs are his true passion. The Witcher, Persona, Dragon Quest, Mass Effect, Final Fantasy, Trails, Tales — he’s played ’em all. A little too much, some might say.