The Manor House Thurloxton, between Taunton and Bridgwater, has dropped from its previous “good” rating following an assessment by the Care Quality Commission (CQC).
The five-person residential home was assessed between August 18 and September 3, with inspectors visiting twice, including an unannounced first visit.
In a reporter published on October 29, the CQC found the provider was in breach of legal regulations relating to safe care and treatment, staffing and good governance.
Watchdog inspectors said: “We identified several shortfalls at the service. The provider had not always identified and mitigated risks to people and those associated with health and safety to provide safe care.”
The home’s safety was rated “requires improvement” and scored 53 out of 100. Despite the score, residents have praised the home and said they “wouldn’t be anywhere else,” while inspectors acknowledged the kindness and compassion of carehome staff.
“Risk of harm” concerns for residents raised by CQC
Among inspectors’ concerns was a swimming pool accessible to residents, for which the provider had not assessed the risks.
The report said: “This presented a risk of harm to people, including a risk to life or serious injury.”
Inspectors also found water temperatures in residents’ rooms above recommended safe levels, uncovered hot radiators and pipes and, on their first visit, no first-floor window restrictors and hazardous products accessible to residents.
By the CQC’s second visit, window restrictors had been fitted and hazardous products were locked away. The deputy manager also said equipment to maintain safe water temperatures had been ordered.
Fire safety concerns included outstanding actions from a May 2026 assessment, no Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans in residents’ care records, and no fire drills despite these being recommended.
The watchdog report also noted staff had not received fire-safety training, although fire alarms were tested weekly.
Medicines management at Somerset care home criticised
During the visits inspectors also raised concerns over the management of medicine at the care home.
Three gaps were found in medication administration records for one resident’s pain relief, meaning the CQC said it could not be assured the medicines had been received.
There was no system for checking medicine stocks, while inspectors said high-risk medicines including lithium and blood thinners had not been risk-assessed.
“Staff did not receive training in medicines and did not have their competencies checked,” the report noted.
However, the inspectors noted medicines were securely stored, and residents had access to those prescribed to them.
Following inspectors’ feedback, the deputy manager “immediately acted” and introduced an electronic medication administration record system and medicines policy.
Residents and families praise “compassion and respect” at care home
Despite the concerns, the report paints a far more positive picture of residents’ experiences of the home.
The CQC continued to rate the home “good” for ‘caring’ and ‘responsive’ service categories, with both scoring 75 out of 100.
Inspectors said residents and relatives gave positive feedback, and observed staff treating people “with kindness, compassion and respect”.
One resident said: “I wouldn’t be anywhere else,” while another said: “They [staff] are all so kind.”
A relative told inspectors: “Staff go above and beyond, and way past the expectations we have,” while another said: “They [staff] behave like an extended family. They include the residents in what they do.”
Residents and relatives did not raise safeguarding concerns with inspectors, while one resident said: “Yes I am safe here, staff treat me well.”
The CQC also found the home was clean and welcoming, staff knew residents well, and people were supported to maintain their independence and access healthcare.
The regulator has asked the provider to submit an action plan responding to the concerns identified during the assessment.
“Our environment is intended to be as a family home”
After being approached for comment by the Bridgwater Mercury, a spokesperson for The Manor House Thurloxton said: “As a very small (maximum of five), family run, and entirely non-institutional care home, our environment is intended to be as a family home would be. This does not always align neatly with regulations designed to manage the risks in care homes with dozens of beds.
“Our small staff take time to know every resident’s needs and preferences (as noted in the report).”
However, the spokesperson acknowledged the CQC’s requirement for auditable records, to prove compliance with all the areas of the regulations needed.
They added: “Where appropriate, and as acknowledged in the report, we have already implemented or instigated a number of changes requested by the CQC (for example, an upgrade to our existing fire detection system, and the implementation of computerised medication records) and have an action plan to carry out everything required in order to return to the ‘good’ rating we have held for the past 30 years.
“As is made clear in the full version of the CQC report, everyone agrees that we provide an extremely kind, caring and compassionate service, and the CQC found that residents and their families along with all professionals contacted, were universally happy with the care we provide.”