Open this photo in gallery:

The federal government has proposed merging the RRSP with the RRIF, eliminating the need for conversion by age 71.Kenneth Cheung/iStockPhoto / Getty Images

After Ottawa proposed an “RRSP-for-life” in last week’s federal budget, Aaron Hector, founding partner and senior wealth advisor at Calgary-based Tier Wealth, a partner firm of Q Wealth Partners Inc., took to his keyboard.

He posted three pages of commentary on LinkedIn and will e-mail a formal submission to Finance Canada for its public consultation on the proposal, which ends Jan. 8, 2027.

As the federal government envisions, the RRSP-for-life would merge the registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) with the registered retirement income fund (RRIF), eliminating the need to convert an RRSP to a RRIF by age 71. It’s a move Mr. Hector proposed in a post published on LinkedIn more than a year ago.

Globe Advisor spoke with Mr. Hector about advisor engagement in public policy and his recommendations for combining the two registered retirement plans.

What compelled you to respond to the government’s callout for comments?

I know most advisors don’t write comments [to the government], but they should. The government is asking for feedback from people on how these ideas should work. This is our moment to use our voices as the government is looking to change the fundamental retirement account most Canadians use.

I saw it as an opportunity to look at some of these bigger issues that have been flawed with these accounts for a long time.

Rather than commenting directly, advisors may defer to their professional association or dealer to comment on their behalf.

It’s true we should expect that our industry associations will be making a submission, but there’s also power in numbers. If the government hears not only from organizations, but also from potentially thousands of Canadians about how the system could be improved, that will have some weight.

As someone who works with clients on their registered accounts, what does Finance Canada absolutely need to get right with the RRSP-for-life?

People don’t want to lose any of the flexibility they have today with an RRSP or RRIF. You don’t want to combine them if it means people are left in a worse position than they were in previously.

So, things such as ensuring that they’re not offering a mandatory successor-holder option for the account, but [ensuring] a client has the option to designate a beneficiary instead for additional post-death tax planning flexibility for the survivor.

I’d also like to see RRSP savers treated in a similar light to how defined-benefit pension members are treated. Now is the time when the federal government should be looking at bringing more fairness into the system, fixing inequalities.

Most people don’t go into their first job thinking, ‘When I retire, am I going to be able to income split?’ They’re just looking for a job they enjoy and will pay the bills.

As it stands right now, one spouse with a DB pension plan can income-split their pension with their spouse when they retire. Another person who doesn’t have a DB plan but has an RRSP can’t split that income with their spouse when they retire if they’re under 65 years of age. There’s an unfairness in that equation.

You also mentioned problems with the withholding tax.

The withholding tax amounts are wildly out of date. They haven’t adjusted for inflation since 1978, [and] $5,000 back then, inflation-adjusted, is more than $20,000 today.

[Currently, withdrawals from RRSPs (and withdrawals from RRIFs in excess of the minimum) up to $5,000 have 10 per cent withheld; between $5,000 and $15,000 have 20 per cent withheld; and more than $15,000 have 30 per cent withheld.]

I see this quite often, in which someone needs to take a larger sum of money out of their account and the only savings they have of any significance might be in an RRSP or a RRIF. The extra 30 per cent [withholding tax] they need to take out to get that money becomes a punitive situation for their overall taxes. They end up having to pay tax on the entire larger amount.

What about the goal of having the RRSP-for-life in place for the 2028 taxation year?

That’s pretty ambitious. The feedback period closes in early 2027. To expect them to get all the legislation in place, have it approved, go through Parliament and then get it into the financial institutions for them to be able to make changes? I think that’s too tight of a timeline.

This interview has been edited and condensed.

Are you reading us on the web or did someone forward the e-mail version to you? If so, you can sign up for Advisor Weekly here.Must reads

Don’t be a meat proxy: There’s a new insult making the rounds in tech circles, and financial advisors should pay attention, Jason Pereira writes.

Preparing for CRM3: With weeks to go before the new CRM3 reports land in front of clients, advisors have a window of opportunity to get in front of potential sticker shock and ensure a smooth transition. The first article in our series offers five tips on how to approach total cost reporting. The second article asks behavioural finance experts what makes a well-designed client report.

FHSA mistakes: Many new homebuyers remain confused about how the first home savings account works more than three years after the vehicle’s launch. Advisors say these common issues are tripping up their clients.

More from The Globe

Key person risk: Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang was almost inseparable from the company: his board had no chairman, there was no succession plan for his replacement and an unusually large number of senior executives reported to him directly, John Rapley writes. The question now is, could Nvidia’s tangled political and corporate webs bring the whole market down with it?

Improper borrowing: Ontario’s securities watchdog has ruled that Toronto-based fund manager Emerge Canada Inc. and two executives, including founder Lisa Langley, breached their responsibilities to investors when they borrowed almost $6-million of investor money improperly to cover operating expenses. The tribunal also found the three members of the firm’s independent review committee did not fail in their duties to oversee conflicts of interest.

Online gambling: Advisors are hearing more about their clients’ (or their clients’ children’s) online gambling. Meera Raman reports on how even small, regular bets can add up over time, eating into savings and making it harder to reach long-term financial goals.