
Credit: Far Out / YouTube Stills
November 14th, 2026 · 9:45pm GMT
Movie sequels rarely live up to the original film that inspired them, but there are a few that, somehow, surpass what came before. For Javier Bardem and Gary Oldman, one of their favourite movies is the greatest sequel of them all.
Rotten Tomatoes caught up with both to ask them what their five favourite films are. Three of the answers were common. Bardem listed The Deer Hunter, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, and E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial as movies that meant a lot to him. Perhaps the only surprise was 1953’s Welcome Mr Marshall, which was co-written by his uncle, Juan Antonio Bardem.
Topping the list was Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather Part II. His reasoning was, “You can’t go wrong with that, right? It’s one of those where everything works. Everybody had to pick up their performance, including cast and technicians. And I’m a huge, huge long-time fan of Mr Pacino so… I think it’s, along with Dog Day Afternoon, his best performance. There’s something about the movie that really transports you to a different era, like it takes you to a new place.”
When Oldman answered the same question, one on the list was an entry many may not have seen: 1998’s Ratcatcher. Also up there was the 1973 Martin Sheen and Sissy Spacek classic, Badlands. He also showed off his Coppola fandom, with three of his five faves coming from the iconic director.
He named Apocalypse Now and The Conversation, and the one remaining slot, as with Bardem, went to The Godfather Part II. He said, “With these three [Coppola’s] a great storyteller. Godfather: Part II, I just think it’s a master class in acting, production design, directing, lighting, composition. I think that if you were a film student, you’ve got, the way he tells the story, it’s masterful storytelling. And it never ever seems to disappoint.”
Coppola hit it big in 1972 with The Godfather. Winning five Oscars, the violent tale of the Corleone family was based on Mario Puzo’s novel of the same name. The follow-up had the challenge of being an original idea, with Coppola back as both the director and co-writer with Puzo. Just as challenging, The Godfather Part II was coming off the heels of the critically praised The Conversation, which came out the same year.
Bardem is spot on about how everything in The Godfather Part II works. The phenomenal cast included a whopping three nominees for ‘Best Supporting Actor’, with Robert De Niro claiming a trophy. The only shocker is that Pacino didn’t win ‘Best Actor’, losing out to Art Carney for Harry and Tonto. As magnificent as he was in the first for his portrayal of Michael Corleone, he turned expectations on their head in the sequel as a leader the audience roots for while he becomes more cruel.
Further reading: Cutting Room Floor
The filmmaker’s writing often gets overshadowed by those classic performances. It shouldn’t be. He and Puzo picked up the ‘Best Adapted Screenplay’ Academy Award due to their ability to take the established familiar and push it farther. Not only does Michael Corleone grow darker, but the viewer is given the contrast of De Niro as Vito Corleone rising to the top as his son falters in the present.
So many sequels fail because of a lazy attempt to recapture the magic of the past. The Godfather Part II sucks you in by going even bigger than before. The risk pays off with one of the best movies ever made. Notice, however, that neither Bardem nor Oldman listed The Godfather Part III in their list. You won’t see that disaster listed by anyone.