It’s time for our Monday wrap on who has their name in lights and who is making headlines for all the wrong reasons after the weekend.
THEY’RE ON FIRE!
Wales: Nowhere else to start this week but with Steve Tandy’s superheroes. We stuck them into the Broken Thermostat section last weekend after their laboured victory against Japan, but what they produced against the All Blacks was incredible and a beautiful reminder of how fantastic and unifying rugby can be.
The Welsh have been the butt of a bad joke for far too long, damaged goods not helped by brutal WRU governance, but the valleys are now alive again with joyous giddiness that the national rugby team is no longer a laughing stock. The way Tandy’s team defended in the closing 26 minutes and protected that seven-point lead with their lives was jaw-dropping, cult status epitomised in the defiance of the likes of Dafydd Jenkins, Jac Morgan and James Botham. Their attack, though, has to be saluted as well; they moved the ball deliciously to set up the shock result.
France: So much for that old rugby saying, no scrum, no win. The French front-row creaked all Friday night at Stade de France, conceding nine penalties, yet they were the ones celebrating at the finish of a marvellous contest that gladdened the heart of rugby neutrals everywhere. More so than the Welsh, whose last score against the All Blacks was their 49th-minute converted try, the defensive resolve demonstrated by the French following their last-score 32nd-minute try was startling, especially as three yellow cards were copped while clinging on.
The way Fabien Galthie’s charges stayed connected was a terrific reflection on how far a positive attitude can take you in this sport, and the fact that the win was secured with the astounding Antoine Dupont selected as emergency out-half made the success even more spectacular. It was a timely reminder that next year’s Springbok World Cup title hat-trick isn’t the done deal it has been made out to be by their partisan fans despite their team’s dominance in areas of the game such as the scrum.
England: We came into November after crying out loud all year for stubborn Steve Borthwick to give his head a wobble and allow Lee Blackett to ignite the English attack, and people are now salivating about the possibilities of what can be achieved after a second successive demonstration of on-the-ball vibrancy at Twickenham. Yes, the Japanese were defensively horrendous, but there was chutzpah about the way England clinically went about their business of ratcheting up 78 points.
Will Joseph was the jackpot beneficiary, scoring five tries in just his second appearance – his first since 2022. His impact was an example that a talented seam of players who exist on the fringes have been underused by the conservative Borthwick, who consistently prefers his favourites unless injury forces his hand. Mention must also be made of Maro Itoje, given England’s next two matches will be fierce contests. His tackling and turnover winning has taken on a fresh edge this month, generating optimism that England finally won’t crash and burn as they have been doing when November annually gives way to the February Six Nations.
Jake White: We liked the quick organisational improvement the South African coach has made with Fiji. Watching the Pacific Islanders getting destroyed by England in Liverpool last July was a kick in the goolies, igniting fears that they would be a mess for next year’s World Cup, the quadrennial tournament they come alive for. Saturday night’s 28-point margin of defeat in Dublin wasn’t a fair reflection; the match was much closer than that.
The Fijians forced the Irish to make more tackles than they did, and who knows, if this was a visiting team with a couple of years under White tutelage, they could genuinely have threatened to take the win. As it was, a golden chance was lost early in the second half with Ireland a yellow-carded man down and only two points separating the teams on the scoreboard. A game plan truly designed to exploit the situation didn’t exist and its absence is surely something White will go about concocting once the fundamentals, such as the penalty-leaking scrum, are further tightened up this November.
Latest World Rugby rankings: Scotland cut gap on England as Wallabies feel the heat
BROKEN THERMOSTAT!
South Africa: Losing would normally be a prime reason for chucking a team into our Cold As Ice section, but we’re giving Rassie Erasmus’ charges a reprieve on this occasion on the basis that the last scrum in Paris on another night would have resulted in a penalty call that would have allowed them to win with the match’s final kick. Referee Andrea Piardi had no hesitation blowing his whistle numerous times to punish French front-row infringements, but for whatever reason, he didn’t fancy doing so when it most mattered and instead told them to play on.
That is the sort of interpretation that will infuriate the Springboks and it should make them a better team in the long run. Similar to the loss to New Zealand last August in the opening Greatest Rivalry series match, the South Africans neglected to kick penalties for points due to an overindulgence to go down the touchline instead. They need to be more pragmatic in such situations. After all, they won the last World Cup with three one-point wins in the knockouts and goalkicking is something they need to get back to.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
Ireland: Andy Farrell has been blathering about new standards for his team, but their inconsistencies were visible again at the weekend, providing more evidence that when he mixes up his selection, the standards drop off rather than improve. We have seen this vulnerability last July when things didn’t click against Japan in Newcastle, and it was similar against the Fijians in Dublin.
Ireland’s first-half display wasn’t the confident step forward they wanted to take heading into next Saturday’s defining meeting with the Springboks a year on from the pasting they got when the teams last met. They have a severe headache to alleviate at No.8 and a looseness to their play on both sides of the ball that must be remedied or a price will be paid in Nations Championship round six. They also had another reminder that they aren’t the drawcard they once were with the Irish public, as Aviva Stadium had empty seats for the second match in a row. Boy do they need a victory over the Boks to alter the indifferent consensus about them.
Argentina: Saturday’s win in Genoa didn’t have fans dancing at the crossroads in Buenos Aires and with good reason; it was an ugly win reflective of the vulnerability and indecision that have shackled the Pumas’ progress for some time now. They really need to rediscover what they were good at. As has too often been the case of late, there were too many turnovers conceded and too many tackles missed against Italy, issues that will be exploited by France next weekend unless there is an improvement.
In fairness, they reacted well to going down to 13 players with Italy closing the gap to five points, doing enough to protect that advantage and staying in front, but there is little or nothing about Felipe Contepomi’s team at the minute to genuinely get excited about. Is it inadequate coaching or players simply not being good enough? The jury is out on that front. As it stands, a huge performance is needed in Paris.
Scotland: Another team where the weekend reaction about was meh! Going 46 minutes without a score at home made for tough viewing for Scottish fans and, in ways, how they played was a re-run of last November when the hangover of defeat to the All Blacks carried over into the disappearing act against Argentina. They were beaten on that occasion 12 months ago, so Sunday’s insipid display versus Australia wasn’t disastrous in the sense that the Scots won this time around after enduring another All Blacks hangover.
However, they were far too dull for anyone’s liking and questions will again start formulating over why they have stuck with Gregor Townsend through to World Cup 2027 instead of trying something different to get them out of the washing machine-like cycle they remain sucked into. With Japan visiting next weekend, Scotland will finish their Nations Championship pool with four wins from six, but reasons to be genuinely positive about next year are still in short supply.
COLD AS ICE!
New Zealand: The fear of getting stigmatised has been a great motivator for All Blacks teams in matches they are expected to win comfortably. No player wanted to be part of a Kiwi team on the receiving end of an upset result, and they would respond accordingly and win. However, they have now been sent spiralling into the hurt locker. Wales’ run of Test results since World Cup 2023 has been desperate, so the All Blacks losing last Saturday – and becoming the first New Zealand side to do so in the fixture in 73 years – will damage careers.
Dave Rennie’s tenure is now under severe pressure as well and nothing but a win over England can soothe the emergency he has been plunged into. A big deal has been made about the creative moving-the-ball style he has brought in, but the sacked Scott Robertson wasn’t in charge of an All Blacks side that lost to Wales. They had the composure to douse Welsh fire a year ago and run out 52-26 winners. Rennie was unable to make an in-game difference last Saturday, a development that spells trouble for the general agreement that he was the right man to take over.
Japan: Is Eddie Jones now too long in the tooth for Test rugby? The evidence of Saturday’s capitulation in London suggests that the 66-year-old is now a dinosaur in a sport that keeps evolving quickly and he hasn’t kept pace. Hasn’t done so for years, given how his England tenure and his damaging Australia cameo ended.
The least he could be doing with the Japanese is having them organised, but the way they never got off the bus at Twickenham and the way they reacted to having 14 players due to Harry Hockings 20-minute red card smacked of a team that hadn’t trained for such a scenario, so large were the defensive gaps. There was a romantic aspect about Jones returning to take charge of the country he ignited at the 2015 World Cup, but the current team is lacking the basics to be taken seriously and that’s on Jones who has been with them for nearly three years.
Australia: With another defeat arising on Les Kiss’ watch, the Wallabies are again stuck in this Cold As Ice! but the state of affairs isn’t as gloomy as it was after the trouncing by England. They never fired a shot in London, but there was a threat to them in Edinburgh that suggests they have it within their gift to make the improvements demanded by their long-suffering fans.
Not having a dependable 10 they could build their game on has severely hampered them in recent years, but it was interesting that there were some flashes of attacking quality from the fit-again Carter Gordon and he could be the long-run talisman to lift their game. The statistic of Australia’s 10 linebreaks to Scotland’s one stood out as something to build on in their remaining two matches this month.
Italy: If rugby was football, Gonzalo Quesada would be up for sacking. He felt on top of the world with his team when they beat England for the first time last March, but they have now lost six on the bounce and the lack of confidence evident in the latest defeat to Argentina has you wondering if the coach has got the guile to turn things around.
For a team playing at home, getting well beaten in the possession and territory stakes was disappointing. That had a couple of stars such as Manuel Zuliani, but they collectively just didn’t take enough of the fight to Argentina, another team struggling for results, and they got the loss they deserved.
READ MORE: The Raeburn Shield – Why Wales are now world champions after beating the All Blacks