Although surgeons had been instructed to stop operating on children, the order was not fully implemented until August.
Angela Constance told MSPs that was “an extremely serious and wholly unacceptable failure”.
She added: “I became aware of the paediatric service cessation in August through media interest and acted immediately, speaking to the Chief Executive, setting clear expectations for safe and rapid restoration, and visiting Dr Gray’s within days to meet the Chief Executive and staff.”
Ms Constance has drafted in an emergency team to turn the beleaguered board around (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)
During exchanges in the chamber, Labour’s Jackie Baillie pointed out that HIS had raised concerns with one of the Scottish Government‘s Deputy Chief Medical Officers in May.
She asked why ministers had not been alerted then, and said those who should be held accountable had “all mysteriously left their posts”.
Ms Constance said she was sighted on the HIS report on October 29 and had been aware of the issues at Dr Gray’s in August.
The Health Secretary also questioned the reliability of information NHS Grampian had given to ministers.
Her predecessor, Neil Gray, chaired the board’s annual review in October 2025, where Grampian stated it was making clear progress, including on Significant Adverse Event Reviews.
Ms Constance said: “That raises serious questions about the accuracy of the information being scrutinised by the Board and shared with Government.”
Labour leader Michael Marra accused NHS managers of being “more interested in managing headlines than fixing patient care” and asked if Ms Constance was satisfied those in charge had not covered anything else up.
She replied: “I have faith in Healthcare Improvement Scotland in terms of the review. I think we can all agree that it has not minced its words and I do not believe it has left any stone unturned.
“He is right to point to concerns around veracity. To be blunt, confidence will have to be rebuilt with ministers. I think that journey has started, but I will absolutely demand the highest of standards and that all facts, whether they are positive or negative, are accurately laid in front of ministers.”
The minister also defended NHS Grampian’s chief executive
To help turn the board around, Ms Constance announced she was drafting in a new external Intervention Support Team made up of senior NHS leaders from outside Grampian with expertise in operational recovery, clinical governance and patient safety.
She defended Chief Executive Laura Skaife-Knight, who brought in HIS in May, eight months after taking up the post. Ms Constance said: “She was right to do this.”
She added: “I have seen from the Review and from my time in Grampian that the Chief Executive has held her hands up where she has made mistakes, she has apologised and she has shown a commitment to dismantling the poor organisational culture that has led to many of these issues.”
She said: “Importantly, both the Chief Executive and the Interim Chair know they have until the end of the year to evidence urgent improvements. The Board requires stability now to do that.”
Ms Constance announced that NHS Grampian will remain in a strengthened Stage 4 framework and warned that the option to escalate to Stage 5 remains on the table, with a reassessment due in six weeks.
Jack Middleton, the SNP MSP for Aberdeen Central, warned that the crisis “underlines a wider issue that public service reform is going to have to address”.
“There are too many executives earning massive salaries who face such little accountability that they can preside over serious failures like this and still walk away at the end of it with a massive payoff paid for by the taxpayers,” he said, asking how quickly ministers would intervene if improvements are not delivered by the end of the year.
Ms Constance replied: “Patients and frontline staff have been badly let down and those responsible for leading NHS Grampian must now demonstrate rapid and sustained progress. As I said in my statement, I expect clear progress before Christmas.
“And if progress is not delivered, I can assure you I will act quickly and all further escalation options will remain available.”
The board’s leadership is already being overhauled following the resignation of its chair in August and the appointment of Interim Chair John Connaghan CBE in October.
Dr Graham Ellis, one of the Scottish Government‘s Deputy Chief Medical Officers, started as interim medical director on Monday, while four new non-executive directors are being appointed — replacing almost half the board.
Ms Constance said Dr Ellis’s appointment showed “how seriously I take the issues at Grampian”.
Alongside an early review by HIS within three months and regular briefings for MSPs, Ms Constance said she had also asked the Patient Safety Commissioner to provide external scrutiny of the board.
The Health Secretary also responded to recent speculation about the future of Dr Gray’s under the government’s public service reform programme.
She said: “What is evidenced in this report is that the status quo is not working, and that is due to a failure of leadership, governance and accountability.”
She added: “Let me be categorical: Dr Gray’s Hospital will remain a key asset for care of patients in the north and will be a primary focus of our work to recover Grampian.”
Ms Constance said Dr Gray’s would remain a “key asset” for NHS Grampian (Image: Anne Burgess / Geograph)
HIS found that some of the hospital’s key services were “functioning in isolation rather than as part of a cohesive and resilient NHS Grampian model”. It also said there was a “them and us” culture between Elgin and Aberdeen, which “appeared to be reinforced by those in leadership positions”.
Ms Constance said: “I find it completely intolerable that the Review found a culture of ‘us’ and ‘them’.”
The Cabinet Secretary has written to trade unions to say that staff who raise concerns have a right to be heard without fear of detriment, and has invited Scotland’s Independent National Whistleblowing Officer to get involved in NHS Grampian’s work.
She said: “There can be no lasting improvement in patient safety, organisational culture or public confidence unless staff are confident that their voices are heard and their concerns addressed.”
She added: “The evidence is clear that the principal challenge lies not with frontline staff, but with the leadership.”