The world number one became the first player since 1967 to lose all four matches in the opening four sessions as Europe put themselves on the verge of a historic victory, leading 11.5-4.5 going into the final day.
After opening day defeats in the fourballs and foursomes, Scheffler again returned empty-handed on Saturday with another double loss.
The 29-year-old, playing with Russell Henley, suffered a one-hole defeat to Robert MacIntyre and Viktor Hovland in the morning foursomes, to make it a 100 per cent loss record from his four outings in that format.
Things got worse for him in the afternoon fourballs as he and partner Bryson DeChambeau were beaten 3&2 in a match that involved a bust-up between the players and caddies.
Scheffler is the standout individual player in the United States team, having won five tournaments this year including the PGA Championship and the Open.
It is a record that has put him clear of the field in a similar way to Woods during his pomp.
While Woods dominated on an individual level he could not bring that to the Ryder Cup, especially in the two-player formats where he had a poor record of nine wins, 19 losses and one half.
Scottie Scheffler of Team United States during the morning foursome
And it seems the 29-year-old is having a similar problem, with just one win, six defeats and two halves.
Before the tournament started Scheffler was asked whether he would be a difficult partner given his individual results.
Asked if he had an aura like Woods, he said: “Not really. I don’t have much to elaborate on that.
“I’d like to think that I’m not difficult to pair with people. I’d like to think of myself as someone that’s a nice guy and easy to get along with.
“I’ve had different partners over the years and have had some success. I would definitely not put myself in that category.
“I think some of the difficulty you had with playing with Tiger…I mean, I don’t even know what it could be. It could just be the aura that was Tiger Woods.
“There was some times there when he was doing nothing but winning golf tournaments and just beating the absolute crap out of people time and time again.”
Now Scheffler will look to claim his first point of this year’s Ryder Cup as he faces a mouth-watering showdown with Rory McIlroy on Sunday.
Tee times for the third day of 45th Ryder Cup at Bethpage Black, New York, on Sunday, September 28:
Singles (USA names first, all times BST):
1702: Cameron Young v Justin Rose
1713: Justin Thomas v Tommy Fleetwood
1724: Bryson DeChambeau v Matt Fitzpatrick
1735: Scottie Scheffler v Rory McIlroy
1746: Patrick Cantlay v Ludvig Aberg
1757: Xander Schauffele v Jon Rahm
1808: JJ Spaun v Sepp Straka
1819: Russell Henley v Shane Lowry
1830: Ben Griffin v Rasmus Hojgaard
1841: Collin Morikawa v Tyrrell Hatton
1852: Sam Burns v Robert MacIntyre
1903: Harris English v Viktor Hovland