I’ve reported on many criminal cases, but nothing like Constance Marten and Mark Gordon’s. Their trials were extraordinary.
A couple who were twice in the dock over the death of their newborn baby, they appeared to be completely in love and still fiercely united. And yet they had utter contempt for the court process.
They caused chaos across their two trials, which both overran by months. At one point, the Old Bailey’s most senior judge accused them of trying to “sabotage” and “manipulate” their retrial. It nearly collapsed a number of times.
Their behaviour – from refusing to turn up to court and claiming to be ill, to sacking countless barristers and Gordon’s trousers even being misplaced one day – left His Honour Judge Mark Lucraft KC exasperated on many occasions.
At one point he said two teenagers, who had been in his court the previous week, were “rather better behaved” than Marten, adding: “And they pleaded guilty to murder.”
Over the last 18 months I’ve sat through Marten and Gordon’s two criminal trials.
The first, which started in January 2024, resulted in the pair being found guilty of concealing the birth of their baby, Victoria, of perverting the course of justice and child cruelty.
But in late June, the jury in that trial was dismissed, unable to decide on one of the two, more serious charges about Victoria’s death.
A second trial began almost nine months later. They have now both been found guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence.
Now their case is over, we can report some of the remarkable moments when jurors were not in court. At times what happened across the trials was jaw-dropping.