A recent article in the Harvard Business Review reports that the top use of artificial intelligence (AI) tools like ChatGPT in 2025 are now for companionship and therapy. This is a shift from 2024 where the predominant use was for organization and general reference. As a practicing psychotherapist and lecturer in media and communication, I have been deeply fascinated with this emerging role played by AI in people’s private and interpersonal lives, and wonder if this truly can be a useful or valuable resource for individuals struggling with mental health or loneliness in our digital age?

In Marshall McLuhan’s laws of media, he argued that every new medium or technology both enhances and obsolesces core human faculties. With that in mind, it’s important to look at what AI enhances or improves at the level of interpersonal skills or therapeutic engagements, and also what it obsolesces or weakens at the same time. From this lens, we can see how a tool like ChatGPT may serve usefully as a facilitator for private or personal dialogue. At the same time, knowing its affordances, biases and limitations can alert us to ways that AI as a companion or therapy tool may inhibit core relational skills such as conflict repair or individualization.

Positive Therapeutic Alliance

Generative AI is designed to be an engaging and positive experience for users. It is trained to minimize frustration and maximize satisfaction. As a technology, it privileges coherence, helpfulness, and politeness. On the surface, a good companion or therapist may have the same qualities. In therapy we call this a positive therapeutic alliance. At the beginning of therapy, a positive alliance is essential as a way to build trust and rapport as an entrance point to self-disclosure and deeper psychological work. Therapists very often work to make a client’s “messy” psyche seem more coherent and may try to provide useful and helpful tools to manage difficult emotions or situations.

Generative AI is often very good at simulating this alliance. In my own experience experimenting with ChatGPT, it is always very enthusiastic about the topics I propose and never shy about offering tips or suggestions on psychological issues like boundary setting or having difficult conversations. I have never strongly opposed any of its therapeutic suggestions outright, except on the ground that they tend to be generic and obvious. For example, in a recent prompt on how to be civil during divorce proceedings, AI recommended “clarifying boundaries and limits” for each partner and normalizing feelings of “loss, disbelief and unfairness.” Nothing wrong with this, though not uniquely insightful either.

The major problem with AI as a therapist or companion, however, lies outside of its design paradigm. It is not designed to frustrate, to challenge, or to be at a loss for words. This is ironically why it is so appealing. It is never too tired or distracted to listen, and it never contradicts or questions a user statement. It my clinical training we had a name for this—benign therapy. This is where a therapist merely agrees and affirms the client at all times, and does not risk resistance, ambivalence, or uncertainty. In other words, AI can often be too much of a “yes man.”

Negative Capability

The poet John Keats discussed the importance of what he called negative capability—the ability to bear mystery, uncertainty, and doubt. In the space of the unknown, where boredom or frustration can grow, the self can also take shape. A relationship of any kind without friction or resistance is one-sided and ultimately unsatisfying, a narcissistic loop. We need to be challenged, tested, and left without clear answers or coherence. This allows for creativity and the seeds of individual thought.

Generative AI can be a good starting point to brainstorm or “whiteboard” thoughts that may not be ready for “real life.” It may be a good developmental step toward self articulation. So next time you venture a conversation or therapeutic “relationship” with a bot, ask it to challenge or contradict you. Invite it to be less coherent or to help ask questions instead. It may not reproduce a real flesh relationship, but it may yield richer social friction.