A former governor of the Bank of England has attacked proposals to impose a “mansion tax” on high-end properties, describing it as a “back of a fag packet” approach that could damage the economy.

Lord King of Lothbury was responding to suggestions that Rachel Reeves was considering imposing an annual 1 per cent tax on the value of a property above the £2 million mark, meaning that the owner of a £3 million home would face a bill of £10,000 every year.

This could raise between £2 billion and £3 billion a year for the Treasury. It is one of a number of tax measures on the wealthy being considered by the chancellor as she looks to close a hole of £20 billion to £30 billion in the government’s finances.

Rachel Reeves speaking with a microphone before her.

Rachel Reeves needs to fill a hole in the government’s finances of up to £30 billion

JORDAN PETTITT/PA WIRE

King, who was governor of the Bank until 2013, warned Reeves that adding yet another tax on to an already complicated system was incoherent, and blamed the budget process for failing to address the long-term problems with the economy.

• What a property tax shake-up could look like

“Property taxes are an interaction between stamp duty, council tax, capital gains tax [and] inheritance tax,” he said.

“You don’t solve that problem by just adding another wealth tax to it. So what I would advise her to do is to set up a group of people who, in 12 months, look deeply at all aspects of the tax treatment — not just on property but all kinds of other sorts of savings and wealth — to come up with a coherent view to what it should look like.

“And that doesn’t seem to happen. What happens is the OBR [Office for Budget Responsibility] produces just before the budget a number [for the deficit] and then they look round for ideas, almost written on the back of a fag packet, about how you can raise an extra few billion.

“That is not a coherent tax strategy. And you could do a great deal by thinking it through first.”

King said successive chancellors had failed to take a strategic approach to taxation and urged Reeves to change course. “There’s plenty of scope for reforming the tax system. We haven’t seen a chancellor take a strategic look at the tax system for almost 40 years. It’s been one kind of tinkering after another. That’s created a mess, an excessively complex one.”

Any move to impose a mansion tax would potentially require a revaluation of all properties in the UK, as council tax bands are based on the property values of April 1991. It would also disproportionately hit homeowners in London and the southeast, who have seen the price of their properties rise at a far faster rate than other parts of the country.

• Paul Johnson: Reeves must choose between political or economic disaster

The average house price in London is £561,000, compared with £291,000 in the rest of the UK. London house prices have almost doubled in 20 years.

Wes Streeting, the health secretary, described plans for a mansion tax as “wild speculation” — but admitted that the budget was likely to be difficult. “People can see the public finances are in a challenging state,” he told GB News. “So is the economy, but also so are family finances, so are business finances. We recognise that, we’ve got to get our economy growing again.”

He added: “There have been some encouraging signs in terms of interest rates and the UK projected to be the fastest-growing economy in the G7, those are all cause for encouragement. But we’re not out of the woods yet. The chancellor has got a challenging job. She’s got lots of considerations to balance and she will set out her choices at the budget and not before.”