Scott Foster’s articles from Lewis Silkin are most popular:


within Litigation and Mediation & Arbitration topic(s)
in United Kingdom
with readers working within the Pharmaceuticals & BioTech industries

Lewis Silkin are most popular:


within Cannabis & Hemp, Privacy and Law Practice Management topic(s)

The Court of Appeal’s decision in Samsung v ZTE
clarifies a live question in SEP/FRAND litigation: when parties are
locked in a global forum battle, does pressing for your preferred
court amount to bad faith? The answer, at least on these facts, is
no.

The backdrop in a nutshell

Samsung and ZTE are negotiating a renewed global cross-licence
over cellular SEPs (now including 5G). Samsung sued first in
England for a global FRAND determination and related relief. Within
days, ZTE launched proceedings in the Chongqing Court in China for
a global FRAND cross-licence. ZTE also filed infringement cases in
several jurisdictions (Germany, UPC, Brazil, Hangzhou), while
Samsung responded in kind in some fora and brought competition
claims elsewhere. Both sides floated interim cross-licence terms on
substantially the same commercial footing, with a single sticking
point: which court’s final FRAND determination should govern
any true-up—London (Samsung) or Chongqing (ZTE).

At first instance, Mellor J held ZTE had acted in bad faith by
using a wave of injunction actions to force a Chongqing FRAND
determination and granted declarations, including that a willing
licensor would enter into an interim licence tied to the English
court’s ultimate FRAND outcome. ZTE appealed.

What the Court of Appeal decided

The Court allowed the appeal, delivering three core
messages.

First, pressing for your preferred FRAND forum is not, without
more, bad faith. The Court distinguished earlier interim-licence
cases where SEP owners were using foreign injunctive pressure to
extract supra‑FRAND rates. Here, both sides accepted there
should be an interim licence and the fight was purely
jurisdictional. Absent a legitimate, substantiated objection to the
other forum (and none was made out against Chongqing), seeking to
channel the final determination there is not bad faith—even
if the conduct is unattractive and increases costs.

Second, “first seised” is not a trump card. While
being first to issue may be a tie-breaker in some contexts, it does
not, by itself, make the other party’s forum strategy improper.
The Court stressed that, given the lack of an international FRAND
forum rule, parallel proceedings are a structural feature of the
current ecosystem, not an automatic badge of bad faith.

Third, keep interim licences jurisdiction‑neutral. Birss
LJ in particular highlighted that the interim‑licence concept
(rooted in the CJEU’s decision of Huawei v ZTE) is
about securing ongoing implementation and payment while final terms
are resolved. In most cases, that can be done by fixing a sensible
interim financial mechanism that any competent court or tribunal
can credit later—without embedding a forum preference or
attempting to force a party into a specific jurisdiction.

On comity, the Court did not need to decide the point but
flagged real concerns with declarations designed to
“force” forum choices. It set aside the bad-faith and
forum‑specific declarations. A narrow, neutral
interim‑licence declaration reflecting agreed terms might be
permissible, but the parties were invited to address that
separately.

Why this matters

This judgment recalibrates interim‑licence practice and
forum strategy in FRAND disputes:


Bad faith is about substance, not forum preference. Using
injunctions to coerce supra‑FRAND outcomes remains offside.
Using litigation pressure to prefer a competent foreign FRAND
forum—absent concrete objections to that forum—does
not.

First-to-file helps, but won’t carry the day.

Neutral interim licences are a possible model. Courts will be
wary of interim constructs that smuggle in jurisdictional wins. A
clean, jurisdiction‑agnostic interim payment/security
framework, later credited against whatever final licence emerges
(wherever it’s determined), is more likely to stick.

Comity counts. Relief intended to lever parties out of a
parallel, properly seised foreign FRAND process risks
overreach.

Practical takeaways

For SEP owners and implementers alike, the safe path for interim
relief is pragmatic and neutral: set a fair, time‑limited
interim payment (or security), avoid forum‑locking clauses,
and let competent fora proceed. If you want to challenge the other
side’s chosen court, bring a substantiated,
forum‑specific objection—not a generic preference. And
if you are first seised, treat it as a factor, not a free pass.

Bottom line: in the current multi‑forum FRAND world, the
Court of Appeal has signalled that interim licences should reduce
friction, not weaponise it, and that forum jockeying—without
proof of real unfairness—is not, in itself, bad faith.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.