The army’s most senior former officers have accused the prime minister of allowing human rights law creep to undermine the effectiveness of Britain’s armed forces.
In an unprecedented intervention, nine four-star generals signed an open letter in The Times to coincide with Armistice Day on Tuesday, the moment the nation remembers its forces’ sacrifices.
They warn that soldiers’ trust in the legal system has deteriorated so badly that it now “risks everything”.
The collapse of faith is stripping UK troops of their fighting edge, just as the threat of new wars rises again and a major new force is being prepared to keep any peace in Ukraine, the generals claim.
They go as far as branding the depth of the trust erosion as “a direct threat to national security”, and reveal it has already sparked an exodus from the special forces — a claim they allege ministers have inaccurately tried to deny.
The increasing loss of highly trained personnel from elite units like the SAS and SBS is “not insignificant”, the generals argue, as they are “the men and women who quietly neutralise threats and protect lives in our cities every week”.
They write: “Today every British soldier deployed must consider not only the enemy in front of them but the lawyer behind them.

The prime minister with the leader of the Conservatives, Kemi Badenoch, and the leader of the Liberal Democrats, Ed Davey, at the Cenotaph during the service of Remembrance in Whitehall on Sunday
TIMES PHOTOGRAPHER RICHARD POHLE
“Make no mistake, our closest allies are watching uneasily, and our enemies will be rubbing their hands.”
The open letter is the most powerful salvo yet in a revolt that has been brewing for months across serving ranks and among Britain’s two million-strong veterans community.
It is also the first time in several generations that so many recently serving senior officers who hold the highest rank have spoken out together.
The generals say the collapse in faith is a direct consequence of “lawfare”, which they define as “the use of legal processes to fight political or ideological battles”.
Under it, decisions taken by troops in combat situations that were lawful at the time are now being re-evaluated, often years later, in “the misplaced light of hindsight”. The main tool for that, they say, is “an ever-broadening interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights”.
Soldiers’ fears of that happening to them is “paralysing decision-making, distorting rules of engagement and deterring initiative”.
The nine signatories have between them run much of the UK’s armed forces for the past 15 years, and include three former chiefs of the general staff, and ex-deputy Nato supreme allied commanders, and a former chief of the air staff.
• Veterans deal will stop IRA rewriting history, says minister
A source close to the generals said: “This is an existential issue for the armed forces and our nation’s fighting effectiveness, but the government is refusing to recognise it despite all the overwhelming evidence presented to them. The generals have decided the time has come for them to publicly stand up and be counted in the hope their voices help.”
In their letter, the senior figures directly call on Sir Keir Starmer and the attorney-general, Lord Hermer KC, to protect service personnel by urgently enacting a new legal framework.
They insist it must disapply the European Convention on Human Rights and the UK’s own Human Rights Act from troops’ actions while on active service in the UK and globally.
Uppermost of the signatories’ concerns is the government’s Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, which will allow a series of new investigations into military actions in the province over the three-decade-long war against the IRA that ended in 1997.
In passing the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act in 2023, the previous government ended dozens of new police investigations, coroners’ inquests and civil actions that had begun to result in veterans in their seventies and eighties facing court.
Under the Labour government’s new bill, the act would be scrapped and a new legacy commission set up, along with a dedicated legacy unit run by the Garda Siochana (Irish police) to probe historical allegations against UK forces as well as the IRA.
Ministers insist the new bill contains a series of protections for veterans.
But the generals argue they are paper-thin and the bill is a bitter betrayal of their service and “an abdication of responsibility”, as it “treats those who upheld the peace and those who bombed and murdered in pursuit of political ends as equivalent actors in a shared tragedy”.
• Former SAS brigadier ‘fears knock on door’ over Troubles killings
The nine four-stars also insist the problem “now extends far beyond Northern Ireland” and lawfare is able to target anyone in uniform on active service anywhere in the world.
The generals also insist that the Overseas Operations Act, also passed by the last government to end lawfare over conflicts abroad, does not go far enough to protect troops today. While Labour is not planning to repeal the new law, they say it only enforces a statute of limitations and still leaves enough ambiguity for service personnel to be pursued.
• The Times view: Acquittal of ‘Soldier F’ raises questions on handling of Troubles trials
The open letter’s nine signatories are former chiefs of the general staff (the professional heads of the British Army), Sir Peter Wall, Sir Patrick Sanders and Sir Mark Carleton-Smith; the former chief of the air staff (head of the RAF), Sir Andrew Pulford; the deputy Nato supreme allied commanders Europe, Sir Richard Shirreff and Sir Tim Radford; the former commanders of the UK’s Joint Forces Command, Sir Richard Barrons and Sir Chris Deverell; and a former commander-in-chief, land forces, Sir Nick Parker.
The MoD last night rejected the generals’ accusations and insisted that the new bill did have “robust safeguards” to protect veterans.
A government spokesman said: “We promised our veterans who served with honour in Northern Ireland that we would put proper protections in place, and the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill delivers on that commitment.
“After the false promises of the last government, we are putting in place six real, workable protections for veterans that the failed Legacy Act never did. We will not allow the process, like so many times before, to become the punishment for our veterans.”
“These robust safeguards will ensure the rights of those who served their nation so honourably are protected whilst providing victims with a human rights compliant, fair, and transparent system to seek answers.”