Just under two months after initial reports suggested Celtic were exploring long-term replacements for Kasper Schmeichel, the conversation has re-ignited, this time with a stronger focus on Manchester City’s Stefan Ortega.
The German goalkeeper, once viewed as an ambitious but unrealistic target, has again been linked with a potential summer move to Glasgow.
The renewed speculation comes via journalist Pete O’Rourke, who believes Ortega is firmly on Celtic’s radar as the club continues planning for a post-Schmeichel era.
With Schmeichel’s deal expiring in the summer of 2026 and his place increasingly under scrutiny, it is no surprise that recruitment staff are continuing to assess options.
However, while Ortega would represent a high-quality addition, his situation at Manchester City, and his salary level, means this rumour still sits firmly in the “interesting but improbable” category.
Celtic’s financial structure has rarely allowed for elite Premier League earners unless they are willing to accept major wage reductions, and at this stage there is no indication Ortega is prepared to make that jump.
Wilfried Nancy’s arrival has only intensified the conversation. His footballing philosophy demands a goalkeeper comfortable playing high, distributing under pressure, and contributing to build-up.
Ortega possesses those qualities in abundance, which naturally keeps his name near the top of speculative lists.
But tactical suitability and financial feasibility are two very different layers of the same debate.
He said: (the Inside Track podcast), “I think obviously it is an area of the team that the Celtic recruitment personnel are looking to strengthen the goalkeeping options.
“Ortega would be a good fit, you would think, especially if he does become a free agent in the summer.
“He’s basically just fallen totally out of favour at Man City, with Gianluigi Donnarumma and James Trafford ahead of him, and Marcus Bettinelli has been travelling with the squad.
“If Celtic are looking a new goalkeeper come the summer when Schmeichel’s contract is up, Ortega could be a really good pick up on a free transfer.
“He’s got good experience he’s played at the highest level for Manchester City as well.
“A very effective as a goalkeeper with the ball at his feet as well, so it could fit into the style of football that Wilfred Nancy will want to implement at Celtic.”
O’Rourke’s comments show why Ortega keeps appearing in discussions. His pedigree, Champions League football, Premier League experience, and a reputation for calm distribution, ticks virtually every box for a modern goalkeeper.
For Nancy, who wants to build patterns from deep and encourage bravery, few available keepers would be more stylistically aligned.
But even with the appeal clear, the practical obstacles remain large. Ortega is currently on Premier League-level wages that dwarf the salary band Celtic typically operate within.
Any move to Glasgow would require a substantial cut, possibly by more than half, which historically has made transfers of this profile extremely difficult, free agent or not.
Even if Ortega becomes a free transfer in 2026, his market will include Bundesliga clubs, mid-table Premier League sides, and ambitious European teams capable of offering both higher wages and guaranteed top-level competition.
Celtic can sell prestige, trophies, and European nights, but very rarely can they compete head-to-head financially.
Celtic’s pursuit of a new long-term No.1 is far from new. The earlier October reports already revealed internal concerns about Schmeichel’s consistency and longevity, while also raising questions about Viljami Sinisalo’s pathway into the starting role.
Ortega’s name fits the profile of the kind of bold, forward-thinking signing the club would ideally make, yet the underlying reality remains unchanged.
Schmeichel’s contract timeline gives Celtic another season to identify a successor, but the urgency is clear.
Nancy’s system demands a goalkeeper who is quick, composed, and mobile. Whether that player emerges from within, from a more financially attainable European league, or from a re-shaped negotiation landscape remains to be seen.
For now, the Ortega talk sits where it has sat for months: credible in football terms, questionable in financial terms.
O’Rourke is right that Celtic admire the profile, and the goalkeeper situation is unquestionably a priority. But unless Ortega is prepared to dramatically adjust his wage expectations, the leap from Manchester City to Celtic still feels unlikely.
Soccer Football – Premier League – Manchester City v Aston Villa – Etihad Stadium, Manchester, Britain – April 22, 2025 Aston Villa’s Marcus Rashford in action with Manchester City’s Stefan Ortega and Ruben Dias REUTERS/Phil Noble
The links will persist because of fit, timing, and need. But Celtic’s next No.1 will almost certainly come from a more realistic market.
Ortega may remain the dream signing, but dreams and budgets rarely align at Parkhead.
