Andy Burnham still wants to return as an MP before May’s local elections, when a Labour collapse could trigger a leadership crisis for Sir Keir Starmer, allies have said.

The mayor of Greater Manchester is understood to have identified a seat after meetings with MPs and is already canvassing support for a leadership challenge, according to sources. One said there were a “number of potential options open to him” and he has identified one which is “nailed on”.

Speculation has been mounting for months that Burnham is seeking a Westminster comeback. Asked last week about his ambitions, he told ITV News that “if the call came” to return to government “I’m not going to just turn away from it”. After another week of questions about Starmer’s future, Lucy Powell, the deputy Labour leader, urged colleagues to get behind him and his government “because of what we fear may come if Labour does not succeed”.

Lucy Powell MP holding an umbrella in Hulme Park, Manchester, with city buildings in the background.

Lucy Powell, the deputy Labour leader

MEN MEDIA

Powell said the party must come together and focus on the narrative of how Labour is “rewiring the country so it works more in the interest of ordinary people”.

However, Richard Burgon, the Labour MP for Leeds East, appeared to back Burnham for leader, saying Starmer’s successor should not be a member of the cabinet. Speaking on Radio 4’s The Week in Westminster, he said the next leader needed to be “somebody who isn’t implicated in any of the unpopular decisions”.

Burgon, who is on the hard left of the party and makes an unlikely ally of the soft-left Burnham, said: “The reality is, if we do well in the elections in May, and we should do … then the prime minister, I’m sure, will be safe in his position. If we don’t do well, obviously people will start to intensify talk of a replacement. But if we’re in that situation [in] May, I think anybody who has been seen as being part of the problem in the eyes of the public would struggle to make a clean break. So, when you look at the names of current MPs [in] the cabinet or [who have] been in the cabinet recently, they haven’t got that distance from the prime minister.”

Allies of Burnham, a former health secretary, are understood to have canvassed support from members of the Socialist Campaign Group of Labour MPs, which includes Burgon, Diane Abbott and John McDonnell. Clive Lewis, who offered last month to give up his Norwich South seat to Burnham, is also a member of the group.

One Labour MP said Burnham’s supporters had gone so far as to suggest that the socialist group had been promised at least one minister in his cabinet.

Burnham’s allies have also approached Angela Rayner, the former deputy prime minister; some MPs would like her to make a pact with Burnham to avoid splitting the left.

The prospect of Burnham’s return to Westminster has prompted speculation among MPs that other possible leadership challengers, including Wes Streeting, the health secretary, could force a contest before May, when the Scottish and Welsh parliaments and some English councils hold elections. A senior Labour MP said: “If you are, Wes, what are you waiting for? The path to power is only going to get more crowded and MPs are getting increasingly worried about what’s going to happen in May. Changing the leader before then might at least save a few seats.”

Another senior Labour figure said: “No 10 is completely stuck. There is complete inertia. Something needs to happen in the new year to force change or there will be anarchy.”
A third said allies of Streeting had been urging MPs to “turn up the heat” on Starmer in recent weeks. In an interview with the New Statesman, published last week, Streeting said the government was failing to communicate its achievements and was presenting itself as the “maintenance department for the country”.

Richard Burgon, Angela Rayner, Rosena Allin-Khan, Dawn Butler, and Ian Murray walking together at the deputy Labour leadership husting.

Richard Burgon appears to back Burnham, whose supporters hope to avoid a left-wing challenge from Angela Rayner, right

DANNY LAWSON/PA

He added: “The problem with that kind of practical, technocratic approach is that if someone else comes along and says, ‘Well, I’ve got a maintenance company too, and mine’s cheaper’, why wouldn’t people go, ‘OK, well, we’ll give that maintenance team a try’?”

Burnham’s route back to Westminster would require Labour’s ruling national executive committee (NEC) to approve his seat selection. It has previously been claimed that Burnham was given assurances that the NEC would not block him — but it has also been reported that Morgan McSweeney, the prime minister’s chief of staff, would stop him getting onto any shortlist.

• Anthony Seldon: It’s not over but Keir Starmer’s had worst start as PM in 70 years

Triggering a leadership contest would require the support of at least 80 Labour MPs.

Burnham did not respond to requests for comment.