5 Brodie Retallick
A rare blend of size, skill and intelligence propelled Brodie Retallick into the All Blacks’ engine room almost instantly after his 2012 debut. His early success with the Chiefs, including back-to-back Super Rugby titles, set the tone for a career defined by excellence. Retallick passed 100 caps for New Zealand, anchoring their 2015 World Cup victory and consistently delivering world-class performances.
A 2014 World Player of the Year award—earned as the youngest ever—validated his global impact. Comparisons to the legendary Colin Meads became common as he redefined expectations of a modern lock: mobile, skilful and relentless. Even while playing in Japan later in his career, his place among the greats was already secure.
4 Nathan Sharpe
Steady leadership and relentless consistency made Nathan Sharpe the Wallabies’ cornerstone for more than a decade. Starting at the Reds before becoming the inaugural captain of the Western Force, he helped shape rugby’s expansion in Australia. Sharpe’s 116 Tests included 20 as captain, and he was twice awarded the John Eales Medal for his impact and reliability.
Known particularly for his line-out mastery, he remained central to Australia’s plans even when injury crises forced him to postpone retirement and lead the side through 2012. His final year was arguably his finest, ending with national player-of-the-year honours. Sharpe’s career stands as a testament to loyalty, durability and understated excellence.
3 Paul O’Connell
Towering standards and uncompromising commitment turned Paul O’Connell into Ireland’s spiritual leader for over a decade. With Munster he became the heartbeat of their European success, while for Ireland he steered the team to three Six Nations titles, including the famous 2009 Grand Slam.
As captain of Munster, Ireland and the Lions, he inspired through clarity, intensity and presence rather than theatrics. His 108 caps placed him among Ireland’s most-capped players, but it was the intangibles—work ethic, honesty, relentlessness—that cemented his legend. Forced into retirement by injury after the 2015 World Cup, he transitioned into coaching, continuing to shape Ireland’s forward play. O’Connell remains a symbol of Irish pride, resilience and leadership.
2 Victor Matfield
Masterful line-out control and brilliant rugby intelligence made Victor Matfield the architect of South Africa’s forward success. With the Bulls he formed a devastating partnership with Bakkies Botha, translating that dominance onto the international stage. His ability to dismantle opposition set pieces became central to the Springboks’ 2007 World Cup triumph, where he was named Player of the Tournament.
Matfield captained sides that broke significant records, including a historic win over the All Blacks in New Zealand in 2008. Though he initially retired after the 2011 World Cup, he returned to add even more caps to an already remarkable career. Calm, athletic and endlessly influential, Matfield stands among the most complete locks ever to play the game.
1 Martin Johnson
Commanding presence and unrivalled leadership made Martin Johnson the ultimate English lock. Across 16 seasons with Leicester and England, he became the sport’s gold standard for authority and composure. His captaincy defined an era: Grand Slam success, European titles with Leicester and, most memorably, the 2003 Rugby World Cup triumph. Johnson also became the first player to lead the Lions on two tours, reinforcing his reputation as rugby’s respected general.
His 84 caps were marked by brutal physicality and sharp tactical instincts, while at club level he delivered four straight Premiership titles and consecutive European Cups. More than his achievements, it was the aura of control he carried that set him apart. For many, he remains the greatest lock of all time.
Quiz: Name these 10 retro rugby players
From jaw-dropping tries to unforgettable moments (and yes, some questionable haircuts), these players defined a golden era of the game. If their names don’t instantly come to mind, we suggest a quick trip to YouTube to jog your memory. Trust us, it’s worth it.
Ready to test your knowledge? Let’s see if you’ve still got it. Good luck!
More Quizzes:
Like this:
Like Loading…