Amid a theory that Penny Branning could die on EastEnders after a baby twist linked to the flashforward episode, some fans now think it’s a red herring and someone else dies
19:30, 11 Mar 2026Updated 20:39, 11 Mar 2026
A new death theory has been shared about EastEnders by fans, but they don’t think it’s Penny Branning (Image: CREDIT LINE:BBC/Jack Barnes/Kieron McCarron)
A new death theory has been shared about EastEnders by fans, but they don’t think it’s Penny Branning who meets a sad fate.
For months, fans have wondered if Penny will be killed off, after a flashforward teased her being AWOL in January 2027. With Jack Branning seemingly caring for a baby boy named Ethan, fans wondered if the baby was Penny’s and if Jack was carer as Penny had died.
When Penny’s pregnancy was recently confirmed, it sparked concern that their theory was true. So is baby Ethan the future child of Penny, and does her absence in the flashforward episode mean she dies?
Fans are not so sure anymore, instead thinking this is a red herring. They believe someone else will die before January 2027, and that Jack is caring for Ethan while Penny is either off the rails or in hospital.
READ MORE: Emmerdale and Coronation Street tease multiple exits as EastEnders’ Mark exposedREAD MORE: EastEnders fans ‘solve Mark’s true flashforward link to Max’ after car lot spoiler
For months, fans have wondered if Penny will be killed off, but could it be Vinny?(Image: CREDIT LINE:BBC/Jack Barnes/Kieron McCarron)
The new death theory is that Vinny Panesar, the father of Penny’s baby, will end up losing his life as part of the crime plot involving Vinny’s brother Ravi Gulati and Mark Fowler Jr. Will the Brannings get involved too, and might Vinny get caught in the crossfire?
One fan said: “Penny dying is a red herring. We can see that if Penny were to die no way would Vinny leave his child with Jack. But what I can see is Vinny dying, Penny not being able to cope and leaving baby Ethan with Jack.”
Another said: “I have a feeling it’s not Penny that dies, but Vinny. Her support is taken away from her because he is caught in the crossfire between Ravi and the drug lord which was ultimately okayed by Jack.
Amid a theory that Penny Branning could die on EastEnders after a baby twist linked to the flashforward episode, some fans now think it’s a red herring(Image: CREDIT LINE:BBC/Jack Barnes/Kieron McCarron)
“Penny falls into a deep depression leaving Jack to take care of Ethan. I think the downfall of Ravi will really begin when his brother dies and he is excommunicated from the Panesar family for good.
“The final nail will be finding out Max has been sleeping with a pregnant Priya, prompting him to kidnap his children.” A third viewer posted: “They want us to think Penny is gone but it will be a red herring.
Another added: “I personally thought Jack was mostly depressed due to it being the 10th anniversary of Ronnie’s death – him looking at a wedding ring. Plus Lauren’s comment about that specific day being hard for him. I’m not sure he looked as broken as he would be if one of his daughters had recently died (baby Ethan looks to be no more than a couple of months old), and it would also be a bit strange if Max was going ahead with a wedding soon after the death of one of his nieces.”
Get the latest drama from the Dales by joining our Emmerdale WhatsApp group
As drama continues to unfold in the Yorkshire Dales, the Mirror has launched its very own Emmerdale WhatsApp community where you’ll get all the latest breaking news, secrets, and spoilers delivered straight to your phone.
Users must download or already have WhatsApp on their phones to join in. All you have to do to join is click on this link, select ‘Join Chat’ and you’re in! We may also send you stories from other titles across the Reach group.
We will also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose Exit group. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
A final post read: “That’s why I am leaning towards Vinny being dead and Penny being in a coma/recovering in hospital. If she is the sole parent left then it would make sense for Jack as her dad to have temporary custody while she recovers.
“We didn’t see any of the Panesars in the episode so we don’t know if they are grieving, or indeed if they are sharing responsibility for caring for the baby. Vinny could of course also be seriously injured rather than killed off.”
EastEnders airs Mondays to Thursdays at 7:30pm on BBC One and BBC iPlayer. * Follow Mirror Celebs and TV on TikTok , Snapchat , Instagram , Twitter , Facebook , YouTube and Threads .