(Credits: Far Out / Tidal)
Wed 6 August 2025 22:00, UK
It must be a strange thing for an artist to routinely sing songs on stage that were born from one of life’s distant chapters, potentially decades ago.
One minute, you’re Johnny Rotten voicing a generation’s nihilist angst and excoriating the monarchy in the grippingly treasonous ‘God Save the Queen’, the next you’re plain old John Lydon offering contrite condolences upon the death of Queen Elizabeth II, 40-odd years later on Public Image Ltd’s social media.
People should change. Few manage to maintain poster boy status into their 60s, but, for better or worse, the characters popular music stars become can either clash awkwardly with the integrity their work once held, or simply grow and form new dimensions and meanings to whatever life’s thrown at them.
Love songs are the ultimate diary songs, expressions of passion or romance nailed onto a specific time in one’s life. It’s incredible to think that Paul McCartney takes the stage and regularly bellows 1970’s ‘Maybe I’m Amazed’, crafted for his then-wife Linda. Having remarried twice since her death in 1998, perhaps the feeling behind the words sung on those live nights is redirected towards his current partner, Nancy Shevell, or serves as bookmarks in his life, revisited as necessary, as one flips through an old photo album.
The evolving meanings of songs are an inevitability well known to heartland rock stadium-filler Bruce Springsteen. In the run-up to 1987’s Tunnel of Love, Springsteen was caught in a private and creative flux. Having previously dropped the decade’s monster Born in the USA, he decided to put his famed E Street Band on hiatus and sought to cut a more introspective and personal record reflecting the fraught marriage with actor and model Julianne Phillips. While always denying an autobiographical point, the lead single ‘Brilliant Disguise’ has been speculated as shaped by the couple’s dissolving relationship and nagging mistrust creeping in.
Aided by its memorable black-and-white video, ‘Brilliant Disguise’ presents the conflicted thoughts of a man whose faith in the coupling and his partner’s feelings are beginning to ebb. After confronting his girl, the tables begin to turn, and he starts expressing his inauthenticity in their messy relationship.
As his divorce from Philips was finalised, Springsteen had grown smitten with E Street singer Patti Scialfa, eventually marrying in 1991. Burnished in the private turmoil of one romantic chapter in his life, ‘Brilliant Disguise’ took on a new life in the new decade, and he was regularly singing the number with Scialfa, even as recently as in his Broadway residency in 2017.
“I guess it sounds like a song of betrayal,” Springsteen mused on VH1’s Storytellers in 2005. “Who’s that person sleeping next to me? Who am I? Do I know enough about myself to be honest with that person? But a funny thing happens: songs shift their meanings when you sing them, they shift their meanings in time, they shift their meanings with who you sing them with. When you sing this song with someone you love, it turns into something else.”
It would have been understandable to confine ‘Brilliant Disguise’ as a time capsule for a moment in life best left to history, but Springsteen instead steps up to the task of any great songsmith, dissecting his most personal hits and rediscovering new definitions and meanings to fuel the sincerity needed to perform the numbers live for an audience, who have similarly ascribed their own memories and interpretations to his lauded anthems.
Related Topics