Researchers studying South American butterflies and moths have found that the same two genes underpin mimicry coloration across species separated by over 120 million years of evolution. The findings suggest that adaptation may follow more constrained and predictable pathways than previously understood.
A new study has found that distantly related butterfly and moth species from South American have independently arrived at nearly identical wing color patterns by modifying the same two genes repeatedly across deep evolutionary time. Rather than representing a coincidence, the pattern points to fundamental constraints on how organisms can reach certain adaptive outcomes, constraints that have held firm since before the mass extinction that ended the age of dinosaurs.
The research, published April 30 in PLOS Biology and led by scientists at the University of York and the Wellcome Sanger Institute, examined seven butterfly lineages and one day-flying moth species. These species belong to the neotropical “tiger” mimicry ring, a group of more than 100 distantly related species that share warning color patterns signaling toxicity to predators. Mimicry of this kind (where multiple unpalatable species converge on the same appearance) is known as Müllerian mimicry, and it distributes the cost of educating predators across species.
The Same Two Genes, Across 120 Million Years
Using genome-wide association analyses on nearly 285 wild-caught individuals across multiple species, the researchers identified which regions of the genome were most strongly linked to key color pattern differences, specifically, the presence or absence of a yellow forewing band and the extent of black hindwing patterning. In every butterfly species examined, the most significant genetic signals clustered around the same two genes: ivory, a long noncoding RNA involved in pigmentation, and optix, a transcription factor previously linked to color patterning in Heliconius butterflies.
Crucially, the changes driving color variation did not occur within the genes themselves but in regulatory regions, sequences that act as switches controlling when and where a gene is active. According to the paper, the associated variants in multiple species consistently fell within the first intron of ivory, in a narrow genomic window located upstream of a known regulatory element. Despite no clear sequence homology across species, the location of these switches remained strikingly consistent across lineages that diverged up to approximately 28 million years ago.
Geographic ranges of the three tiger sub-mimicry rings and time-calibrated phylogeny of the eight lepidopteran species studied. ©PLOS/Biology
“Investigating seven butterfly lineages and a day-flying moth, we show that evolution can be surprisingly predictable, and that butterflies and moths have been using the exact same genetic tricks repeatedly to achieve similar colour patterns since the age of the dinosaurs,” said Professor Kanchon Dasmahapatra of the University of York’s Department of Biology, a senior author on the study.
A Moth’s Genomic Architecture Mirrors a Butterfly’s
Perhaps the most unexpected finding involved the day-flying moth Chetone histrio, which is separated from the butterflies in the study by roughly 120 million years of evolutionary history. Where the butterfly species showed narrow clusters of associated genetic variants near ivory, the moth displayed a broad, approximately one-megabase block of DNA in near-perfect association with its color pattern differences. That block turned out to be a chromosomal inversion (a large segment of DNA flipped into reverse orientation) that includes ivory alongside several flanking genes.
This architecture closely mirrors a supergene arrangement found in Heliconius numata, a butterfly that also uses a chromosomal inversion near ivory to maintain discrete mimetic forms. According to the study, one of the Chetone inversion breakpoints matches the location of the H. numata inversion with considerable precision, and the dominance relationships of the inversion haplotypes are similar in both species.
GWA mapping of three optix cis-regulatory modules and functional validation via CRISPR knockout and ivory expression profiling in Mechanitis messenoides. ©PLOS/Biology
The researchers also found limited evidence that the shared color patterns arose through hybridization between species, a mechanism known to drive mimicry convergence among closely related Heliconius species. Instead, the data point toward independent mutations arising repeatedly in the same genomic regions.
Professor Joana Meier of the Wellcome Sanger Institute noted that the highly conserved genetic basis may itself explain why so many species have managed to join the mimicry ring. “It seems quite easy to evolve these same colour patterns due to the highly conserved genetic basis over 120 million years,” she said. The authors suggest that these recurring pathways may also help scientists anticipate how species respond to environmental pressures, including those posed by climate change.