When Maiko started swiping on Tinder, she wasn’t sure what she was looking for, but in Kenji she quickly found the ideal man. At 30, he was a few years younger than her and he had an impressive job at one of Japan’s most famous advertising agencies. There was a dorky, unpolished quality about him that she found appealing and once their romance began he was a devoted boyfriend.
He routinely travelled two hours from his home to see Maiko in her own town, south of Tokyo. They frequently went for weekends and minibreaks in hot spring hotels.
“He was very shy and he seemed not to be used to women,” she says. “He wasn’t cool — he’d get his hair cut at an old-fashioned barber, rather than a smart hair salon. I trusted him and I felt safe.”
That was until one day, four months in, he completely cut off contact.
Calls, messages and emails were all blocked overnight. Maiko feared that he had suffered some sudden illness or accident. Not knowing his exact address, she hired a private detective to find him, and soon received the devastating news that Kenji was alive and well, and living in the family home with his wife and two young children.
It is a sadly familiar story of deception and abandonment, played out countless times across the world and throughout history. The difference is that in Japan, women like Maiko have the law on their side.
Rather than simply nursing her broken heart, she hired lawyers and sued Kenji under a Japanese civil law that protects “the right of chastity”. She successfully argued that if she had known his marital status, she would never have slept with him, and that by concealing it he violated her right to “sexual self-determination”.
Having won ¥1.5 million (£7,000) in compensation last December, she has formed an organisation, the Association for the Victims of Bachelor Pretence, which has 50 members and which helps women who have been similarly betrayed. A petition calling for lying about being married to be made a criminal, rather than just a civil offence, already has 39,000 signatures.
“Fundamentally I believe this issue shares many characteristics with date rape,” says Maiko, whose real name has been changed, as has that of her former boyfriend. “It should not merely be viewed as a violation of ‘chastity rights’, but rather as a violation of sexual autonomy and informed sexual consent.”
Japanese civil law passes judgment on personal relationships in ways that would be unthinkable in most modern western societies. It is not uncommon, for example, for a betrayed spouse to win legal damages not only from their cheating wife or husband, but from the lover with whom the adultery has been perpetrated.
It was this that made Maiko so angry — that Kenji had put her in the position of a home wrecker, potentially vulnerable to legal action by a wife she never knew existed. Despite its international reputation as a tool for casual hook-ups, Tinder’s Japanese homepage says that people who are “not single” cannot use it. There is no obvious effort to enforce this, but Maiko — who had been though one divorce and recently been treated for cancer — clearly said on her profile that she had no interest in married men.
After discovering his deception in November 2023, she wrote to Kenji asking for an apology and compensation. He responded through a lawyer, insisting that it had been no more than a physical relationship, and offered ¥200,000 (£940) as “settlement money”.
“Even then I still believed he was a man of serious character, but his response damaged me again, twice as much,” she says. “Over those four months, we had sex 229 times, which is quite a lot. I had to be treated for a sexually transmitted infection disease myself.”
When the judge, and Maiko’s own lawyer, later encouraged her to settle for ¥2 million (£9,400) she refused. “What I wanted was not the compensation money but the court judgment.”
Late last year, as the case was drawing to a close, she cross-examined Kenji in the Tokyo district court. The hearing had to be moved to a larger court room to accommodate the number of spectators. She was struck by how gaunt he looked — he has since resigned from his job after it emerged that he had sex with Maiko during his company’s working hours.
As she confronted him with the blandishments he had lavished on her during their romance, he failed to look her in the eye. “He could not really answer, but sometimes he was silent for two or three minutes. Then he said that after nine years from his marriage, he wanted to have a ‘make-believe romance’. I asked, ‘Do you think it was make believe for me?’ He didn’t answer.”