4. Carlos Spencer
Few players have ever possessed more natural talent than Carlos Spencer.
His outrageous offloads, no-look passes and moments of magic made him a fan favourite across the rugby world. However, Spencer’s reputation often seems to be built as much on highlights as achievements.
Despite his brilliance, he never fully cemented himself as New Zealand’s long-term first-choice fly-half and won just 35 Test caps.
Quirky fact: Spencer became the first player to score 100 points in Super Rugby history.
3. Beauden Barrett
This is where the debate really begins.
A two-time World Rugby Player of the Year and one of the finest attacking players rugby has ever seen, Barrett’s place among New Zealand’s greats is secure.
However, some supporters rank him alongside Dan Carter as one of the greatest fly-halves ever. While Barrett was devastating with ball in hand, many would argue he was never as complete a game manager or tactical controller as Carter.
Quirky fact: Barrett is one of four brothers to play professional rugby, alongside Scott, Jordie and Kane.