A patient on the Isle of Man says they have been “robbed of their recovery”, after travelling from the island for major surgery – only to be left with “no post-operative care”.
‘Samantha’, not her real name, said her experience after surgery was “terrifying”, and has “completely knocked her confidence” in Manx Care.
Speaking anonymously to ITV News, she also explained how since the surgery – which was undertaken in Liverpool – more than a hundred other people have privately shared their own experiences with her, but are “terrified of speaking out for fear of what it will do to their future care”.
With one saying: “I would rather die in my chair, than to go to Noble’s Hospital.”
‘Samantha’, not her real name, spoke anonymously to ITV News. Credit: ITV Granada Reports
Samantha went to Noble’s Hospital with a swollen abdomen, where doctors identified what they believed to be cancer, requiring major surgery.
An operation of this kind is not available on the island, so Samantha travelled to Liverpool, under the island’s health agreement with the UK to carry out certain practices across the water.
Following the surgery Samantha then travelled back to the island just six days after the operation, where she was told by doctors in Liverpool that she would receive post-op support.
However instead, she says she was left 11 days in her bed at home waiting for care that never came.
“I tried to get help… but I was just passed to pillar to post,” she said.
“Emailing and calling every single day, with no answers, until I could actually smell my wound. And out of desperation, I broke my medical driving restrictions, just to get to a doctor, and finally he sent a nurse to come and see me.
“But my wound had gone uncleaned for two weeks. I feel like all this fighting just for basic care has robbed me of my recovery.”
Noble’s Hospital is the island’s main hospital, situated on the outskirts of Douglas. Credit: ITV Granada Reports
After sharing her own experience, Samantha has spoken with more than a hundred other people, who also feel aggrieved by the island’s healthcare service.
“There is a deep systemic problem, and people are terrified to speak out. They’re terrified of speaking out for fear of what it will do to their future care,” she said.
“I’ve spoken to people who have said to me, and it broke my heart, I would rather die in my chair, than to go to Noble’s Hospital… that is terrifying.”
Samantha said she has also been contacted by people working within the island’s healthcare service, adding “they are in fear of speaking out too, because of their careers”.
ITV Granada Reports has been contacted by more than 40 different people on the island, sharing similar experiences of healthcare at the hospital.
Noble’s Hospital sent Samantha for surgery in Liverpool under Manx Care’s agreement with the UK. Credit: ITV Granada Reports
Samantha has made previous formal complaints about her care through the Health and Social Care Ombudsman Body (HSCOB), an body set up to review unresolved complaints regarding healthcare.
They concluded Manx Care’s response to Samantha’s complaint was “fair and reasonable”, something Samantha disagrees with, arguing the current healthcare model “lacks independent, caring oversight”, claiming health bosses are “marking their own homework”.
She said: “The complaints system is so difficult that people give up. They feel like they can’t carry on. They’re totally consumed by it all.
“Some of the people I have spoken to are sadly no longer here. It just made me realise this is is bigger than what I thought. There are so many people that can’t get through the complaints system.
“If you complain about a doctor, you end up being refused care… it’s happened to me. We go down the complaints route and it’s a dead end.
“We get sent from one department to another department, and before you know it, years have gone by and you still haven’t got anywhere.
“And I think it leaves people feeling invisible, like they don’t matter. Patients need somewhere safe to turn, and staff must be able to raise concerns without fear.
“When people running the system pretend the problem doesn’t exist, it leaves patients and staff feeling invisible. It feels like we’re being gaslit by the very institution meant to care for us.
“I think we need transparency, and my question is always, who guards the guards?”
While the Care Quality Commission (CQC) has carried out reviews into healthcare on the Isle of Man, it has no enforcement powers on the island.
Instead, the island has a Health and Social Care Ombudsman Body (HSCOB), set up to review unresolved complaints made about health and social care services.
As well as the Manx Care Advice and Liaison Service (MCALS), which is a support, guidance and feedback service.
Manx Care is the public sector body responsible for delivering integrated health and social care services on the island. Credit: ITV Granada Reports
Referring to her own experience, Samantha added: “Look, everybody makes mistakes, we’re human. But just for them to have some accountability, to hold our hands up, you know, we’ve got it wrong.
“Let’s see how we can make this health care better. Let’s be a shining example. Let’s show the rest of the world how to do it. And that’s what it should be”.
Responding to the allegations, a spokesperson from Manx Care said: “We want everyone who uses Manx Care’s services to feel listened to, respected and confident in the care they receive.
“While over nine in 10 instances of patient feedback describe a positive or very positive experience, we recognise that this is not everyone’s experience.
“Feedback from patients is vital to identify barriers, improve services and ensure people feel heard and taken seriously.
“Concerns can be raised through the Manx Care Advice and Liaison Service (MCALS), Meet the Matrons or our formal complaints process.
“MCALS provides confidential support to help people raise concerns, seek resolution or make a formal complaint.
“We appreciate that travelling off-Island for treatment can make a patient’s care journey more complex, particularly around discharge, follow-up care and communication.
“Patients should not feel they have to navigate these arrangements alone. Manx Care is committed to working with NHS partners to address gaps in pathways and improve patients’ experiences.
“Although we cannot comment publicly on individual cases due to patient confidentiality, we encourage anyone with concerns to contact us directly so we can understand their experience and respond appropriately.
“Listening to patients, families and carers is central to improving our services. No one should feel afraid to speak up, and raising a concern or complaint will not adversely affect the care or treatment they receive.”
Want more on the issues affecting the North? Our podcast, From the North answers the questions that matter to our region.