But Plymouth City Council says new crackdown order has made ‘a huge difference’

The old Toys R Us car park is where the commotion took place(Image: Scarlett Hills-Brooks/Plymouth Live)

NHS staff working at Plymouth City Centre’s new community diagnostic centre (CDC) are feeling unsafe using the Western Approach Car Park on late shifts due to ongoing anti-social behaviour, claims a business leader.

Ray Robins, chair of the Plymouth Market Traders Association in the West End of town where the new CDC is situated, says the car park is still a hot spot for ASB despite Plymouth City Council introducing a public spaces protection order (PSPO) a year ago designed to stop this behaviour.

He says he has also received complaints from workers and traders of drug taking and people blocking up the stairwells.

The PSPO was made for Western Approach, and eight other car parks, following reports of gatherings of people loitering, motorbikes racing and revving engines, stairwells being used as toilets and drug and alcohol use.

Plymouth City Council says the order HAS made a difference and considerable efforts had been made to improve Western Approach Car Park.

The NHS has paid for 50 places on level 4 of the car park across the main road from the CDC for staff to use with daily permit tariffs matching the £2.50 and £3.50 per day charged at Derriford Hospital.

This avoids staff paying the £6.50 daily charge rate.

Western Approach Car Park

Western Approach Car Park(Image: Alison Stephenson)

But Mr Robins said he was aware of staff concerns around using the car park especially since the clocks had gone back.

“Winter is approaching and there is still ASB in there and drug taking. Nurses and healthcare staff are not happy walking through there to their cars when they leave their shifts at 8pm. They don’t feel safe.

“It’s a bone of contention that needs sorting out.”

Mr Robins is suggesting that part of the ground floor former Toy R Us car park which is much more open and on street level be given over to NHS parking. He has called for a meeting between all parties to discuss it.

The £22 million CDC opened in June promising more than 91,000 tests and scans every year and addressing health inequalities in the city. Around 130 people work at the site.

A second facility is due to be built next door.

Don’t let an algorithm decide what Plymouth news you see – click here to add The Herald as your preferred Google source.

Car parking facilities for staff and patients has been a general concern as the building is a car free development.

Plymouth City Council said: “We are sorry that some staff members are still feeling unsafe as considerable efforts have been made to improve this car park to make users feel more comfortable.

“While it is true this car park had been blighted by anti-social behaviour in the past, the public space protection order that came into effect last November has made a huge difference to this car park and its users.”

The council said its parking manager was arranging to meet with senior staff at the CDC to discuss any specific issues that their staff had so they could be addressed where possible.

“Clear signs are up and continuous messaging over the car park’s PA system is a reminder that the car park is covered by the order,” it added. “This allows the police and PARC (Plymouth Against Retail Crime) officers to respond swiftly to calls from the public about gatherings of young people in the car park as well as carry out spot checks. There is also CCTV.

“Where officers encounter people who sleep rough, they work with our outreach teams to offer support and encourage them to move elsewhere.”

Ahead of the CDC opening, level 4 was refurbished and made more welcoming, with a separate entrance available for NHS staff, said the council

“There are no plans to relocate the ground floor for NHS workers as the majority of spaces are allocated to people with disabilities and parents.”

A spokesperson for the University Hospitals Plymouth NHS Trust said: “The safety and wellbeing of our staff and patients is extremely important to us.

“We have security staff based at the Plymouth Community Diagnostic Centre (PCDC) 24 hours a day and are working closely with colleagues and local policing teams to address any reports of anti-social behaviour.

“We encourage any incidents to be reported to the police via 101 and to the centre management team so appropriate action can be taken.”

Sign up to The Herald Premium here.