The question \u201cwhat present do you recommend for \u2026\u201d will be tapped into phones and computers countless times over this festive period, as more people turn to AI platforms to help choose gifts for loved ones.<\/p>\n
With a quarter of Britons using AI to find products, brands are increasingly adapting their strategies to ensure their products are the ones recommended, especially those trying to reach younger audiences.<\/p>\n
But can AI offer thoughtful, personal suggestions for friends and family? The Guardian put the idea to the test.<\/p>\n
First we tried asking for possible gifts for a middle-aged man who enjoys running and photography. The market-leading chatbot ChatGPT suggested: a Canon lens for \u00a3129 from Argos; a Koospur tennis racket sensor tracker for \u00a371.72 on Amazon; and a Boondocker recycled camera bag for \u00a334.98. The AI platform insisted the \u201cideal present\u201d would be the camera bag, plus maybe the tennis sensor tracker. It also threw in experience ideas such as tennis coaching, whisky tasting or live music.<\/p>\n
When asked to work with a more restricted budget it suggested tennis racket-emblazoned socks for \u00a318, which were ugly and definitely not worth the high price tag.<\/p>\n
The answers skewed heavily towards big online retailers, with seven of the nine initial suggestions from Amazon. Asking for ideas from more niche companies led to a minimalist tennis court print for \u00a330 from a website called the Smart Party Shop <\/a>and vague advice to buy from \u201cEtsy or Not On the High Street-type sellers\u201d.<\/p>\n Searching for a woman who likes beauty products, DIY and fitness again produced some middle-of-the-road suggestions. However, with a nudge for more cult picks it steered towards a \u00a317.50 Odylique rose moisturiser gift set, which it described as \u201cluxurious but not mainstream\u201d. It also put forward a \u00a330 Floris sandalwood and patchouli-scented candle, which it claimed was \u201cmore personal than just another lipstick\u201d.<\/p>\n When asked to recommend DIY tools, it suggested a small, pink kit with some rather useless-looking pliers, rather than the usual all-purpose devices such as drills, sanders and staple guns \u2013 a sign that the longstanding complaint that AI reinforces gender stereotypes<\/a> remains.<\/p>\n