

The Los Angeles Dodgers have already built one of the most talented rosters in baseball, but building a dynasty is more important than pushing all your chips for the three-peat.
With several Dodgers contributors such as Max Muncy, Freddie Freeman, and Miguel Rojas all on the wrong side of 35, the organization should eventually need to lean more into youth and long-term roster sustainability.
Meanwhile, the Oakland Athletics remain locked in a prolonged rebuilding stretch after finishing near the bottom of the league in four straight seasons. The franchise has assembled an intriguing foundation of young talent, but adding a proven superstar might be a must.
The Oakland Athletics have two potential superstars in Nick Kurtz and Max Muncy who the Dodgers should be chomping at the bit to try adding.
*PREDICTION*
Related MLB Content from TWSN:
Why Athletics have a STAR in Max Muncy
Top-3 MLB World Series Contenders
Dodgers receive: 3B/SS Max Muncy, 1B Nick Kurtz
Athletics receive: 1B Freddie Freeman, SS prospect Emil Morales
Freeman has become a beloved figure in Los Angeles, especially after earning World Series MVP honors in 2024, but even elite organizations must occasionally make difficult forward-thinking decisions.
Freeman still has two seasons left on his contract, yet at age 35, he isn’t likely to remain the team’s long-term answer at first base. In this scenario, the Dodgers would transition to 23-year-old Nick Kurtz, a young slugger with the upside to anchor the position for years to come.
The key question with any Freeman trade is value in return, and a package centered around Muncy and Kurtz would be wild. Both are just 22 years old and former first-round selections (Kurtz at No. 4 overall and Muncy at No. 25), giving Los Angeles two controllable, high-ceiling position players.
Third base has recently been a patchwork spot for the Dodgers, with veteran Max Muncy and Miguel Rojas both 35+, youth will at some point be needed.
The younger Muncy (from the Athletics) offers defensive versatility across third base, shortstop, and second while flashing pop at the plate, making him an immediate lineup option and a long-term developmental piece. His Southern California roots, growing up near Dodger Stadium, only adds to this.
Kurtz, meanwhile, profiles as a potential middle-of-the-order first baseman at 6’5’’ with major league-ready power finishing 10th in the MLB in Home Runs.
Freddie Freeman Would Fix the Athletics
From Oakland’s perspective, moving two cornerstone prospects would be painful, but the franchise has also been criticized for lacking ambition and stability.
Even at 35, Freeman remains one of baseball’s most productive hitters, carrying one of the league’s highest batting averages for much of the season and immediately slotting in as one of Oakland’s best offensive players alongside breakout star Jared Wilson.
Pairing Freeman with Wilson, Brent Rooker, and Tyler Soderstrom could give the Athletics a legitimate offensive core for the next few seasons.
In the end, both teams would be taking a risk, and shockingly the Athletics would likely be the team that would turn down this proposal, and while the Dodgers fans would be pissed parting ways with Freeman, this proposal would undoubtedly yield them two young superstars.