Editor’s note: Comstock’s welcomes opinion pieces from a
variety of perspectives. To submit a piece for consideration,
please email Digital Editor Jennifer Fergesen at jfergesen@comstocksmag.com.

Homelessness is a growing problem
in Sacramento and other cities around the country. According to
the nonprofit Sacramento Steps Forward’s State of Homelessness
dashboard,
over 9,000 people

engaged with Sacramento County
homeless services in December 2025, an increase of nearly 900
compared to the previous month. (The nonprofit also conducts the
point-in-time count of homeless people in Sacramento County,
which reported that the county’s homeless population had
decreased by
29 percent between 2022 and 2024
to a count of 6,615, leading to funding cuts
and raising questions about their methods.)

Homelessness degrades those who
experience it and degrades the communities in which there are
homeless. The homeless include more than people living in camps,
along the American River Parkway and in neighborhoods and near
businesses. It also includes the less visible people who move
from one friend’s coach or garage or basement to another. It is
people who live in their cars. It is men, women, children and
people of every age. It is veterans, it is family members and
neighbors. It is caused by poverty, by mental illness, by drug
addiction, unemployment, high housing costs and poor public
policy.

The federal government, state
government and city and county government have spent large sums
of money, and it has never been enough to end or significantly
reduce homelessness. The number of homeless continues to grow
faster than the available housing. The policy of “housing first”
is a theory that the best way to address homelessness is to first
house the homeless and then to assess what needs to be done;
whether it is mental health treatment, addiction treatment, job
training or long term institutional care for those who cannot be
rehabilitated. Housing first provides the chronically homeless
people long-term subsidized housing and offers, but does not
require, treatment for mental illness or addiction. It contrasts
with programs that condition help on sobriety or work, which the
new administration officials want to encourage though there is
less direct research to suggest their efficacy.

Related: California
Counties Must Jump Through New Hoops to Get Homelessness
Funds

If housing first is a valid
theory of change that addresses homelessness, the test is: does
it result in a return to independence or at least minimal public
assistance; does it address mental health problems; does it
address addiction; does it restore the health of the homeless;
and does it result in long term success?

The short answer is that housing
first does one thing well: It stabilizes those that are housed.
But only a low percentage return to independence, and there are
not enough long-term studies to see how long those that become
independent remain independent. The big problems with housing
first are that it is expensive; there is not enough shelter or
housing space; and there is not enough program support for mental
health, addiction and job training. Therefore, the homeless
problem is growing. Housing first is less effective at providing
rehabilitation services, and without long term oversight there is
no assurance that there is a long-term success rate.

Many of the programs that rely on
government funding are run by nonprofits. Here in Sacramento, the
Salvation Army operates the Center of Hope Shelter for about 130
men and women, the Next Step program for about 70 men and the E.
Claire Raley Transitional Living Center for about 30 families.
The Salvation Army Pathway of Hope program includes housing and
case worker support to lead the homeless on a pathway to
independence. It addresses addiction, mental health issues,
joblessness and the despair that comes with homelessness.

Salvation Army’s Pathway to Hope
program has been part of empirical studies and it is proven to
work. But the resources available for the Salvation Army program
or any program that is based on housing the homeless do not come
close to meeting the needs of the homeless.

What is needed is an approach
that recognizes that the homeless need to be in a caseworker
supported program that offers stability and the resources to
address their needs and create pathway to independence for those
who can achieve independence and a pathway to long-term care and
support for those who cannot live independently due to either
age, mental illness, disability or other factors.

Related:
Perspective: The Ever-Growing Sacramento Homeless Crisis

In Sacramento, we need to
recognize that the homeless population has outgrown our capacity
to house and shelter them. We need a plan to stabilize them, even
though we do not have permanent housing or shelter space, so that
we can begin the process that leads to long-term solutions — and
we need to clear out the homeless encampments that degrade the
homeless and our community.

A four-stage program seems a good
solution compared to our current plan, which is not solving a
growing homelessness problem.

Stage one is to create
managed camps in designated areas that have around-the-clock
supervision and management; garbage pickup, toilets, showers,
clean water and food service; and programs to begin to
address addiction, mental health and job training and
placement. This step allows us to house more homeless at a
lower cost than current solutions while creating a cleaner,
safer, and more secure and stable environment for the
homeless than the current camps. These camps can be ramped up
or down as need changes. Similar camps are used to house
those displaced by war or disaster. Of course, the “not in my
backyard” problem will make placing these camps
difficult.

Stage two is to begin ramping
up drug addiction, mental health and job training programs to
support transitioning all the homeless to independence, for
those who can make that transition.

Stage three is to create
transitional housing either through subsidizing local
apartments by providing vouchers or building or buying
existing multi-family housing units. Most of those who are
moving to independence will need up to two years of
transitional housing or subsidized housing. During the
transitional period, case worker support will be
needed.

Stage four is to create
long-term housing with case worker support for those who
cannot live independently due to mental illness, drug
addiction, disability, old age or other factors. In
particular, the available mental health care facilities are
far short of what we need. When the state mental hospitals
were closed, we failed to build a replacement network of care
facilities.

This plan addresses the need for
a more robust mental health care system, a more robust drug
addiction treatment system and a long-term care solution for
those who are not able to live independently and currently
continually return to homelessness, crowd our emergency rooms and
create problems for police, residents and businesses. It also has
the advantage of putting in place lower-cost, temporary housing
to move more homeless people into caseworker-supervised programs
at a faster pace than other solutions, and it can flex with the
need for sheltering and rehabilitating the homeless.

Henry Wirz is the former CEO of SAFE Credit Union and a
volunteer with organizations including the UC Davis Foundation
and the Sacramento Regional Community Foundation.

–

Stay up to date on business in the Capital Region:
Subscribe to the Comstock’s newsletter
today.