With voting underway, seven candidates spar in a heated CNN debate marked by sharp divides on immigration, Trump, and attacks targeting Xavier Becerra.
SACRAMENTO, Calif. — With ballots already mailed and some votes cast, candidates in California’s governor’s race are running out of time to make their final pitch to voters ahead of the June 2 primary election.
Seven leading candidates, two Republicans and five Democrats, took to the debate stage Tuesday night in a two-hour televised program by CNN.
Democratic candidate Tony Thurmond was not invited to the debate because he did not meet the polling threshold.
The debate quickly centered on Democratic candidate Xavier Becerra, whose support has surged following Eric Swalwell’s exit from the race.
Candidates were asked to rate Governor Gavin Newsom’s time in office, revealing a split in tone between parties. Democrats offered words like “bold” and “progressive,” while the Republicans responded with “failed” and “failure.”
That divide carried into policy discussions, including immigration.
“We should abolish ICE. They’re deliberately breaking the law,” Democrat Tom Steyer said.
“No one’s broken the law in California,” Republican Chad Bianco said, in stark contrast.
Tensions escalated during an exchange between Katie Porter and Steve Hilton after Porter said immigrants contribute significantly to the economy.
“Given that you’re an immigrant, and you added to our population, and we’re all having to live with the consequences of that decision,” Porter said, to a Hilton who countered, “Katie, I think there’s a difference you’ll accept between legal and illegal immigration.”
Divisions also emerged over former President Donald Trump, who has endorsed Hilton.
“The fact is all you do is point at Democrats and scream at Democrats and don’t have anything else to say,” Democrat Antonio Villaraigosa said, critiquing the repeated points by both Republicans.
“Well, you have been in charge for 16 years, Antonio,” Hilton responded, while emphasizing his continued point that there must be a party change in leadership in California.
“I’m going to repeat Donald Trump as often as I have to because he’s the real menace we have in California,” Becerra said on that point.
“You’ve got nothing else to say,” Hilton replied.
Candidates were also asked how they would work with the federal government under Trump.
“If he’s going to attack California, yeah, F him,” Porter said.
“[I will] work with the president regardless of party,” Hilton, who has been endorsed by the president, said.
“That’s why I had to go toe-to-toe with him in court over 120 times,” Becerra said, referring to his lawsuits against the first Trump Administration during his time as California Attorney General.
“The best resistance is delivering results,” Democrat Matt Mahan, who has been maintaining a more moderate line in the race, said.

“You’re not going to hear one word from me about President Trump, President Biden, or anything else, because I’m going to be the only governor on this stage that will be governor of California for Californians,” Bianco said.
“I’ve been in enough board rooms to know a crook when I see one, and he is a crook,” Steyer said.
“But I can also challenge Donald Trump,” Villaraigosa said.
Porter also pushed back on criticism of her temperament, following controversies regarding her treatment of a reporter and a staffer during several tense moments.
“Boys, boys, enough with the bickering,” Porter interrupted at one point. She continued, “I can’t believe that one stage with 30 minutes of interrupting, and bickering, and name calling, and shouting, and disrespect for everyone up here who’s stepping into public service, that anyone wants to talk about my temperament.”
Bianco faced scrutiny over his past affiliation with the extremist Oath Keepers group. When pressed by moderators, he clarified he was referring to taking an oath as a sworn law enforcement officer, though he did defend the group.
ABC10 reached out to the Bianco for Governor campaign for clarification but did not hear back as of late Tuesday night.
“You know, you’re an oath keeper, we all know that,” Villaraigosa said, in an attack on Bianco.
“And I’m very proud of it,” Bianco said.
“I don’t think an oath keeper is qualified to be governor of California,” Villaraigosa said in response.
“I don’t think you know what an oath keeper is,” Bianco said.
Asked whether he still considers himself a member, Bianco said, “No.”
Much of the criticism throughout the debate — from both parties — was directed at Becerra.
“Being in bed with oil companies is a mistake. Xavier Becerra has taken the max amount of money from Chevron,” Steyer said.
“It’s a rich response coming from a guy who made his billions investing in fossil fuels and oil companies,” Becerra responded.
Becerra, in his counterargument, points to controversies over Steyer’s past investments in fossil fuels and oil companies, which Steyer has admitted to and said he ended more than a decade ago.
Becerra was also attacked by both Hilton and Villaraigosa for being brought up in the federal indictment of Governor Newsom’s former chief of staff, who had funds from a dormant Becerra campaign account siphoned to some of his closest allies. Becerra has not been accused of wrongdoing.
“He may not have been indicted at this point, but he has to be under suspicion because it doesn’t pass the smell test,” Villaraigosa remarked.
“If I had been involved, the U.S. Attorney General would have had me in that indictment,” Becerra countered.
Candidates also took on Becerra for recently surfaced critiques regarding his shifting stance on single-payer healthcare in California.
While he has clearly stated his support for a single-public-agency-run healthcare system, Becerra has recently taken a more cautious approach, per multiple reports.
That lack of clarity was evident on the debate stage as fellow candidates pressed Becerra multiple times for a yes or no.
To which, Becerra responded more broadly that all Californians, including undocumented immigrants, deserve access to care and that he would support Medicare for all.
ABC10: Watch, Download, Read












1
/
12