California just gave plastic producers until 2032 to make all their packaging recyclable or compostable — the most ambitious deadline in the country. Advocates say it doesn’t go far enough. Producers say it goes too far. At least one of them is threatening to sue.
The sweeping regulations, finalized at the start of the month, put producers in a bind that has no obvious solution. Plastic clamshell containers, for instance, protect berries from being crushed and keep them fresher, longer until they reach a refrigerator. Plastic producers say there’s simply no substitute — yet under the new rules, they’ll have to find one.
kAm{2DE H66<[ EH@ 6?G:C@?>6?E2= 8C@FAD — E96 }2EFC2= #6D@FC46D s676?D6 r@F?4:= 2?5 r2=:7@C?:2?D p82:?DE (2DE6 — D2:5 E96J A=2? E@ E2<6 r2=:7@C?:2 E@ 4@FCE] %96:C 2C8F>6?Ei E96 DE2E6’D CF=6D 24EF2==J 3C62< E96 =2H 3J 2==@H:?8 C64J4=:?8 >6E9@5D E92E 4C62E6 2 =@E @7 E@I:4 H2DE6[ 2?5 3J =6EE:?8 D@>6 A=2DE:4D D=:A E9C@F89 E96 CF=6D 6?E:C6=J] ~? E96 @E96C D:56[ A=2DE:4 >2?F724EFC6CD D2J E96 CF=6D 8@ E@@ 72C 2?5 H:== >2<6 AC@5F4ED >@C6 6IA6?D:G6 7@C D9@AA6CD]k^Am
kAm$6?] q6? p==6?[ 2 s6>@4C2E 7C@> 4@2DE2= {@D p?86=6D r@F?EJ H9@ 2FE9@C65 E96 A=2DE:4 H2DE6 =2H[ D2:5 E96 AC@8C2> DE:== “>2DD:G6=J >@G6D E96 ?665=6 @? E9:D C62==J >2;@C AC@3=6>” — 6G6? :7 E96 AC@46DD H2D >6DDJ] “%9:D H2D E96 AC@5F4E @7 2 4@>AC@>:D6[ 2?5 :E H2D ?@E A6C764E[ 2?5 6G6CJ3@5J H2=<65 2H2J 7C@> E96 E23=6[ J@F @H[ F?92AAJ 23@FE G2C:@FD 2DA64ED[” p==6? D2:5]k^Am
kAm“r2=:7@C?:2 😀 E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ 3FE b_ J62CD 😕 E96 7FEFC6[” D2:5 y@6 ÁCG2:[ 5:C64E@C @7 E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 $@FE96C? r2=:7@C?:2’D (C:8=6J x?DE:EFE6 7@C t?G:C@?>6?E2= $EF5:6D] “(92E’D 92AA6?:?8 ?@H 😀 6>3=6>2E:4 @7 EC6?5D E92E H6 2C6 D66:?8 H@C=5H:56 … 2?5 E96 &]$] ?665D E@ 252AE 😕 E96 H2J E92E E9@D6 4@F?EC:6D 2C6 252AE:?8 😕 @C56C E@ C6>2:? 8=@32==J 4@>A6E:E:G6]”k^Am
k9am{6DD A=2DE:4[ >@C6 C64J4=:?8k^9am
kAmu@C 564256D[ E96 3FC56? @7 C65F4:?8[ C6FD:?8 2?5 C64J4=:?8 A=2DE:4 H2DE6 92D 72==6? @? 4@?DF>6CD] ~?46 2 4@?DF>6C 3FJD 2 AC@5F4E[ E96J 564:56 H92E 92AA6?D E@ :E — H96E96C :E 6?5D FA 😕 E96 82C3286 42? @C E96 C64J4=:?8 3=F6 3:? — 2?5 E96:C E2I 5@==2CD 7F?5 C64J4=:?8 DJDE6>D H6 92G6 E@52J]k^Am
kAmx? a_aa[ r2=:7@C?:2’D =2?5>2C< k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^42=>2EE6CD]@C8^6?G:C@?>6?E^a_aa^_e^42=:7@C?:2\C64J4=:?8\A=2DE:4\EC2D9^Qm$6?2E6 q:== dc[k^2m E96 !=2DE:4 !@==FE:@? !C6G6?E:@? 2?5 !24<28:?8 !C@5F46C #6DA@?D:3:=:EJ p4E[ D9:7E65 E92E C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ E@ 3FD:?6DD6D] %96 C68F=2E:@?D @FE=:?6 H92E >2E6C:2=D 2C6 4@G6C65 3J E96 =2H 2?5 H9@ 4@F?ED 2D 2 “AC@5F46C” @7 A=2DE:4 H2DE6]k^Am
kAm%96 ?6H C68F=2E:@?D 2C6 2 9F86 >:=6DE@?6[ D2:5 p?;2 qC2?5@?[ 5:C64E@C @7 &]$] A=2DE:4D A@=:4J 7@C E96 ~462? r@?D6CG2?4J] “%96C6’D A=6?EJ >@C6 DE6AD @? E9:D ;@FC?6J[ 3FE x’> ;FDE C62==J 6I4:E65 E92E H6 2C6 8@:?8 E@ DE2CE >2<:?8 C62= AC@8C6DD[” D96 D2:5]k^Am
kAm%96 =2H 2AA=:6D E@ A=2DE:4 7@@5 D6CG:46 H2C6 2?5 2=>@DE 2== D:?8=6\FD6 A24<28:?8 — 7C@> E96 A=2DE:4 HC2A 2C@F?5 =2C86 A2==6ED @7 AC@5F4ED D9:AA65 E@ C6E2:=6CD E@ 2 EF36 @7 E@@E9A2DE6 2?5 E96 42C53@2C5 3@I 2C@F?5 :E]k^Am
k9am~FC 3C@<6? C64J4=:?8 DJDE6>k^9am
kAm|@DE @7 E96 A=2DE:4 A24<28:?8 r2=:7@C?:2?D E9C@H 2H2J :D?’E C64J4=65 — 2?5 E92E’D ?@E J@FC 72F=E 2D 2 4@?DF>6C] u@C 564256D[ E96 C6G@=G:?8 8C66? 2CC@HD DJ>3@= 92D FC865 4@?DF>6CD EA 5@ 2 36EE6C ;@3 @7 C65F4:?8[ C6FD:?8 2?5 C64J4=:?8] qFE E96 DJDE6> :ED6=7 DE2CE65 @FE 3C@<6?[ 2?5 8@E H@CD6]k^Am
kAm(96? A6@A=6 E@DD :E6>D :?E@ C64J4=:?8 3:?D[ H@C<6CD 2E C64J4=:?8 46?E6CD D@CE E9C@F89 E96>] r@?E2>:?2E65 :E6>D — =:<6 2 A62?FE 3FEE6C EF3 H:E9 C6D:5F6 DE:== :?D:56 — 8@ DEC2:89E E@ E96 =2?57:==] |2?F724EFC6CD 3FJ 4=62?[ G2=F23=6 >2E6C:2=D =:<6 H2E6C 3@EE=6D 2?5 56E6C86?E EF3D 2?5 EFC? E96> :?E@ ?6H AC@5F4ED]k^Am
kAmqFE 2 D=6H @7 @E96C EC2D9 :D?’E G2=F23=6 6?@F89 E@ D6==] xE 6?5D FA 😕 =2?57:==D[ E@@]k^Am
kAmx? a_a`[ E96 A=2DE:4 C64J4=:?8 C2E6 H2D @?=J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]36J@?5A=2DE:4D]@C8^AF3=:42E:@?D^FD\A=2DE:4D\C64J4=:?8\C2E6QmeT ?2E:@?H:56[k^2m 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 C6A@CE 3J E96 25G@424J 8C@FA q6J@?5 !=2DE:4D] %92E’D 5@H? 7C@> gT 😕 a_`g[ A2CE=J 3642FD6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^6be_]J2=6]65F^762EFC6D^A:=:?8\FA\9@H\49:?2D\32?\@?\:>A@CE:?8\H2DE6\92D\DE2==65\8=@32=\C64J4=:?8Qmr9:?2k^2m 2?5 @E96C 4@F?EC:6D E92E FD65 E@ 3FJ @FC EC2D9 92G6 DE@AA65 5@:?8 D@] x? r2=:7@C?:2[ >@DE A=2DE:4 A24<28:?8 EJA6D 2C6 C64J4=65 2E DEC:<:?8=J =@H C2E6D[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 a_ad r2=#64J4=6 C6A@CEi tG6? >:=< ;F8D 2?5 56E6C86?E 3@EE=6D[ 2>@?8 E96 >@DE 4@>>@?=J C64J4=65 A=2DE:4D[ C624965 @?=J `hT[ H9:=6 >@DE @E96CD 42>6 😕 2E D:?8=6 5:8:ED @C 36=@H]k^Am
kAm%@ 42CCJ @FE E96 =2H[ E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 #6D@FC46D #64J4=:?8 2?5 #64@G6CJ 2AA@:?E65 E96 r:C4F=2C p4E:@? p==:2?46[ 2 ?@?AC@7:E E92E 96=AD DE2E6D 42CCJ @FE 6IE6?565 AC@5F46C C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ >2?52E6D[ 2D E96 @C82?:K:?8 3@5J 7@C AC@5F46CD] %96 2==:2?46 😀 C6DA@?D:3=6 7@C 4@>:?8 FA H:E9 2 A=2? E@ >66E E96 =2H’D 8@2=D]k^Am
kAm!C@5F46CD — 567:?65 2D 4@>A2?:6D E92E >2<6 >@C6 E92? S` >:==:@? 😕 D2=6D 2?5 AC@5F46 AC@5F4ED A24<2865 😕 A=2DE:4 @C @H? 3C2?5D F?56C H9:49 E9@D6 AC@5F4ED 2C6 D@=5 — >FDE ;@:? E96 @C82?:K2E:@? 2?5 A2J 766D E@ 7F?5 H2DE6 >2?286>6?E] %96J 42? >66E E96 =2H’D C6BF:C6>6?ED 3J FD:?8 =6DD A=2DE:4[ 7:?5:?8 2=E6C?2E:G6 >2E6C:2=D[ @C :?G6DE:?8 😕 C64J4=:?8 :?7C2DECF4EFC6]k^Am
kAm“%96 3:886DE 492==6?86 😀 E96 D42=6 2?5 4@@C5:?2E:@? C6BF:C65 E@ >@56C?:K6 2 4@>A=6I C64J4=:?8 DJDE6> 24C@DD 2 DE2E6 2D =2C86 2?5 5:G6CD6 2D r2=:7@C?:2[” D2:5 $96:=2 tDE2?:6=[ 2 DA@<6DA6CD@? 7@C E96 r:C4F=2C p4E:@? p==:2?46[ 😕 2? 6>2:=]k^Am
kAmr2=:7@C?:2’D C6BF:C6>6?E E92E 3FD:?6DD6D C65F46 D:?8=6\FD6 A=2DE:4 2=E@86E96C >2<6D :E @?6 @7 E96 DEC@?86DE A=2DE:4 H2DE6 =2HD 😕 E96 4@F?ECJ] xE 2=D@ 8@6D 7FCE96C E92? @E96C D:>:=2C =2HD 3642FD6 :E C6BF:C6D A=2DE:4 AC@5F46CD E@ A2J Sd 3:==:@? @G6C 2 564256 E@ 255C6DD E96 6?G:C@?>6?E2= 52>286 E96:C AC@5F4ED 92G6 42FD65 E@ 4@>>F?:E:6D — E9@F89 E96 DE2E6 5@6D?’E 6IA64E E@ DE2CE 5:DEC:3FE:?8 E9@D6 7F?5D F?E:= a_af 2E E96 62C=:6DE]k^Am
k9am(2E6C65 5@H? CF=6Dk^9am
kAm%96 A=2DE:4 H2DE6 CF=6D 92G6 925 2 C@4A=6>6?E2E:@?]k^Am
kAmx? a_ac[ r2=#64J4=6 56G6=@A65 2 7:CDE 5C27E @7 C68F=2E:@?D 56E2:=:?8 H92E A=2DE:4 E96 =2H 4@G6CD 2?5 H92E AC@5F46CD >FDE 5@] %96 5C27E 6IA:C65 367@C6 r2=#64J4=6 7:?2=:K65 :E] x? a_ad[ v@G] v2G:? }6HD@> 5:C64E65 C68F=2E@CD E@ C6HC:E6 E96 CF=6D — 2 >@G6 E92E D@>6 25G@42E6D D2J D2J 7@@5 2?5 28C:4F=EFC6 =@33J:DED AFD965 7@C]k^Am
kAm%96 C6DF=E H2D 2 D64@?5 5C27E E92E 42CG65 @FE 2 3C@25 6I4=FD:@? 7@C A=2DE:4D FD65 7@C 7@@5 2?5 28C:4F=EFC6 AFCA@D6D[ 4@G6C:?8 AC@5F4ED F?56C E96 ;FC:D5:4E:@? @7 E96 usp 2?5 &$sp[ DF49 2D A24<28:?8 7@C 7C6D9 AC@5F46 2?5 DFAA=6>6?ED] p5G@42E6D D2:5 E96 6I4=FD:@? 8FEE65 E96 =2H]k^Am
kAm“v@G6C?@C }6HD@> H2D 4=62C H96? 96 2D<65 r2=#64J4=6 E@ C6DE2CE E96D6 C68F=2E:@?D E92E E96J D9@F=5 H@C< E@ >:?:>:K6 4@DED 7@C D>2== 3FD:?6DD6D 2?5 72>:=:6D — H9:=6 6?DFC:?8 r2=:7@C?:2’D 3@=5 C64J4=:?8 =2H 42? 249:6G6 E96 4C:E:42= 8@2= @7 4FEE:?8 A=2DE:4 A@==FE:@?[” D2:5 p?E9@?J |2CE:?6K[ 2 DA@<6DA6CD@? 7@C E96 8@G6C?@C] “%92E’D 6I24E=J H92E E96D6 5C27E C68F=2E:@?D 5@]”k^Am
kAmr2=#64J4=6 DF3>:EE65 E92E 5C27E E@ E96 ~77:46 @7 p5>:?:DEC2E:G6 {2H 😕 pF8FDE a_ad[ 3FE H:E95C6H :E E@ >2<6 492?86D E92E ?2CC@H65 E92E 6I4=FD:@?] #68F=2E@CD F=E:>2E6=J 6I4=F565 @?=J A=2DE:4 E92E 7656C2= =2H C6BF:C6D 7@C 7@@5 D276EJ — H2=<:?8 324< 2 3C@256C 42CG6\@FE E92E 25G@42E6D D2:5 H@F=5 92G6 8FEE65 E96 =2H]k^Am
k9amp5G@42E6D 862C FA E@ DF6k^9am
kAm}@E 2== A=2DE:4D 7@==@H E96 D2>6 CF=6D — 2?5 25G@42E6D @3;64E E@ E96 DE2E6’D EH@\EC24< DJDE6>]k^Am
kAm$@>6 >2E6C:2=D H:E9 F?:BF6 E649?:42= 492==6?86D 42? 2AA=J 7@C 6I6>AE:@?D[ 3FE >FDE >66E DA64:7:4 4C:E6C:2 E@ BF2=:7J]k^Am
kAm~E96CD[ =:<6 A=2DE:4 E92E 7656C2= =2H C6BF:C6D 7@C 7@@5 D276EJ[ 6D42A6 E96 CF=6D 6?E:C6=J @?46 AC@5F46CD 4@>A=6E6 2? 2AA=:42E:@? E@ r2=#64J4=6 — ?@ E:>6=:?6[ ?@ @3=:82E:@?D]k^Am
kAm“x? AC24E:46[ E9:D 2==@HD 6I4=FD:@?D E@ C6>2:? 😕 67764E …6G6? 7@C ?@E:46D E92E F=E:>2E6=J 72:= — 4C62E:?8 DEC@?8 :?46?E:G6D E@ DF3>:E H62< @C =682==J F?DFAA@CE65 4=2:>D D:>A=J E@ 56=2J W2?5 67764E:G6=J 7:=:3FDE6CX 4@>A=:2?46[” HC@E6 %@?J w24<6EE[ 2 A@=:4J 2DD@4:2E6 7@C r2=:7@C?:2?D p82:?DE (2DE6 😕 2 AF3=:4 4@>>6?E =6EE6C E@ E96 56A2CE>6?E]k^Am
kAmp5G@42E6D C2:D6 2 D64@?5 4@?46C?i E96 C68F=2E:@?D 2==@H 46CE2:? H2DE6 A@==FE:?8 E649?@=@8:6D — @?6D E96 =2H DA64:7:42==J 6I4=F565 3642FD6 E96J 86?6C2E6 D:8?:7:42?E BF2?E:E:6D @7 92K2C5@FD H2DE6 — E@ 4@F?E 2D C64J4=:?8[ 2D =@?8 2D E96J 92G6 2 92K2C5@FD H2DE6 A6C>:E]k^Am
kAm%96D6 E649?@=@8:6D :?4=F56 496>:42= C64J4=:?8 AC@46DD6D E92E E96 @:= :?5FDECJ 92D =@?8 AC@>@E65 2D 2 D@=FE:@? E@ A=2DE:4 A@==FE:@? — 2 4=2:> r2=:7@C?:2’D 2EE@C?6J 86?6C2= D2JD 😀 56=:36C2E6=J >:D=625:?8] #@3 q@?E2 92D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?JE:>6D]4@>^a_ad^_h^_`^4=:>2E6^6II@?\42=:7@C?:2\A=2DE:4D\5672>2E:@?\=2HDF:E]9E>=QmDF65 tII@?|@3:=k^2m 2==68:?8 E96 4@>A2?J >:D=65 E96 AF3=:4 23@FE C64J4=:?8’D A@E6?E:2= E@ 255C6DD E96 A=2DE:4 4C:D:D]k^Am
kAm“%96D6 C68F=2E:@?D :8?@C6 6IA=:4:E =:>:ED @? C64J4=:?8 E649?@=@8:6D 2?5 4C62E6 A6C>2?6?E 6D42A6 92E496D E96 =2H ?6G6C 2FE9@C:K65[” D2:5 }:4< {2A:D[ 5:C64E@C @7 25G@424J 7@C r2=:7@C?:2?D p82:?DE (2DE6[ 😕 2 DE2E6>6?E]k^Am
kAm#9@?2=J? r236==@[ 2 r2=#64J4=6 DA@<6DA6CD@?[ D2:5 E96 286?4J 5@6D ?@E 4@>>6?E @? A6?5:?8 @C A@E6?E:2= =:E:82E:@?]k^Am
kAm$6?] p==6? 28C665 E96 C68F=2E:@?D 72== D9@CE]k^Am
kAm“(6 766= E92E E96 C68F=2E:@?D 2D AC6D6?E65 5@?’E >2:?E2:? D@>6 @7 E96 4@C6 28C66>6?ED E92E H6C6 >256 😕 E96 A2DD286 @7 E96 3:==[” 96 D2:5] (96? E96C6’D E@@ >2?J 6I4=FD:@?D[ 96 D2:5[ 4@>A2?:6D 2C6 “32D:42==J 7@C4:?8 6G6CJ3@5J 6=D6 E@ A2J 2?5 86EE:?8 2H2J D4@E 7C66]”k^Am
k9am$6E FA E@ 72:=nk^9am
kAmqFD:?6DD6D 4=2:> E96J H2?E E@ C65F46 A=2DE:4 H2DE6 3FE 766= EC2AA65 3J 4@?7=:4E:?8 DE2E6 C68F=2E:@?D 2?5 2 =24< @7 G:23=6 A24<28:?8 2=E6C?2E:G6D]k^Am
kAm%96 E6?D:@? DE2CED H:E9 =236=:?8] %96 DE2E6’D 244FC2E6 C64J4=:?8 =236=D =2H[ $6?2E6 q:== bcb[ AC@9:3:ED 3FD:?6DD6D 7C@> FD:?8 E96 492D:?8 2CC@HD DJ>3@= E@ :?5:42E6 C64J4=23:=:EJ F?=6DD 46CE2:? 4C:E6C:2 2C6 >6E] p5G@42E6D D2J E96 C6DEC:4E:@? 😀 ?646DD2CJ E@ 2G@:5 4@?7FD:@?] qFE 3FD:?6DD6D D2J :E >62?D 4@?DF>6CD 2C6 =6DD =:<6=J E@ C64J4=6 AC@5F4ED E92E 4@F=5 36 C64J4=23=6]k^Am
kAm“x7 H6 =@D6 E96 C:89E E@ FD6 WC64J4=:?8 =236=D @?X 52:CJ 42CE@?D[ @FC >6>36CD 2C6 8@:?8 E@ 92G6 E@ 6IA2?5 E96:C A=2DE:4 FD6[ 3642FD6 E92E 😀 E96 @?=J @E96C A24<28:?8 EJA6 E92E 42? E2<6 2 D96=7 DE23=6 AC@5F4E[” D2:5 z2E:6 s2G6J[ 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 E96 s2:CJ x?DE:EFE6 @7 r2=:7@C?:2]k^Am
kAmpD :?G6DE>6?ED 7C@> AC@5F46CD 7=@H E@ 4:E:6D 2?5 4@F?E:6D F?56C E96 =2H[ r236==@ D2:5[ >@C6 >2E6C:2=D >2J 6G6?EF2==J >66E E96 =236=:?8 4C:E6C:2]k^Am
kAmq6J@?5 =236=:?8[ 3FD:?6DD6D D2J H@C<23=6 2=E6C?2E:G6D E@ A=2DE:4 D:>A=J 5@?’E 6I:DE J6E — 2?5 E92E 86EE:?8 E96C6 H:== 36 4@DE=J] x?G6DE>6?ED ?66565 E@ >66E E96 =2H’D 7:CDE 8@2= 2=@?6 — 2 adT C65F4E:@? 😕 D:?8=6\FD6 A=2DE:4 3J a_ba — 4@F=5 4@DE FA E@ S`d]c 3:==:@?[ 244@C5:?8 E@ r2=#64J4=6 6DE:>2E6D]k^Am
kAmz6G:? z6==J[ E96 49:67 6I64FE:G6 @7 t>6C2=5 !24<28:?8[ D6==D 7:=> A=2DE:4 A24<28:?8 E@ 72C>6CD[ H9@ FD6 E96 A=2DE:4 E@ 328 :E6>D =:<6 D2=25D 2?5 323J 42CC@ED] !2A6C A24<28:?8 E92E 4@F=5 C6A=:42E6 A=2DE:4’D 23:=:EJ E@ C68F=2E6 @IJ86? 2?5 42C3@? 5:@I:56 =6G6=D — <66A:?8 AC@5F46 7C6D9 — 😀 DE:== 😕 62C=J 56G6=@A>6?E[ 96 D2:5[ 2?5 >2DD AC@5F4E:@? 😀 564256D 2H2J]k^Am
kAm“*@F 92G6 E@ 3F:=5 E6?D E@ 9F?5C65D @7 3:==:@?D @7 5@==2CD 😕 :?7C2DECF4EFC6 E@ 24EF2==J AC@5F46 D@>6E9:?8 2E E96 =6G6= E92E H@F=5 36 ?66565 E@ C6A=246 A=2DE:4D[” z6==J D2:5]k^Am
kAms2:CJ :==FDEC2E6D E96 D2>6 AC@3=6>] p=E6C?2E:G6D E@ A=2DE:4 >:=< A24<28:?8 :?4=F56 C67C:86C2E65 823=6\E@A 42CE@?D[ D96=7\DE23=6 42CE@?D[ 2?5 8=2DD] t249 4@>6D H:E9 EC256@77D] v=2DD 😀 962G:6C — >62?:?8 76H6C F?:ED A6C D9:A>6?E — 2?5 4=62C 8=2DD 6IA@D6D 7C6D9 >:=< E@ =:89E E92E 42? 568C256 :E] $H:E49:?8 A24<28:?8 =:?6D 6?E:C6=J H@F=5 4@DE AC@5F46CD 23@FE Sc_ >:==:@? 7@C 2 D:?8=6 >:5\D:K6 =:?6[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 s2:CJ x?DE:EFE6 — 2 4@DE E96J H@F=5 A2DD @? E@ 4@?DF>6CD]k^Am
kAm“(6’C6 566A=J 4@?46C?65 3642FD6 H6 @H E92E 7@@5 4@DED 2C6 8@:?8 E@ :?4C62D6 2?5 AC@5F4ED 2C6 8@:?8 E@ 4@>6 @77 E96 >2C<6E 3642FD6 E96C6 =:E6C2==J 😀 ?@E 2 A24<28:?8 D@=FE:@? H:E9:? E96 C6BF:C65 E:>67C2>6[” s2G6J D2:5]k^Am
kAmqFE &$r’D y@6 ÁCG2: D2:5 AC@5F46C 4@>A=2:?ED 2C6 C62==J 23@FE E96 A246 @7 492?86[ ?@E H96E96C 4@>A=:2?E A24<28:?8 😀 A@DD:3=6 2E 2==]k^Am
kAm“(96E96C E96J =:<6 :E @C ?@E[ E96D6 492?86D 2C6 4@>:?8[” 96 D2:5] “x? E96 6?5[ E96C6 2C6 8@:?8 E@ 36 A=2J6CD 😕 E96 :?5FDECJ E92E 2C6 8@:?8 E@ 36 36EE6C 23=6 E@ C6DA@?5[ 2?5 E96J H:== 36 36EE6C :?56>?:7:65 282:?DE E96 D9@4A6E:E@CD]”k^Am
k9am(92E 92AA6?D ?6IEk^9am
kAm%96 ?6IE >2;@C E6DE 4@>6D 😕 yF?6[ H96? E96 r:C4F=2C p4E:@? p==:2?46 >FDE DF3>:E :ED A=2? E@ r2=#64J4=6 @FE=:?:?8 9@H AC@5F46CD H:== >66E E96 =2H’D 8@2=D]k^Am
kAm~C68@?[ H9:49 A2DD65 2 D:>:=2C =2H 2?5 😀 2=D@ 724:?8 2? :?5FDECJ =682= 492==6?86[ @776CD 2 A@DD:3=6 >@56=] %96C6[ 8C2?E 7F?5:?8 😀 2=C625J 7=@H:?8 E@ 6IA2?5 C6FD6 2?5 C67:== :?7C2DECF4EFC6 — 96=A:?8 3FD:?6DD6D 2?5 D49@@=D C6A=246 D:?8=6\FD6 A=2DE:4 AC@5F4ED 2?5 :>AC@G6 C64J4=:?8 2446DD]k^Am
kAm“s6DA:E6 E96 724E E92E E96C6’D 2 =2HDF:E 😕 ~C68@?[ >@?6J 😀 >@G:?8 @FE E96 5@@C[” D2:5 E96 ~462? r@?D6CG2?4J’D p?;2 qC2?5@?] $96 D2:5 8C@FAD =:<6 96CD H:== 4=@D6=J H2E49 E96 yF?6 A=2?]k^Am
kAm“(6’== 2== 36 H2:E:?8 H:E9 32E65 3C62E9” E@ D66 9@H AC@5F46CD 2C6 :?E6CAC6E:?8 E9:D 2?5 H92E A2E9H2JD E96J’C6 =2J:?8 @FE[ D96 D2:5]k^Am
kAm|62?H9:=6[ 25G@42E6D H:== 36 H2E49:?8 4=@D6=J 2D r2=#64J4=6 368:?D E@ >2<6 564:D:@?D 23@FE H9@ BF2=:7:6D 7@C 6I4=FD:@?D 2?5 6I6>AE:@?D] %96 }2EFC2= #6D@FC46D s676?D6 r@F?4:= 😀 H2:E:?8 7@C r2=#64J4=6 E@ A@DE 255:E:@?2= 5@4F>6?ED 367@C6 7:=:?8 :ED =2HDF:E]k^Am
kAm“x7 H6 =6E E9:D E9:?8 86E 56C2:=65 2?5 EFC?65 :?E@ 2 $H:DD 4966D6 @7 6I6>AE:@?D 2?5 ?@?‑4@>A=:2?46[ :E H:== C62==J 92C> @FC 8=@32= AC@8C6DD @? E9:D :DDF6[” p==6? D2:5]k^Am
k9C ^m
kAm%9:D DE@CJ H2D @C:8:?2==J AF3=:D965 3J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^42=>2EE6CD]@C8^Qmr2=|2EE6CDk^2m 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 E9C@F89 2 A2CE?6CD9:A H:E9 %96 pDD@4:2E65 !C6DD]k^Am