With 45 games played so far under the regime of first-year manager Tony Vitello, the San Francisco Giants. The team has been one of the worst in all of Major League Baseball. Through no fault of his own, the former Tennessee Vols manager inherited a complicated situation, one that’s led to seeing his club currently ranked last in MLB in runs scored and second to last in home runs hit. On a team that has a massive payroll and high annual expectations, their 18-27 record is almost unbelievable.

So… will the Giants do a total rebuild?Buster Posey | Giants rebuild?

Sep 9, 2025; San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey sits in the dugout before the game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Robert Edwards-Imagn Images | Robert Edwards-Imagn Images

Many people around baseball believe that the Giants, who have a 2026 team payroll of about $220 million, should cut out high-priced veterans, promote several of their prospects, and accept that you may have to lose now to win later. That’s a move that San Francisco fans, who saw the club win three World Series titles in the previous decade, would be buried in the stands for a season or two.

However, anyone who has been watching what another storied franchise, the St. Louis Cardinals, has done since they decided to blow things up and start over. Stagnant as an aging and tired squad, the vets were shipped out this offseason, while new stars have emerged. In the end? A year that was supposed to be down and out in the Gateway City has seen the Redbirds (26-18) actually stay near the top of the National League Central division.

In reality, the Cards’ start could end up being a mirage, and it’s certainly an anomaly for them to be this good, this quick. Still, if this team loses around 100 games this season? Critics be damned, it may be time to peddle their wares this offseason. Something’s gotta give in the Golden Gate City, and it may end up being the team’s status as a contender for the next couple of years.

Add us as a preferred source on GoogleFollow