Congress, Supervisor Races, and More

This has been a tough time for local campaigns. Donald Trump has caused many San Francisco voters to focus 100% on resistance. But the city’s congressional race, two tight supervisor races, and competing ballot measures have finally gained voters attention. Here are my election predictions.

The Race for Congress

I wrote on January 5, 2026: “Saikat Chakrabarti, the third candidate for Congress, cannot overcome Wiener or Chan. I don’t care how much money he spends; he’s up against two candidates with very loyal constituencies.”

This assessment remains true. I felt even before Pelosi endorsed Chan that the supervisor’s chances were underrated. Chakrabarti’s staggering spending—he’s spent nearly $10 million on his campaign— led many to wrongly conclude he would take progressives from Chan. I never felt this would happen. I explained why in “Why Connie Chan Should Make Runoff.”

Chakrabarti has recently even used his wealth to attack frontrunner Scott Wiener. I saw a Bluesky post from Chakrabarti where he blames Wiener— nationally recognized for securing long overdue housing reforms—for the city’s high housing costs. And for the city not building enough housing.

That could be evidence that Chakrabarti is trying to take younger voters, those most impacted by his messaging, from Wiener. Or it could just be a sign of a desperate campaign.

Prediction: A Wiener-Chan runoff in November.

San Francisco’s District 2

The race to fill Catherine Stefani’s expiring term features two unusually strong candidates. Appointed incumbent Stephen Sherrill is a hard-working and diligent supervisor. Lori Brooke is a longtime neighborhood activist with deep roots in D2.

Stephen Sherrill

Sherrill faces three vulnerabilities.

First, mayoral appointees to the Board do not have a good track record in winning elections.

Second, his support for the Family Zoning Plan has associated him with the planned 25-story twin towers on the Marina Safeway. He opposes the project but favors the pro-housing policies that made that project possible.

Third, recent claims have revived talk that Sherrill’s appointment was part of a political deal that Mayor Breed made with Mike Bloomberg. It’s said that in exchange for the appointment, Bloomberg would give Breed a job.

Conor Johnson, the source of the recent story, contacted me months ago about this. I felt then, and still feel, that it means nothing that Sherrill got his appointment through his association with Bloomberg. Political appointments are  almost always made for political or personal reasons. That’s called politics.

Sherrill’s vulnerabilities are countered by two strengths:

First, and most importantly, Sherrill is a close ally of Mayor Lurie. D2 is where the mayor lives and is most popular. Sherrill is a core ally of Team Lurie.

Second, Sherrill has effectively represented the district. He has not taken a single vote at the Board which went against clear majority sentiment in D2.

Lori Brooke

Lori Brooke is a longtime neighborhood activist. She is best known in recent years for opposing state and local measures to increase housing heights and density.

When I met with Brooke I came away very impressed with her knowledge of issues. She faces two major challenges.

First, she is asking D2 voters to elect a supervisor who will not be a part of Team Lurie. And who won’t hesitate to oppose the mayor.

Second, D2 has a lot of younger voters who aren’t concerned about increasing housing heights and density. The twin towers on the Marina Safeway has not turned them against Sherrill. They likely support Lurie.

Prediction: I see Sherrill winning. I can’t see D2 voters bucking the mayor’s choice. If the race is close expect a November rematch.

San Francisco’s D4

I’ve written a lot about this incredibly tight race to finish the term of former supervisor Joel Engardio. I can easily see the three top candidates—Albert Chow, Natalie Gee and Alan Wong—running against each other in November for a full term.

Here’s the case I made for Wong, “Why Alan Wong Can Win,” December 8, 2025. And why I later gave Chow a chance, “San Francisco Political Forecast, January 5, 2026. But as the campaign proceeded I saw Natalie Gee as most likely to win. See “Why Natalie Gee Can Win in SF’s D4.”

Prediction: I’m sticking with Gee to win. Far and away the most energetic and personable candidate of the three.

Props C and D

Props C and D are the city’s only heavily funded ballot measures.  Prop D, the Overpaid CEO Tax, was put on the ballot by labor unions and progressives seeking to insulate San Francisco from Trump budget cuts. Prop C also raises taxes but exempts more small businesses; Prop C was put on the ballot solely to defeat Prop D.

Although Prop D is supported by nearly all major labor unions, Nancy Pelosi, and eight of eleven supervisors—including Lurie allies like Danny Sauter and Alan Wong—-it has faced a massive opposition campaign. According to Mission Local, as of June 1 backers of Prop D had spent $3.3 million and opponents $6.6 million.

Prop D was also hurt by Chief Economist Ted Egan’s report that estimates the 20-year effects of Prop. D. Egan found it would “include the losses of 944 jobs and $206 million in gross domestic product.” Mayor Lurie promoted the report as confirming that Prop D would slow the city’s recovery.

Voters are being deluged with anti-Prop D messaging. Most claim that Prop D will set the city’s economy back just as it’s turning a corner.

The media has widely accepted Egan’s analysis. But should we be swayed by predictions of job markets twenty years down the road? After all, in 2015 economists could not foresee COVID’s job impact only five years later.  Nor in 2020 did any foresee how Trump’s tariffs would wreck the nation’s economy.

Opponents of Props C and D have done a great job in leaving voters confused over who and what is being taxed. And by how much. When voters are confused about ballot measures they inevitably lose.

Prediction: Both Props D and C lose.

Prop B

See my story, “The Truth About Prop B.” This term-limits measure seemed headed for easy victory until former Governor Jerry Brown, the SF Chronicle, SPUR and the local chapter of the League of Women Voters all came out against it.

I think voters will see through the falsehoods and reject Prop B.

If you are voting absentee and haven’t yet mailed your ballot, please bring it to the polls instead. Remember that San Francisco election results are often not known for days, as absentee ballots that decide the outcome are counted.

Randy ShawRandy Shaw

Randy Shaw is the Editor of Beyond Chron and the Director of San Francisco’s Tenderloin Housing Clinic, which publishes Beyond Chron. Shaw’s new book is the revised and updated, The Tenderloin: Sex, Crime and Resistance in the Heart of San Francisco. His prior books include Generation Priced Out: Who Gets to Live in the New Urban America. The Activist’s Handbook: Winning Social Change in the 21st Century, and Beyond the Fields: Cesar Chavez, the UFW and the Struggle for Justice in the 21st Century.

More Posts