Graham Memorial Presbyterian Church, a part of the Coronado scene since the 1880’s, is preparing to welcome a new permanent pastor after a nearly 3 and a half year search.

Ken Ireland, a retired Coronado resident who serves as an elder and chair of the Christian Education Committee, explained that the church’s roots stretch back to the earliest days of the community. The main sanctuary, he noted, “was built with materials remaining from construction of the Hotel Del Coronado when the wife of one of the builders said she wouldn’t move to Coronado if the town didn’t have a Protestant church.”

Over nearly 140 years, Graham Memorial has had more than a dozen pastors. The most recent permanent pastor, Reverend David McElrath, served Graham for nearly 30 years. When he retired in early 2022, the church initiated a search for a new pastor.

Ireland emphasized that in the Presbyterian tradition, this process is led from within the congregation. “Unlike other denominations, the Presbyterian church does not rely on a Bishop or other regional leader to select a church’s next pastor,” he said. “Our denomination utilizes a congregation-led, deliberate process so that the congregation, through its election of a search committee, finds and calls its next Pastor. This democratic process is at the heart of Presbyterianism.” He added that several of the drafters of the US Constitution came from Presbyterian or Reformed church backgrounds and drew on their knowledge of church governance in crafting the Constitution.

The work of calling a new pastor began with a Mission Study, in which membership defined the aspects of the church and its outreach that they value, as well as the qualities they seek in a new pastor. According to Ireland, “This Mission Study can take upwards of a year.” Once it is approved by the congregation, a Pastor Nominating Committee, or PNC, is formed. “In the case of Graham, we had a 9-member committee. I was one of the members,” he said.

The PNC then compares the results of the Mission Study against the resumes of prospective pastors, conducting initial short interviews via phone or Zoom and, for promising candidates, “2-3 longer (1 hour plus interviews) remotely with the candidate and spouse if possible” before inviting them for a multi-day visit.

“For an idea of scale,” Ireland said, “the PNC looked at over 100 resumes, conducted about a dozen initial interviews, about a half dozen candidates were given second and/or third interviews, and we invited 3 candidates for visits.” According to Ireland, the committee offered Pastor Chris (Rev. Dr. Christopher Atwood) a call to serve at Graham after nearly six months of interviews, visits, and conversations about the fit of this pastor for the future that Graham envisions for our congregation and the greater community of Coronado. During this extended period, Graham had two Interim Pastors. “These are specially trained short-term pastors who shepherd congregations through the process of searching and calling a new pastor.”

Ireland said the PNC’s decision centered on theology, leadership style, and experience. “Most importantly, Pastor Chris has a personal theology, as stated during his interviews and on his written statement of faith, that aligns with the congregation at Graham,” he explained. “His style of teaching and preaching is aligned with what the congregation stated it values in our Mission Study.”

Beyond alignment, Ireland described a history of effective leadership. “Pastor Chris has a proven track record of revitalizing churches and growing congregations at the three churches he has served as Senior Pastor,” he said. “Pastor Chris has a heart for reaching out to people of faith as well as those who have no faith community. He is highly relational and relatable. Finally, he and his wife and children are West Coast natives who desire a return to the coast to be closer to family.”

Ireland also outlined the new pastor’s background. “Pastor Chris was introduced to the Christian faith through Young Life as a teenager in the Pacific Northwest. (As an aside, Coronado has an active Young Life program for high school and middle school-aged kids),” he added. “After graduating from college, he earned his Master’s of Divinity degree from Princeton Seminary in New Jersey, where he met his wife, who was also earning her Master’s of Divinity degree. He continued his studies, earning a Doctorate from Wheaton College in Illinois. He has served as Senior Pastor of churches in California, Ohio, and Florida.”

The arrival of Pastor Chris marks a major turning point for the congregation. “After 30 years with our previous pastor and a nearly 3 and a half year search, our congregation is ready to welcome our permanent pastor,” Ireland said.

According to Ireland, “Pastor Chris and his family will relocate to Coronado in early July, moving into the historic manse on the campus at Graham in time to enjoy our 4th of July festivities.” He added that “He will begin working at Graham on July 15th, and his first day leading worship and preaching at Graham is July 19th.”

VOL. 116, NO. 22 – June 3, 2026