Judge hands San Jose win in license plate reader case | National News

A judge has dismissed a lawsuit challenging San Jose’s network of license plate reader cameras, dealing a legal setback to opponents of a technology used to fight crime that has divided the city’s residents over fears of dragnet surveillance.

In a ruling delivered Friday, Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey El-Hajj rejected arguments that the city’s practice of allowing warrantless police searches of its automated license plate reader (ALPR) data — derived from a network of more than 500 devices scattered across town — violates the California Constitution’s guarantee of privacy rights and prohibition on unreasonable searches. The ruling follows the lead of an earlier decision from a California Appellate Court that found drivers have no reasonable expectation of privacy when traveling through public streets.

kAm!=2:?E:77D 92G6 E96 @AE:@? E@ 2AA62= E96 CF=:?8 2?5 D2:5 E96J 2C6 C6G:6H:?8 E96:C =682= @AE:@?D] %96 4:EJ 2=D@ 7246D 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^2?@E96C\=2HDF:E\E2C86ED\D2?\;@D6D\=:46?D6\A=2E6\42>6C2D^QmD6A2C2E6 4:G:= 42D6 E2C86E:?8 :ED p{!# DJDE6>k^2m ?@H H@C<:?8 :ED H2J E9C@F89 7656C2= 4@FCE]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^D2?\;@D6\4:EJ\4@F?4:=\D:8?D\@77\@?\?6H\4:EJ\2EE@C?6J^Qmr:EJ pEE@C?6J $FD2?2 p=42=2 (@@5k^2m H6=4@>65 E96 ?6HD]k^Am

kAm“%96 4@FCE’D 5:D>:DD2= @7 E96 4@>A=2:?E 😀 E6DE2>6?E E@ E96 724E E92E E96 4:EJ’D p{!# DJDE6> >66ED 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= D4CFE:?J 2?5 @?=J 82E96CD :?7@C>2E:@? E92E 😀 2=C625J @3D6CG65 7C@> E96 AF3=:4 C:89ED\@7\H2J[” p=42=2 (@@5 E@=5 $2? y@Dé $A@E=:89E]k^Am

kAmq24<6CD @7 E96 E649?@=@8J 4@?E6?5 :E 92D 6>6C865 2D 2 G:E2= 4C:>6 7:89E:?8 E@@=[ 96=A:?8 $2? y@D6’D @G6CDEC6E4965 A@=:46 7@C46 D@=G6 ?F>6C@FD 4C:>6D]k^Am

kAmqFE E96 =2HDF:E[ 7:=65 😕 }@G6>36C a_ad[ H2C?D E96 G2DE EC@G6 @7 52E2 86?6C2E65 3J E96 42>6C2 ?6EH@C< 42? 36 FD65 E@ EC24< 5C:G6CD’ H96C623@FED 2D E96J EC2G6= E9C@F89@FE E96 4:EJ] %96 4:G:= =:36CE:6D @C82?:K2E:@?D 2C6 C6AC6D6?E:?8 EH@ ?@?AC@7:ED E92E 25G@42E6 7@C $@FE9 q2J :>>:8C2?ED — $6CG:46D[ x>>:8C2?E #:89ED 2?5 t5F42E:@? }6EH@C< W$x#t}X 2?5 E96 r@F?4:= @? p>6C:42?\xD=2>:4 #6=2E:@?D]k^Am

kAm“(6 36=:6G6 DEC@?8=J E92E E96 CF=:?8 😀 HC@?8 @? E96 =2H[ 2?5 2== @AE:@?D 7@C ?6IE DE6AD 2C6 @? E96 E23=6[” p?5C6H rC@4<6C[ DFCG6:==2?46 =:E:82E:@? 5:C64E@C 2E tuu[ E@=5 $2? y@Dé $A@E=:89E]k^Am

kAm!=2:?E:77D 925 2D<65 E96 4@FCE E@ C6DEC:4E 2446DD E@ E96 52E2 3J C6BF:C:?8 =2H 6?7@C46>6?E 286?4:6D E@ 7:CDE @3E2:? 2 H2CC2?E 367@C6 4@?5F4E:?8 2 D62C49]k^Am

kAmx? 6IA=2:?:?8 9:D CF=:?8[ t=\w2;; 4:E65 2 a_ac 564:D:@? 7C@> r2=:7@C?:2’D cE9 s:DEC:4E r@FCE @7 pAA62=D[ H9:49 56E6C>:?65 E92E G:56@ 6G:56?46 @3E2:?65 FD:?8 DEC66E=:89E 42>6C2D @A6C2E65 3J $2? s:68@ 4@F=5 36 FD65 😕 2 >FC56C AC@D64FE:@?] x? E96 CF=:?8[ E96 4@FCE ?@E65 E92E A6@A=6 2C6 2H2C6 E96J >2J 36 7:=>65 3J D64FC:EJ 42>6C2D @? 4:EJ DEC66ED]k^Am

kAmt=\w2;; C6;64E65 A=2:?E:77D’ 2C8F>6?ED E92E E96 D966C BF2?E:EJ @7 42>6C2D 😕 $2? y@D6 >2<6D E96 4:EJ’D ?6EH@C< 2 72C >@C6 :?G2D:G6 =2H 6?7@C46>6?E E@@=]k^Am

kAm%96 4@?EC@G6CDJ DFCC@F?5:?8 $2? y@D6’D FD6 @7 p{!# 42>6C2D 3642>6 6G6? >@C6 :?E6?D6 =2DE >@?E9 H96? !@=:46 r9:67 !2F= y@D6A9 C6G62=65 E96 $2? y@D6 !@=:46 s6A2CE>6?E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]>6C4FCJ?6HD]4@>^a_ae^_h^“^D2?\;@D6\A@=:46\@77:46C\7:C65\7@C\23FD:?8\7=@4<\=:46?D6\A=2E6\C6256C\52E232D6\49:67\D2JD^Qm7:C65 2? @77:46Ck^2m 😕 pAC:= 7@C 2==6865=J D92C:?8 =@42E:@? 52E2 H:E9 9:D 4@FD:?]k^Am

kAmp>:5 E96 AF3=:4 @FE4CJ[ 2 8C@FA @7 4@F?4:=>6>36CD F?G6:=65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^D2?\;@D6\282:?\2EE6>AED\E@\E:89E6?\4@?EC@=D\@?\=:46?D6\A=2E6\C6256CD^Qm?6H D2768F2C5Dk^2m 7@C E96 E649?@=@8J[ :?4=F5:?8 AC@A@D2=D 2:>65 2E >2<:?8 :E 92C56C 7@C 4:EJ 6>A=@J66D E@ FD6 A6CD@?2= 56G:46D E@ 2446DD D6?D:E:G6 =2H 6?7@C46>6?E 52E2]k^Am

kAm%96 r:EJ r@F?4:= 2=C625J A2DD65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^D2?\;@D6\H6:89D\?6H\D2768F2C5D\7@C\7=@4<\=:46?D6\A=2E6\C6256C\42>6C2D^Qm2? 62C=:6C A24<286k^2m 😕 |2C49 E92E 92D C65F465 E96 2>@F?E @7 E:>6 E96 4:EJ 42? 9@=5 @?E@ E96 52E2 7C@> @?6 J62C E@ b_ 52JD]k^Am

kAmw@H6G6C[ D@ 72C E96 8F2C5C2:=D 92G6 DE:== 72==6? H6== D9@CE @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^D2?\;@D6\C6D:56?ED\H2?E\A@=:46\49:67\@FE\27E6C\7=@4<\42>6C2\>:DFD6^Qm56>2?5D 7C@> >2?J 4C:E:4Dk^2m[ H9@ 2C6 42==:?8 @? $2? y@D6’D =6256CD E@ 7@==@H E96 =625 @7 @E96C q2J pC62 ;FC:D5:4E:@?D — DF49 2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^D2?E2\4=2C2\4@F?EJ\>2J\5:E49\42>6C2\G6?5@C\2>:5\AC:G24J\:DDF6D^Qm$2?E2 r=2C2 r@F?EJk^2m[ {@D p=E@D w:==D 2?5 |@F?E2:? ‘:6H — 2?5 4FE E:6D 6?E:C6=J H:E9 u=@4< $276EJ[ E96 4@?EC@G6CD:2= G6?5@C 4@?EC24E65 E@ AC@G:56 E96 p{!# E649?@=@8J E@ E96 4:EJ]k^Am

kAm“%96D6 42>6C2D 92G6 366? FD65 E@ E2C86E :>>:8C2?ED 2=C625J[ 3FE E96 C62=:EJ 😀 E92E H6 2== H:== 36 DF3;64E E@ E96:C 72C\C6249:?8 :>A24E[” wFJ %C2?[ 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 $x#t}[ E@=5 $2? y@Dé $A@E=:89E]k^Am

k9C ^m

kAm%9:D DE@CJ H2D @C:8:?2==J AF3=:D965 3J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D2?;@D6DA@E=:89E]4@>^Qm$2? y@Dé $A@E=:89Ek^2m 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 E9C@F89 2 A2CE?6CD9:A H:E9 %96 pDD@4:2E65 !C6DD]k^Am

For copyright information, check with the distributor of this item, San José Spotlight.