Penalties for fare evasion on local trolleys and buses will be softened from criminal to administrative under a new compliance policy approved Thursday by the Metropolitan Transit System board.
The goal of the new policy, which the board approved 11-3 after some contentious debate, is to help riders — many of them low-income — avoid criminal records that stick with them for years.
“Missing a $3 fare should not result in a permanent criminal record, a bench warrant or background check,” said County Supervisor Monica Montgomery Steppe, who serves on the MTS board. “I believe this is the overcriminalization of low-income transit riders who are simply trying to get to work or school.”
MTS will shift away from using the state court system and bring the entire citation process for fare evasion in-house, using a third-party vendor to process fines and a hearing officer system to handle citation appeals.
Supporters said the change would make the penalties for fare evasion more akin to parking tickets than speeding tickets.
The new system isn’t expected to be in place until 2029 because of a long series of bureaucratic hurdles that MTS officials outlined during Thursday’s hearing.
Montgomery Steppe said she’s been seeking a fully administrative system for several years, but it was time-consuming to determine exactly how to handle the switch away from a criminal system.
“We are changing and overhauling the way we treat every single citation,” she said.
The move comes 20 months after MTS cracked down on fare evasion that was estimated to be costing the agency $1 million a month. In February 2025, code compliance officers began spot-checking riders for fare compliance significantly more often.
The move also comes six years after MTS shifted from a fully criminal citation system to a hybrid model with the 2020 creation of a program by which violators could avoid fines and prosecution by completing community service.
The new policy approved Thursday completes the agency’s shift from criminal to administrative, Montgomery Steppe said. It will also apply to some other offenses, such as smoking, skateboarding and willful disturbance on trains and buses and at transit stations.
Other large transit agencies in California vary in how they handle fare evasion.
The Los Angeles Metro and San Francisco Muni are fully administrative, while the North County Transit District and Sacramento Regional Transit are fully criminal. Hybrid systems include BART and Caltrain.
The three board members who voted against the new policy are Chula Vista Mayor John McCann, El Cajon Councilmember Steve Goble and Santee Councilmember Ron Hall.
The net cost to MTS of making the shift is expected to be roughly $400,000 per year. There will also be an estimated $375,000 in one-time start-up costs.
“We are in such a bad position right now — we don’t need to add on,” said Hall, referring to projected annual deficits of more than $100 million MTS faces starting in 2030. “We’re worried about staying alive, and this is going to cause problems.”
Goble also cited the costs, but said his chief concern was that the agency would be spending money to make changes that he perceives as toughening enforcement of fare evasion.
He noted that the new policy increases the fine for offenders from $25 to $75, shortens the payment timeline and subjects violators to criminal prosecution on their third offense.
Under the hybrid model MTS has used since 2020, violators can pay $25 or do community service over and over again without things escalating to the criminal level.
Montgomery Steppe called Goble’s comparison unfair, stressing that only about 15% of violators opt for the community service approach. She said that means 85% of violators are funneled into the criminal process.
MTS officials noted that the maximum fine under the new model would be $125, while violators can pay as much as $300 under the current system when all court fees are included.
San Diego Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera, another MTS board member, praised the new policy.
“The way injustice occurs in our community can often-times be in these much smaller, but very impactful ways,” said Elo-Rivera, calling the new system much better than the old. “It is more just.”
Elo-Rivera also reiterated his suggestion that MTS consider a fully-gated trolley system to make fare evasion far less frequent.
“Even better than diversion is prevention,” he said.