Former Bullard High football coach Don Arax, left, and FUSD trustee Keshia Thomas, right.

Former Bullard High football coach Don Arax, left, and FUSD trustee Keshia Thomas, right.

Fresno Bee File

A judge recently issued a ruling in favor of former Bullard High School football coach Don Arax in his defamation lawsuit against Fresno Unified School District and Keshia Thomas, a trustee who’s running for city council.

However, Fresno Unified — the state’s third-largest school district — is now pushing back against Arax’s discovery requests, which it said in a legal filing are “burdensome and harassing.”

Arax sued the district and Thomas in 2022 after the trustee went on a local podcast and said the coach used a racial slur years ago, directed at her son. Arax denied the incident, which allegedly happened at a football camp in 2013 when Thomas’ son was in middle school, and filed the lawsuit.

In August, Thomas’ son, Albert Alford Jr., now an adult, said that Arax never used the slur toward him, prompting some calls for Thomas to resign. She apologized but said she would not resign.

On Wednesday, Sean Kneafsey — legal counsel for Fresno Unified — asked the court to issue a protective order allowing the district to not respond to Arax’s requests for admission, part of the discovery process.

Fresno Unified accused Arax of accosting the district with discovery requests that would necessitate more than 500 written responses.

“Good cause exists for the issuance of a protective order in that the discovery propounded is: overbroad, burdensome and harassing; irrelevant and not likely to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; unreasonably cumulative or duplicative; and unsupported by a good-faith declaration for additional discovery,” the district’s motion reads.

The district’s legal counsel is asking the court to hold a hearing about the matter on November 18.

This development follows a judge issuing a tentative ruling in Arax’s favor on Oct. 7. With her ruling, Judge Kristi Culver Kapetan shot down the defendants’ claim that Thomas’s statement was true. Judge Kapetan also ruled that the district cannot claim that Thomas’s allegation wasn’t privileged speech protected by law.

The allegation that Arax had called Thomas’s son a racial slur is at the center of the lawsuit. In August, Thomas’s son — Albert Alford Jr., now an adult — said the allegation was untrue and that Arax had never called him a slur.

Trial is set for Dec. 7, 2026.

This story was originally published October 16, 2026 at 12:30 PM.


Profile Image of Nick Fenley

Nick Fenley

The Fresno Bee

Nick Fenley is a reporter covering education, lawsuits, breaking news and more for The Fresno Bee. He’s originally from the Imperial Valley and joined The Bee in 2025.