Photo illustration of Oakland City Council President Kevin Jenkins.Vol. VI, No. 1,178

—Last November, the election of Democratic Socialist Zohran Mamdani as mayor of New York City, along with the upset victory of progressive Seattle Mayor Katherine Wilson, drew national attention and signaled a renewed effort by the left to counter the far-right agenda of the Trump administration and Republicans in Congress.

On long-standing issues such as affordability, housing rights, and fair wages, the developments in New York City and Seattle have offered a measure of hope to struggling Americans.

Oakland, however, offers a cautionary tale.

—After years of progressive leadership—and now under the direction of one of the nation’s most prominent progressive figures—Oakland is drifting toward the political center.

The arrival of Councilmembers Charlene Wang and Ken Houston, combined with Council President Kevin Jenkins’ leadership, has shifted the city’s posture on issues that previous councils would have swiftly rejected.

Policies such as expanding surveillance cameras, conducting more aggressive homeless encampment cleanups, and rolling back the Police Commission’s activist makeup are now moving forward.

Oakland remains a progressive city government, but one that has grown noticeably more pragmatic. Even Mayor Barbara Lee has acknowledged that governing a city requires flexibility that ideology alone cannot provide—a different reality from serving as one of 435 members of Congress.

With crime rates trending downward, Lee this week doubled down, announcing a public-private partnership with Kaiser Permanente and PG&E that will contribute $900,000 to fund nine police cadet positions over the next two years.

—Few would have imagined Lee—or earlier generations of Oakland progressives—embracing an expansion of the police force, particularly one financed by corporate partners. Yet that is where the city now finds itself.

It’s not surprising the pendulum has swung the other way. Years of perceived inaction by the Oakland City Council on quality of life issues, such as public safety, poor road conditions, homeless encampments, massive budget deficits and an overall lack of cleanliness have led voters to elect candidates offering a change from the status quo.

Whether voters in New York City, Seattle, and other progressive strongholds will ultimately prosper under similar leadership—or experience the same sense of buyer’s remorse now felt by many in Oakland—remains an open question.

Refer a friend

—More inside:

COUNTY NEWS: The group behind the recalls made history two years ago, and they still have East Bay officials on notice—whether the recall threat is real or not.

CITY NEWS: With threat of a second censure on the table, San Leandro councilmember was willing to bring others down with him.

ELECTION 2026: Stark family offers endorsement in CD14 primary race.

CAMPAIGN FINANCE: List of large campaign contributions for Jan. 16-22.