Could California’s major utilities control their rapidly rising electricity rates by using their power grids more efficiently? State lawmakers want to find out.
A set of bills introduced this year would order Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison, and San Diego Gas & Electric to measure and improve how they’re utilizing the hundreds of thousands of miles of power lines that carry electricity to customers.
At issue is how those utilities handle peaks in electricity demand that happen only a handful of hours per year — typically by upgrading and expanding expensive grid infrastructure. Identifying exactly where on the grid that utilities have taken, or plan to take, this approach and where extra capacity could be freed up is key.
Armed with that knowledge, regulators could set metrics and create incentives for utilities to use technologies like advanced grid controls and distributed solar with batteries to smooth out those peaks — and thus, reduce one of the biggest drivers of soaring electricity costs.
Assembly Bill 1975, introduced by Assembly Member Nick Schultz, a Democrat, would require utilities to measure grid utilization and find ways to improve it over time.
Senate Bill 905, a wide-ranging utility cost-containment package, includes a provision that would mandate “additional reporting on how effectively utilities are using existing distribution grid capacity, particularly during off-peak periods,” when grids have more headroom to deliver power.
“At a time when cost is an issue, making better use of the grid we already have — and have already paid for — is paramount,” state Senator Josh Becker, the Democrat who introduced SB 905, told Canary Media. “That doesn’t mean we won’t keep building new transmission for clean energy. But let’s make sure we’re using our existing grid well.”
One way to do that would be through load flexibility programs, which help relieve temporary grid constraints by paying customers to reduce the amount of power they use via smart thermostats and other devices, or to share the electricity they’ve stored in plugged-in electric vehicles and home batteries charged with rooftop solar.
Making better use of the existing grid could save a lot of money over the long run, Becker said. California’s three big utilities are spending more than other utilities around the country on their distribution grids, according to data from the Department of Energy’s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and The Brattle Group. The costs of those grid investments must be recovered through the rates they charge their customers — who are now paying roughly twice the national average for electricity.
Much of that grid spending is meant to reduce the risk of sparking deadly wildfires. But a sizable chunk goes toward expanding substations, transformers, and power lines to serve EVs, heat pumps, data centers, and broader economic growth.
As the state pushes to meet targets to electrify vehicles and buildings, those costs could grow even further. A 2023 study commissioned by the California Public Utilities Commission found the state’s three major utilities could need to invest up to $50 billion by 2035 to meet growing power demand.
But if utilities can successfully get EV chargers, heat pumps, and other devices to use electricity when the existing grid has more capacity, it would minimize the need for expensive upgrades while also increasing sales of electricity to cover new and existing grid costs.
Utilities don’t have a clear incentive to constrain excess grid spending, however. In fact, under traditional cost-of-service regulation, they earn guaranteed profits based on how much money they invest in infrastructure. That’s why elected officials who are facing voter anger over high utility bills in states across the country are looking to measures like those that have been proposed in California.
Deploy Action, a nonprofit formed to promote distributed energy as a solution to rising electricity costs, is pushing these kinds of grid utilization bills in California and several other states.
“We all know what’s driving up utility rates and bills,” said Phil Ting, the organization’s co-founder and a former California Assembly member from 2012 to 2024. “Every time PG&E is building something, they’re getting their rate of return. That adds to our rate base — the rates go up — and that’s what they’re financially motivated to do.”
Last month, Deploy Action won its first victory on this front in Virginia, with the passage of a law that would set grid utilization requirements for Appalachian Power and Dominion Energy, the state’s two major investor-owned utilities. The law was supported by Gov. Abigail Spanberger, who campaigned on containing rising electricity costs.
Virginia’s law requires utilities to gather and report detailed data on their grid utilization, and orders regulators to use that data to establish targets and timelines for utilities to optimize grid usage, with special consideration to “non-wires alternatives” like batteries and advanced grid controls.
“A goal would be for California to follow in Virginia’s footsteps,” said Arnab Pal, Deploy Action’s executive director and a former adviser in the Biden-era Department of Energy. “Then, we can do some procurement reforms around the technologies that increase utilization.”
What is the status of grid utilization?
This work wouldn’t happen overnight. Under AB 1975 and SB 905, the California Public Utilities Commission would order utilities to collect and share core grid-utilization data. Though the bills differ slightly in their approach, both stipulate that the CPUC set rules for the utilities to improve their grid utilization starting in 2028.