On Monday, May 4, California Governor Gavin Newsom said that he warned insurance companies that they may face legal action if they illegally delay or deny claims from victims of the Los Angeles (LA) fires.

According to the press release, this warning came as it was the same day that the state insurance commissioner made public his intentions to sue State Farm General Insurance Company following “an expedited investigation [that] uncovered significant mishandling of insurance claims filed by survivors.”

Newsom added that victims’ ability to access their insurance coverage is “foundational” to recovery and that they need “accelerated relief.”

“We’re not going to sit by while companies slow-walk claims and make it harder for families to rebuild. We’re standing up for survivors by holding insurance companies accountable—especially when they delay or deny what people are owed,” Newsom said.

California’s Insurance Commissioner, Ricardo Lara, said that while examining 220 cases involving survivors, it was discovered that State Farm broke the law “hundreds” of times.

If the insurance company is found guilty of violating the law, it could be compelled to pay up to $4 million. Additionally, State Farm’s license could be temporarily suspended in California for a year.

State Farm also issued a statement addressing the allegations. The statement read that the company’s errors were largely procedural and administrative and that the lawsuit is a “reckless, politically motivated attack” that can “cripple” the state’s homeowners’ insurance market.

The company also denied allegations of “mishandling or intentionally underpaying wildfire claims,” referencing the $5.7 billion it paid on 13,700 home and auto insurance claims linked to the fires.

Background Information

On January 7, 2025, a ruinous wildfire that began in the Santa Monica Mountains of Los Angeles spread to Malibu, Topanga, and Pacific Palisades. 31 lives were lost, and 16,000 structures were destroyed.

Additionally, many residents were exposed to toxic smoke, which some have attributed to the following spike in heart attacks and abnormal blood test results.

In 2023, two years before the fires, State Farm and other prominent insurance companies temporarily suspended or restricted coverage in California. At the time, the companies explained that they could not reasonably price the risk of property damage because wildfires were increasing in damage and frequency.

In response, in December 2024, California allowed insurance companies to move reinsurance costs to consumers and to consider climate risks when setting their prices.

In return, insurance companies agreed to expand coverage for residents living in areas prone to wildfires.

Insurers agreed to write 85% of the number of policies in wildfire-prone areas that they do in other regions, so their number of policies was almost proportional to the number of policies in lower-risk areas.

Despite this agreement, many survivors of the LA fires claimed that State Farm was delaying or denying claims regarding home damages and potential contamination from smoke.

These numerous claims prompted Lara to conduct an investigation in which he examined 220 randomly selected cases from survivors.

He and his team found approximately 400 violations by State Farm. These violations included underpayments and unreasonably slow processing of claims.

The insurance company was allegedly responsible for almost a third of insurance claims resulting from the fires, possibly resulting in thousands being impacted by State Farm’s handling.