Compare, for a moment, the prime minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland with the governor of California.

One presides over 40 million people, more venture capital than the European continent combined and the world’s fourth largest economy.

The other is, at present, Sir Keir Starmer.

That the so-called Golden State has more heft than most countries, and whoever leads it is a figure of immense political importance, has been true for decades. Now it has a global dimension for another reason: polls for the election this year to replace the term-limited Gavin Newsom have a leader — who is British.

Another striking aspect of the apparent ascendancy of Steve Hilton, who from 2010 to 2012 was director of strategy for David Cameron, the prime minister at the time, is that he is a Republican in a state seen as overwhelmingly Democratic.

This is not necessarily as surprising as it first appears. While the voting went only one way in recent presidential elections:

…gubernatorial elections are more volatile:

It is complicated, too, by the fact that California holds a “jungle primary”. Rather than each party choosing their candidate against the other’s, as in the presidential election, all candidates of any party compete at once to finish in the top two in June and proceed to the November run-off.

It is possible to have a Republican v Republican run-off or a Republican who beats a Democrat, said Mark Baldassare of the Public Policy Institute of California, which conducts regular surveys in the state. “​We’ve had ​governors who have been Republicans because the Democratic vote may be split, or there’s dissatisfaction with long​-term Democratic leadership.”

Both of those factors are out in force this year, especially after sexual misconduct allegations ended the campaign of Eric Swalwell, a Democratic frontrunner. These are the top five candidates.

Steve Hilton: satirised aide and Fox News host

Steve Hilton participating in a CNN California gubernatorial debate.ETHAN SWOPE/AP

Policies include:

Lowering the price of gasoline by suspending environmental regulations

Cutting income taxes for middle-class earners and the wealthy

Opening natural spaces for housing

Hilton, 56, was born in London to parents who had fled communist Hungary. As a political operative for the Conservative Party and aide to Cameron, such was his notoriety as a “wacky thinker” in No 10 that he inspired a character in the TV satire The Thick of It whose lines included “Let’s imagineer a narrative”, “I like the plasmic nature of your data modelling” and “Let’s do away with computers!”

David Cameron and Steve Hilton in the Cabinet room at 10 Downing Street.With David Cameron in Downing Street Rex Features

He left Britain in 2012 for Silicon Valley before endorsing Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton in 2016 and, in an about-turn from his previous life persuading Cameron to embrace more liberal policies, becoming a populist right-wing broadcaster on Fox News. In 2021 he, like Arnold Schwarzenegger decades earlier, was enabled to run for governor by securing dual US citizenship.

Trump has in turn endorsed Hilton for governor, describing him as “a truly fine man, one who has watched as this once great State has gone to Hell”. It was a useful intervention, at least in the primary. “While Trump is not popular in California,” Baldassare said, “if you look at the total electorate, 75 per cent of Republicans approve of the job President Trump is doing, and President Trump received 38 per cent of the vote in the 2024 election.”

The other reason for Hilton’s rise, Baldassare added, was that he had “very articulately made the argument that there are a lot of problems in California and those problems can be traced to the Democratic leadership. This has resonated with a number of Republican voters as well as [independent] voters … which are numerous in California.

“It’s making an articulate argument that the current state of affairs is not acceptable, which many Californians at our polls tell us is the case — ‘the state’s going in the wrong direction’.”

Xavier Becerra: Trump foe and Covid health secretary

California gubernatorial candidate Xavier Becerra gives a thumbs-up during a campaign event.JAE C HONG/AP

Policies include:

Declaring a state of emergency to freeze utility and insurance rates

Remaining open to revising the state’s climate goals to keep fuel affordable

Born in Sacramento to Mexican immigrants, Becerra, 68, was a state assemblyman before spending 24 years as a US congressman.

As state attorney-general between 2017 and 2021, Becerra led about 120 lawsuits against the first Trump administration. As President Biden’s health secretary for the next four years, he oversaw the Covid vaccination programme and sought to protect abortion access after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade in 2022.

He has taken his antipathy towards Trump into debates for the governor election, describing him in one as “Steve Hilton’s daddy”.

Notably, he has backed away from traditional Democratic priorities, especially on the environment, as fuel prices rise:

He has not, however, gone so far as to join Matt Mahan, the mayor of San Jose also running as a Democrat, in calling for an end to the tax on gasoline.

Tom Steyer: the billionaire ex-presidential hopeful

Tom Steyer speaks after a California gubernatorial debate.BENJAMIN FANJOY/Getty IMAGES

Policies include:

Challenging the monopoly status of the state’s investor-owned utilities

Raising taxes on business-owned properties

Collecting a fee on AI usage to support displaced workers

Steyer, 68, was born in Manhattan to a teacher mother and a father who was a prosecutor in the Nuremberg trials. He made his fortune — estimated by Forbes this year at $2.4 billion — after founding a hedge fund in San Francisco. Upon leaving it in the 2010s, he became a climate activist and a supporter of attempts to impeach Trump.

He is not afraid to self-fund his campaigns: he sank $340 million into the 2020 Democratic presidential primaries before dropping out, while for this governor race he is thought to have spent about $130 million.

Perhaps his most famous moment was in the 2020 run, when after a clash between Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders at a TV debate, Steyer inserted himself and said: “I don’t want to get in the middle … I just wanted to say hi, Bernie.” Sanders’ nonplussed response — “Yeah, OK. Good” — went viral.

Chad Bianco: cowboy sheriff with ties to extremists 

Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco speaks into a microphone at a Donald Trump rally.FREDERIC J BROWN/AFP/GETTY IMAGES

Policies include:

Eliminating state income tax

Suspending state regulations, especially on the environment, boosting oil and gas production and ending taxes on gasoline

Overturning the state “sanctuary law” that limits how police can co-operate with federal immigration agents

Bianco, 58, was born at an air force base in Utah and grew up in a mining town. He moved to California in 1989 and worked in law enforcement before being elected Riverside county sheriff in 2018, then re-elected four years later.

He has been characterised as a “cowboy” for his maverick persona, especially during the Covid pandemic when he refused to be vaccinated or enforce the mandated wearing of facemasks. He acknowledged membership in 2014 of the Oath Keepers, a right-wing extremist militia that would later play a key role in the Capitol riot on January 6, 2021. Earlier this year he seized half a million ballots from a 2025 special election, claiming allegations of voter fraud. The state supreme court struck down his investigation and the state attorney-general accused him of going “rogue”.

Bianco can expect higher support in Riverside and other inland areas, which tend to lean more Republican than the coastal cities:

Katie Porter: Elizabeth Warren with a whiteboard

Katie Porter, candidate for governor of California, on stage in a CNN televised debate.DAVID CRANE/Getty IMAGES

Policies include:

Cutting income taxes for middle-income earners

Raising corporate taxes on large businesses

Developing denser housing in urban areas and near transport links

Porter, 52, was born in Iowa, where she grew up on a farm before studying at both Yale and Harvard, including under Warren, later a Massachusetts senator and left-wing presidential contender. Like Warren she embarked on a career in consumer protection and in 2012 was appointed by Kamala Harris, then the state’s attorney-general, to ensure banks provided relief to homeowners in a $25 billion mortgage settlement.

She served in Congress from 2019, attracting attention for using whiteboards to aid her questioning of witnesses in congressional hearings, before standing down from re-election in favour of a failed attempt to secure nomination to the Senate.

The primary is scheduled for June 2 and the general election coincides with the midterms on November 3, when the US House, a third of the Senate and other local votes are held across the country.

On January 4, the new governor is sworn in and Newsom will be in need of a job. He has made little secret of what he wants that to be — but there are suggestions that his record may count against an attempt in 2028 to emulate Ronald Reagan and make the jump from the California governor’s mansion to the White House.

President Donald Trump talks with then California Gov.-elect Gavin Newsom during a visit to a wildfire-impacted neighborhood.Gavin Newsom with President Trump in 2018 EVAN VUCCI/AP

On his watch, voters say, California has failed to tackle problems including the cost of living, a housing shortage, persistent homelessness and a stalling economy. “That’s going to be an issue when or if he runs for president,” Baldassare said. “Many Californians feel that things are not going well in the state.”