Thursday, seven of the top candidates in the race to be California’s next governor faced off in San Francisco in what will likely be the final major debate before the June primary.
Featured on the debate stage were two Republicans (former Fox News host Steve Hilton and Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco) and five Democrats (former Congresswoman Katie Porter, former state attorney general Xavier Becerra, former Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan, and billionaire philanthropist Tom Steyer). With the stakes rising and the race still very crowded, tensions rose to a boiling point between candidates throughout the night.
This hour-and-a-half-long debate was hosted by CBS California and the San Francisco Examiner at the Julia Morgan Ballroom in San Francisco. Many of the candidates hurled criticisms at one another throughout the night, talking over each other to the point where it was difficult at times for people to get a word in. The candidates covered a wide range of issues over the course of the debate.
Former campaign aide bank fraud charges
Becerra, who has been rising in the polls in recent weeks, faced many criticisms from fellow candidates on Thursday, including criticisms in relation to the actions of one of his former aides. Thursday, a former campaign adviser to Becerra pleaded guilty to charges including conspiracy to commit bank fraud related to a scheme to steal campaign funds from Becerra back when he was the Health and Human Services Secretary.
“As I have said from day 1, I was not involved in the wrongdoing I had nothing to do with that, I did nothing wrong,” Becerra said.
“Don’t take my words for it, take the words of the U.S. Attorney who said no candidate running for governor has been implicated in this particular matter,” Becerra said, referring to a statement sent by the U.S. Attorney’s Office to the New York Times.
Climate and the environment
During a lightning round, the candidates were asked if they would increase drilling off the coast of California as governor. Bianco responded, “Yes,” and Hilton responded, “Yes, we have to lower gas prices.” All the other candidates said they would not increase drilling off California’s coast.
Bianco said he believes in climate change, but pushed back against the idea of human-caused climate change.
“We’ve been threatened since I was a little kid of being in an ice age, of California being nonexistent because oceans were going to rise? It’s not going to happen. Am I naïve enough to believe human beings can affect it? No,” Bianco said.
Hilton said the state needs “common sense on climate change, not ideology.”
Steyer repeatedly focused on his efforts to take on fossil fuel companies.
“They think I am coming for their profits, and they’re right, because that’s the only way we’re going to drive down costs and make California affordable for working people again,” he said.
Affordability
Each of the candidates tried to paint a vision for their plan to make California more affordable
Porter outlined a four-point plan that includes lowering the cost of housing and providing free childcare.
“I have plans to lower the cost of housing by building faster, if we build the same speed here in California as we build in Colorado, for example, [we could have] 10 or 20 percent cheaper housing,” Porter said.
Mahan said he is focused on lowering costs for consumers.
“I’ve called for suspending the gas tax and reforming it so that EV owners pay their fair share for maintaining our roads, ” Mahan said, adding, in San Jose we’ve removed one-time fees that make housing more expensive than it should be.”
Villaraigosa said his experience leading a major city would help him to be more effective at cutting costs for Californians.
“We need a problem solver, somebody who’s done it before. I was mayor of a city that is larger than San Francisco, San Jose, San Diego, and Oakland,” he said.
State Superintendent Tony Thurmond, who is also running for governor, wasn’t invited to be part of the debate stage Thursday, but still showed up to watch and to speak with the press.
“I’ve got a very specific plan that I know will help people in the Bay Area and in our state, building 2 million housing units and providing a tax credit to people who are struggling,” Thurmond said.
Many voters are still unsure about who to vote for with just a few weeks remaining before the June primary.
Political correspondent for KQED Guy Marzorati examined the latest California governor debate in San Francisco.