This place—a sun-blasted spine of craggy mountains and sand, where everything sticks, stings, or stinks, as one naturalist put it—can stop you cold with its sheer hostility. But beneath the surface is a world that refuses to give up in the face of warming waters, bleaching reefs, and mounting human pressure. And it wasn’t done wowing me yet.

Still buzzing from the morning’s cetacean spectacle, passengers returned to pangas after lunch, expecting some gentle, low-key snorkeling. But when our tiny boat idled in what felt like the dead center of the Gulf of California, I realized I’d misread the script.

“Okay, we jump here. Big school,” our guide said.

Here? I shook my head. Absolutely not. I’d hit my sensory limit. But once again, peer pressure prevailed. When the 80-year-old beside me calmly adjusted his snorkel, pride did what courage wouldn’t. I jumped.

Blinking into the blue, I looked down and the ocean floor was… moving. Not moving, commuting. Thousands upon thousands of bigeye jacks streamed beneath me like silver SUVs in L.A. traffic, and I was never happier to have faced my open water fears.