HUMBOLDT COUNTY, Calif. — A Northern California mother accused of hiding her child’s death for months was arrested in a small Indiana town after investigators traced her across state lines in a case that began with a missing person report and ended with the discovery of human remains in a remote wooded area near Blue Lake.

Law enforcement said Nichole Thorpe, 32, was taken into custody April 29 in Redkey, Ind., nearly two and a half years after detectives first learned a juvenile had vanished from the lives of family members without explanation.

The investigation began Dec. 3, 2023, when the Arcata Police Department asked the Eureka Police Department’s (EPD) Criminal Investigations Unit to assist in a missing person case. During the investigation, detectives learned the child had not been seen by relatives for an extended period of time and investigators believed the child was dead, with the death allegedly concealed by Thorpe.

The booking photo for 32-year-old Nichole Thorpe of Albany, Ind., following her arrest on Sunday, April 29, 2026, for involuntary manslaughter, child abuse, conspiracy, concealing a death and failing to report a child death. Thorpe was transported to the Jay County Security Center, where she will be incarcerated until being extradited back to Humboldt County, Calif. (Courtesy: Redkey Police Department)

The booking photo for 32-year-old Nichole Thorpe of Albany, Ind., following her arrest on Sunday, April 29, 2026, for involuntary manslaughter, child abuse, conspiracy, concealing a death and failing to report a child death. Thorpe was transported to the Jay County Security Center, where she will be incarcerated until being extradited back to Humboldt County, Calif. (Courtesy: Redkey Police Department)

The next day, Eureka detectives joined the Humboldt County Search and Rescue Team, the Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office and Cal Poly Humboldt personnel in searching a remote area near Blue Lake. During the search, investigators located human remains.

DNA testing later confirmed the remains belonged to the missing child, Eureka police said.

Following an extensive investigation, EPD said an arrest warrant was issued for Thorpe on April 9, 2026, for homicide, child endangerment and welfare fraud. Additionally, the police in Redkey, Ind., said Thorpe was wanted by the State of California for involuntary manslaughter, child abuse, conspiracy, concealing a death and failing to report a child death.

Investigators said the U.S. Marshals Service tracked Thorpe to a home near North Meridian and West Main streets in Redkey. The Redkey Police Department, Jay County Sheriff’s Office and Portland Police Department assisted in the arrest operation.

Police said Thorpe was found at the home and taken into custody by Town Marshal Alex Heath and Deputy Marshal Zach Brown without incident.

Thorpe, identified as a resident of Albany, Ind., was booked into the Jay County Security Center, where she is being held pending extradition to Humboldt County, Calif.

Anyone with information related to the case is asked to contact Eureka Police Detective Sgt. Cory Crnich at (707) 441-4300.

—

Report a correction or typo.