Thinking about buying a home but signing another lease instead? Welcome to Rental Diaries, where real people break down what it’s actually like to rent—what they pay, what they sacrifice, and what they’re still dreaming about.
Today, a divorced mom of 10-year-old twins shares how she found a reasonably priced home rental—with a pool—in America’s most expensive housing market, San Jose, CA.
When her marriage ended, this West Coast renter had one priority: keep her twin daughters’ lives as stable as possible. That meant staying in the same neighborhood, keeping them in the same schools, and finding a home big enough for two growing girls to each have their own space.
Given that she lives in America’s priciest metropolitan area, she knew that finding a property with even those small requirements was no easy feat.
According to the latest Realtor.com® Monthly Rental Report, the San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara metro remains the most expensive rental market out of the 50 largest metropolitan areas in the U.S. as of April, with a median asking rent of $3,306 a month.
Meanwhile, it also tops the list of most expensive markets for homebuyers out of the country’s 50 largest metros, with a current median list price of $1,398,500.
Needless to say, the last thing she expected to find was a four-bedroom, two-bathroom single-family home with a pool—at a price well below her budget. Here’s how she pulled it off, why she didn’t even try to negotiate the rent, and what she did with that extra fourth bedroom.
Who is the renter?
Age: 42
Household setup: Divorced with twin daughters
Occupation: Non-profit manager
What is the property like?
Location: San Jose, CA
Property type: Single-family home
Rooms: Four bedrooms, two bathrooms
Size: 2,000 square feet
Additional amenities: Pool
What was the budget—and how much were the final costs?
Maximum budget: $6,500 per month
Listed rent: $4,295 per month
Final rent: $4,295 per month
Security deposit: $4,295
Upfront deposit: $4,295
Renter’s insurance: $450 per year
Utilities included: Water, landscaping, pool maintenance
Inside the rental processWhat was your home experience when you were growing up?
I grew up in a two-story single family suburban home in Flagstaff, AZ. That’s where I lived until I went to college.
What has your living situation looked like up until this rental search?
My ex-husband and I ended up moving to San Jose for his job and we always rented. When we split up three years ago, I was focused on staying in San Jose so my daughters wouldn’t have to switch schools.
Did you ever think about buying?
We looked into it once, but San Jose is one of the most expensive places to live in the country, so it seemed more realistic to continue to rent. The fact that we didn’t own a home together made our divorce a little bit easier.
Did you have any non-negotiables?
I wanted to stay in the same neighborhood we were in because I didn’t want the kids to have to move schools. I also wanted them to have their own rooms.
What was the search like?
I probably looked at 10 places before I found this one online.
What was your first impression?
In person, it was better than in the photos. I liked the huge windows. There was a lot of light and the neighborhood and the street in general was beautiful. I also loved the pool—I’ve always wanted to live in a house with a pool.
Was there anything that was less than ideal about the rental?
It was old and looked a little rundown. When I moved in, I realized that the windows were single pane which meant that the house was poorly insulated. I asked the landlord to replace the windows and they replaced half right away. I haven’t asked about the other half—yet.
Did you negotiate on the listed rental price?
That wouldn’t work here. There are so many renters here and so few properties. I came in with my application filled out, a letter from my accountant and a security deposit for $4,295.
Besides the window panes, have you made any updates to the rental?
There is a second living room off the pool that was so ugly. I decided to turn it into a pink room—I’m divorced so why not? I got a beautiful pink rug and pink art. I love it now. Everyone that comes over is jealous of that room!
What do you love most about your rental?
The price is right, and I love that I’m able to have a pool. The kids love the house. It’s really spacious and there are so many other kids in the neighborhood. And we have a fourth bedroom that I didn’t need, but use as a guest bedroom for my mom (or overflow room for toys). It’s a happy ending.