The agency has not ​“provided evidence to justify the rather large increase in production subsidies” that the MDI program would provide, Meredith Fowlie, a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and faculty director at its Haas School of Business’ Energy Institute, wrote in an April blog post. ​“Increasing these output subsidies may further reduce leakage — or it may just transfer more value to incumbent producers without materially changing production decisions.”

And regardless of its efficacy in preventing leakage, environmental advocates say that CARB’s own prior analysis shows that the MDI program would undermine climate goals.

“Creating 118 million additional allowances effectively cancels out the 118 million they’re supposed to be reducing by 2030,” said Caroline Jones, manager of energy transition and carbon markets at the Environmental Defense Fund, which opposes CARB’s plan. ​“Removing these allowances was initially proposed by CARB as the lowest threshold of change required to meet 40% reductions by 2030.”

CARB’s counter is that these free allowances will flow only to participating companies that pledge to invest in future emissions reductions. But it’s unclear whether CARB will have the ability or the desire to force companies to make good on those promises. 

At the May 6 Senate hearing, Sanchez said that CARB would ​“monitor, evaluate, and propose adjustments to this program to ensure that it is working as intended and delivering on those emissions reductions.” 

So far, CARB has provided very little in the way of clear rules for how the MDI would accomplish this, Jones said. ​“There are no guardrails on how they need to account for the emissions reductions they’re achieving — or even if they are achieving them,” she said.

How CARB’s plan could undercut the carbon market 

Concerns loom over the ​“invest” side of the program as well.

California uses the revenue raised by selling cap-and-invest allowances to fund statewide climate and decarbonization efforts. But that funding mechanism is only as effective as the underlying market for the emissions allowances being traded — and environmental groups and lawmakers fear CARB’s plan will seriously undermine those dynamics.

Over the past two years, prices in the program’s quarterly allowances auctions have fallen from what Jones described as a relatively healthy range in the mid-$30s to low $40s per ton to the mid-$20s range. In fact, recent auction prices have been within a dollar or two of the minimum price set through a complex regulatory formula, she said.

“Prices in this program are already at a floor,” she said. CARB’s new proposal would ​“effectively flood the market with additional allowances, dragging down the market even further.”

The MDI program could have a particularly pernicious effect because it would open the door for companies to secure allowances on top of those they’ve already been allocated. In some cases, that could allow individual companies to ​“receive free allowances well in excess of their emissions,” wrote Fowlie, who is chair of the state’s Independent Emissions Market Advisory Committee.

According to Fowlie’s math, refineries tapping into the MDI program could rack up 6.1 allowances per barrel of oil, compared with the benchmark GHG emissions rate for refineries of about 3.89 tons per barrel. That windfall supply of allowances could be sold to other emitters, including other oil companies, depressing program revenues and industry compliance costs while turning a profit for polluters.

If those market dynamics play out, it would put a dent in funding for key climate and energy initiatives in California.

The cap-and-invest program helps fund a Climate Credit program that utilities use to reduce customer bills, as well as the state’s Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF), which has been a go-to source for programs that have faced funding cuts over the past several years of tight state budgets.

As part of last year’s negotiations over reauthorizing the state’s cap-and-invest program, lawmakers and Newsom’s office agreed to prioritize GGRF funds for a variety of purposes. The governor’s proposed 2026–2027 budget calls for $1 billion for the state’s high-speed rail project and $1.6 billion to backfill state forestry and fire protection, among other higher-tier funding priorities.

CARB, for its part, has argued that the doomsday scenario painted by critics is unlikely. After all, it’s hard to predict how an untested program like the MDI might impact a market that relies on buyers and sellers making their own decisions about what allowances are worth.

The agency ​“cannot predict auction revenues or results,” Sanchez emphasized in the May 6 Senate hearing. 

But analyses from independent experts and from the state Legislative Analyst’s Office estimate that MDI would add up to billions of dollars in lost auction revenue.

The proposal could lead to a $4 billion loss in auction revenue, equating to $2.3 billion less for the GGRF and $1.7 billion less for the Climate Credit from 2027 to 2030, according to an analysis by data scientists Kyle Meng and Jordan Wingenroth of UC Santa Barbara’s Environmental Markets Lab. In a report to lawmakers, the Legislative Analyst’s Office also found it ​“could somewhat reduce the overall amount of Climate Credit” funding, and would cut annual GGRF revenues to about $2 billion per year — roughly half what they’ve been in recent years.

That ​“would be inadequate to fully support Tier 2 programs” the report found, ​“and leave no funding for Tier 3 programs.”

During the May 6 hearing, Sen. Eloise Gómez Reyes, a Democrat and chair of the Budget Subcommittee on Resources, Environmental Protection, and Energy, grilled Sanchez on the risk of losing this funding. ​“Do you believe the legislature intended to eliminate funding for affordable housing, transit, drinking water, wildfire prevention and clean air programs with the reauthorization?” she asked.

When Sanchez responded that CARB hasn’t proposed to ​“defund any of those specific programs,” Gómez Reyes interrupted her. ​“Let me stop you for a moment,” Gómez Reyes said. ​“That will be the effect. … There’s nothing left to fund Tier 3, and those are the most important programs that have served the community.”

Sen. John Laird, a Democrat who chairs the Senate Budget and Fiscal Review Committee, noted that such a drastic reduction in funding would force lawmakers to ​“put everything back on the table” for upcoming negotiations over the governor’s revised budget plan.

“It really affects what we do, to what level we do it, how the different pieces fit together,” he said. ​“So I want to call out the budget side of the equation, because this is a big deal.” 

{
if ($event.target.classList.contains(‘hs-richtext’)) {
if ($event.target.textContent === ‘+ more options’) {
$event.target.remove();
open = true;
}
}
}”
>