Opinion Written by: Joseph Weinstein 

Late this past Tuesday night, I received an outraged call from a friend whose kids cannot afford to buy a home in Milpitas.  She suggested I watch the City Council Meeting; Item 15, a housing development was the agenda item.

The Developer had worked with City Staff over a 7 year period to present a final design that not only met the various State and Local requirements, but also had been approved by our Planning Commission.

I watched hypocrisy in action; a blatant example of why our children cannot afford homes and why housing costs and rents keep rising.

The Applicant, after a number of comments by our Council, stated that they had negotiated in good faith for over 7 years and asked the Council to approve their development. They pointed out that the project would deliver around $10,000,000 to the City in fees.

Mayor Montano reminded them that the City Council could negotiate too! First, she asked for a police substation, while the Police Department already has one less than a ¼ mile away. When she couldn’t get that, she said that she would take $1,000,000 for the City; the applicant had already offered an additional $400,000.  Her request had nothing to do with housing!  She just wanted more money to fund “other things.”

Councilperson Chua agreed, offering no reason other than what the Mayor asked, and suggested that the payout be made in subsequent years.

Councilperson Barbadillo stated that because he liked to see both sides, the number should be $700,000.

There was no reason, related to housing, for these demands.  Montano even suggested that even though she liked the development she might not support it if she didn’t get her money!

None of these 3 Council people’s requests was related to housing! The end result is the Applicant agreed to raise their contribution to $700,000, and Montano, Chua, and Barbadillo, smiled in victory. Who do they think is ultimately ending up paying for the $300,000!!!

They won, our residents lost. The 3 of them just added $300,000 in costs to the Development in a “victory for the City.” The only result of their efforts was to raise the cost of housing to buyers and low income renters!

Some may laugh and point out that an additional $300,000 in a multi-million project is meaningless in the long run. Well, if that is true, then why not reduce City Fees by $300,000 instead. Almost 30% of housing costs are related to government fees. The Council had a chance to address this in a meaningful way. This is just another example of government officials campaigning on housing affordability and then voting the opposite.

Where is the commitment to address housing affordability? Montano, Chua, and Barbadillo just acted opposite of almost everyone’s desire to lower housing and rental costs and pricing.

Note: The Author has been a Milpitas resident since 1976 and is a retired Real Estate Broker who was focused on helping First Time Home Buyers.