Virginia Donahue, the former director of the San Francisco's Animal Care and Control, was appointed Tuesday to oversee the city's dog court.

Virginia Donahue, the former director of the San Francisco’s Animal Care and Control, was appointed Tuesday to oversee the city’s dog court.

Jessica Christian/The Chronicle

Dog court is coming back to San Francisco after the hearings to deal with vicious canines were abruptly suspended a year ago. The proceedings will be helmed by the out-going head of the city’s animal shelter system.

The hearings stopped after the Department of Police Accountability, which oversaw the program, said it could no longer afford to hold them. Unresolved cases have piled up since then, frustrating dog owners and residents who say they have been menaced by badly behaved pets but have no venue to seek remedy.

Virgina Donohue’s appointment to dog court was announced Tuesday by Supervisor Stephen Sherrill. 

Article continues below this ad

The hearings, sometimes referred to as “dog court,” provide a place for people to work out disputes over an animal’s behavior. The program was established in 2001 after a San Francisco woman was killed in her apartment by a neighbor’s mastiff. 

At a hearing of the Board’s Government Audit and Oversight Committee last month, Greg Sutherland, the officer tasked with investigating dog attacks for the San Francisco Police Department, said more than 66 cases awaited a hearing. The last hearing took place at the end of June 2025, according to the San Francisco Standard. 

San Francisco Chronicle Logo

Make us a Preferred Source to get more of our news when you search.

Add Preferred Source

Dog bites have been trending up in San Francisco in recent years. There were more than 1,020 reported to the police in 2025, up from nearly 870 the year before. This year, there had already been more than 430 reported by the end of May. 

Donohue spent 11 years as executive director of Animal Care and Control before her retirement was announced at the end of May. In addition to overseeing the city’s animal shelter, the agency also responds to animal-related emergencies, provides low-cost veterinary care and investigates animal abuse and neglect. Amy Corso, who previously served as ACC’s deputy director, was promoted to fill the role. 

Article continues below this ad

“You will be dog judge for dog court,” Sherrill said Tuesday at the Board of Supervisor’s meeting where Donohue’s work was recognized. “We’re really quite thrilled that you’re taking up this mantle and helping these critical hearings get back on track.”

In brief remarks to the supervisors, Donohue thanked her former colleagues for their work handling the “physically demanding and emotionally challenging” job of caring for the some 10,000 animals that come through the department each year and she said she was looking forward to taking on her new role. 

“It really, really has to happen,” Donohue said. “It’s truly important.” 

At the hearing last month, Steven Betz, the chief of public safety in the mayor’s office, said he expected the hearings to be up and running again in July. The city expects to hold roughly three hearings each week as it works to clear the case backlog, Betz said. Donohue said she does not have an official start date yet but said she plans to take at least a month off before she dives into the new role.

The San Francisco Police Department will handle the administrative and investigative work and the ACC will provide information at the hearings about a dog’s behavior, ownership history and risk to the public, Betz said at the hearing. 

Article continues below this ad

Donohue told the Chronicle on Tuesday that clearing the case backlog would be her top priority. Before taking over at ACC, Donohue ran a pet boarding business with several locations in San Francisco and worked as a public affairs manager for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. She said her tenure with ACC taught her valuable lessons about pet owners that would inform how she handles and adjudicates the disputes that will come before her.  

“I’ve worked with dogs for 30 years so I have a good sense for dog behavior, but I think working at ACC has also helped me have a good sense for people,” she said.

Often, Donohue said, “conflicts over dogs could be resolved if the custodian of the offending dog could say ‘I’m sorry,’ pays the vet bill and steps up,” Donohue said. “It’s all about people taking responsibility for their dogs.”