The final prosecution witness was the owner of the Reel Inn, a popular Malibu seafood restaurant on the Pacific Coast Highway that was leveled in the fire on Jan. 7, 2025. Andy Leonard narrated before-and-after photos of what he called his “seafood shack,” which he said he had operated for 38 years. The popular eatery was pictured full of noshing customers in the first shot, followed by a scene of blackened rubble after the blaze. Leonard said he hoped to rebuild and reopen someday.

During an eight-hour interview with investigators months before he was arrested but weeks after the fire, Rinderknecht said he was alone in the area around midnight on Dec. 31, 2024. Toward the end of the interview, while walking with agents at the scene of the Lachman Fire, the defendant said he may have smoked a cigarette or two while on the darkened trail. When questioned about the statement, Rinderknecht claimed he could not remember what brand he smoked or how he lit the cigarettes.

Prosecutors contend a green Bic grill lighter found in Rinderknecht’s rented car was used to set the blaze.

Retired Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department detective Ed Nordskog testified Monday for the defense, saying that prosecutors’ belief that Rinderknecht was spurred by a desire for “societal revenge” could not be proven. The Lachman Fire, he said, couldn’t even be considered arson in the first place.

“There’s no data that says it’s arson,” Nordskog said. “There’s more evidence this was fireworks … In fact, I don’t believe it’s an arson at all.”