The Padres have reached the All-Star break with a 48-48 record, which is somewhat remarkable when you consider they have the worst offense in Major League Baseball and their pitching staff has suffered enough injuries to fill Section 101 at Petco Park (which is only a slight exaggeration). The first half of the season has been a rough one so everyone except Mason Miller, who is in Philadelphia for the All-Star Game, has basically the same idea of how to spend the four-day break.
“Rest. Sleep. Be far from humanity for a couple of days and then come back to it,” says outfielder Fernando Tatis Jr.
“They need a break. We all need a break,” says rookie manager Craig Stammen. “They’ve been doing everything that I’ve asked for for the first half of the season and I’m going to ask them probably do even more in the second half.”
He’s going to have to, not just ask, but demand more from his club when it returns to play on Friday in Kansas City because despite all the struggles and middling record the Friars are somewhat miraculously only 3.5 games out of a National League Wild Card spot.
“This is what we’ve asked for, is to be in somewhat contention and to be able to fight for a playoff spot,” says Stammen, who has received mixed reviews in his first season as a skipper at any level.
President of baseball operations A.J. Preller admits he hasn’t given his first year manager a complete roster to work with.
“We’re in position where we could potentially get to October, but we’re going to have to get better,” says Preller.
Which brings us to August 3, the MLB Trade Deadline. Since 2020, Preller and the Padres have been in the mode of emptying the farm system to acquire players they hope can help them win a World Series that season. This year, sitting at .500 and needing to leapfrog four teams to reclaim a playoff spot, the plan is nowhere near as clear-cut.
Do they add to make another playoff run? Or do they send off pieces and regroup for next year?
“We’re going to go into the process open minded to see what’s there and see what can help our club,” says Preller. “Whether it’s acquiring players or, you know, kind of looking at it like, we have to go another direction.”
Preller is so conditioned to chasing improvement he can’t even utter the word “sell.” Part of the equation will come into focus as teams that are currently in contention surge or fade, becoming buyers or sellers (San Diego included).
“You’ve got to look at what’s out there in the market, you’ve got to be realistic with things that you can do as a group and a team, and you’ve also got to have a feel for where your team is,” says Preller.
That’s why the daunting 10-game road trip that awaits them after the All-Star break is utterly crucial. After playing three in Kansas City against the Royals, who share the worst record in the game, the Friars play four in Atlanta and three in Miami, both teams who currently hold playoff spots.
“You don’t want to overreact from game to game but obviously you get more information over those ten days and that’ll all be part of our process in making our decisions here as we get to the deadline,” says Preller.
Put bluntly: if they play well on that trip the Padres will be buyers. If they stumble further they’ll be sellers, which brings up the possibility of trading Miller, something no San Diego fan wants to consider. Other teams have expressed interest in The Reaper but Preller says he’s in no hurry to make that move.
“Mason’s the best in the game. You’re always going to have people interested in somebody that’s the best at their craft and and what they do. He’s performed as good as you could want somebody to perform. We made the deal with the intention that Mason is going to be here for a long time and our intent is still the same as when we made the deal last year.”
As with all things in sports, the best way to avoid being in that precarious position is to win as much as humanly possible.