Just past noon on a recent Saturday in Cayucos, there’s a growing line around the block of its main drag, Ocean Avenue. The length of this human daisy chain is rapidly expanding and the size of it – along with the anticipation emanating from those who occupy it – seems very out of place. It’s the large-scale expectant hum usually reserved for sold-out concerts or playoff game tailgaters.

Inevitably, someone from the queue overhears an inquisitive onlooker, turns to them, and deadpans, “It’s the waffle. Seriously. You gotta try it.”

And the line suddenly grows by two more.

Part coastal foodie mecca, part best beachfront patio views, the spot is a thoughtful breakfast and lunch joint specializing in waffles, called Hidden Kitchen. It’s a vibey, locally owned co-op, the kind of place where you can sweeten your organic coffee with cinnamon and dates and outrun the onset of a weekend hangover with scrambled eggs, slow-cooked carnitas, green salsa and fresh avocado.

Lines around the block are a regular feature of the Cayucos, Calif., outpost of Hidden Kitchen restaurant.  (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Lines around the block are a regular feature of the Cayucos, Calif., outpost of Hidden Kitchen restaurant. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

The tiny, casual restaurant, thanks to word of mouth and boosts from frequent posters on social media, is starting to draw folks from all over the nation to stand in line.

This serpentine line is an everyday event and yet still a shock to owner Amanecer Eizner. But it shouldn’t be. It takes but a minute to hear her tell her own origin story, which features a profound and unlikely upbringing that immediately puts into context the communal spirit of the operation.

“I grew up in Esalen,” Eizner told SFGATE this week. “I was born on property, my brother was also born on property.”

The Avila Avo, Hidden Kitchen restaurant's famous blue corn waffle with a free-range egg, avocado, everything bagel seasoning and Tajin chili salt is just one of the savory specialty waffle dishes that have made the Cayucos, Calif., restaurant a must-stop. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

The Avila Avo, Hidden Kitchen restaurant’s famous blue corn waffle with a free-range egg, avocado, everything bagel seasoning and Tajin chili salt is just one of the savory specialty waffle dishes that have made the Cayucos, Calif., restaurant a must-stop. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Esalen Institute is one of the world’s famed wellness institutions, known for ushering in a modern era of self-realization; it was also featured in one of the most famous final shots in TV history, as the place where Don Draper finally exhaled his inner demons.

Eizner’s first memories, she said, were of a place called “the duck pond.” As romantic as it may sound, those were the code words for “the dish pit in this giant kitchen where all of our favorite aunties and uncles were,” she said

She and her brother always had access to the Esalen kitchen, chopping vegetables and helping make pancakes. “My brother and I and a couple other kids really integrated into that food world,” she recalled of living there, when her mother ran the bookshop and her father helped out with the guest experience on the managerial side. “The farm was on that property. We learned about processing food and preparing food, watching these giant meals come together from people who came from all over the world.”

Diners enjoy the generous oceanside patio in the back of the Cayucos, Calif., Hidden Kitchen restaurant.  (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Diners enjoy the generous oceanside patio in the back of the Cayucos, Calif., Hidden Kitchen restaurant. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

After graduating from high school, it became time to strike out on her own. In the fall of 2010, Eizner was accepted into Cal Poly and headed south to San Luis Obispo, where the slightly bigger world seemed to come at her a little too fast. “I came down here and was like, ‘I’m free! Screw my parents!’ I partied my face off the first year and got kicked out.”

She returned home and worked various hospitality and restaurant jobs in the region, vowing to return to SLO, a community that she felt an immediate connection with. “I really wanted to be here,” she said, “so I returned and worked my way through restaurants, got back into school and ended up graduating.”

She eventually graduated from the university with a degree in hospitality and set off on a similar path to many college graduates, trying different things. She started a jewelry line. She traveled. She fell in love with her now-husband, Wes Cooke.

One of the specialty blue corn waffles at Hidden Kitchen restaurant in Cayucos, Calif. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

One of the specialty blue corn waffles at Hidden Kitchen restaurant in Cayucos, Calif. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Then one day when the pair was traveling through Mexico, they stumbled upon a tiny cafe that specialized in making blue corn tortillas – along with pretty much everything else you could think of to make with blue corn, including a blue corn waffle. “I ate one and I was like, ‘Wes!'” she recalled of her epiphany at that table.

The pair returned home with some blue corn masa and immediately gathered their crew in the kitchen to see if they could re-create it. “I have this vivid memory of sitting around the center island at the house,” she recalled, noting, with a chuckle, that everyone was on a paleo diet at the time.

After a lot of trial and error featuring the work of area cooks and scientists, regenerative geeks and eager onlookers as tasters, they finally dialed in a recipe for the waffle that was “no dairy, and kind of high-protein.”

“We were proud of ourselves,” she said.

At the same time, a friend of theirs had a tiny commercial kitchen space available in the nearby coastal town of Cambria, about 15 miles north of Cayucos. That first spot is a whimsical walk-up window draped in foliage, where a tighter menu is available Saturdays and Sundays. Eizner found a waffle iron at Goodwill, grabbed her blender and went all in on opening the restaurant in October 2018.

The original Hidden Kitchen in Cambria, Calif., was little more than a pop-up window serving smoothies and waffles. Add years and an additional location in nearby Cayucos, Calif., and it's a viral attraction.  (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

The original Hidden Kitchen in Cambria, Calif., was little more than a pop-up window serving smoothies and waffles. Add years and an additional location in nearby Cayucos, Calif., and it’s a viral attraction. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Crowds began to grow, Sunset Magazine stopped by, and before you knew it, Hidden Kitchen, named after the hard-to-find first spot, was gaining a following. “I still pinch myself and have imposter syndrome that Hidden Kitchen has grown as much as it has,” Eizner said.

The rest is a whirlwind that continues today. In 2020, Hidden Kitchen was ready to grow beyond its Cambria digs, and Cayucos came calling. This was a proper-sized restaurant with a storefront on the sleepy main drag and a back patio with panoramic views of the Pacific.

They went all in on the second spot buoyed by local success and word of mouth in Cambria, a place she described as intensely loyal and supportive of its businesses. “Cambria’s like, if there’s a cute, new fun thing in town, everyone’s going to show up and support you,” she said. “We had connections in SLO County from being in the community for so long.”

The timing of its opening, March 2020, couldn’t have been worse. A week after the second, and now main, location opened its doors, COVID-19 shut it down. But Eizner said that gave her and her crew time to pivot to takeout and also work out the kinks of running a full-time endeavor, rather than just a weekend commitment in Cambria.

A sampling of some of Hidden Kitchen restaurant's specialty blue corn waffles in Cayucos, Calif. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

A sampling of some of Hidden Kitchen restaurant’s specialty blue corn waffles in Cayucos, Calif. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

One of the legendary "superfood smoothies" at Hidden Kitchen. The restaurant, with locations in the neighboring California coastal towns of Cambria and Cayucos, regularly draws lines around the block.  (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

One of the legendary “superfood smoothies” at Hidden Kitchen. The restaurant, with locations in the neighboring California coastal towns of Cambria and Cayucos, regularly draws lines around the block. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Mastering the take-out business on the fly also gave the Hidden Kitchen crew time to refine the menu and get ready for folks to come in. As soon as outdoor seating opened up, they had their signature patio on the doorstep of the ocean ready to go.

In a sense, what it all did, she said, was take her right back to the initial communal kitchen times of her youth at Esalen.

Denver residents Brendon Powley and Erin Vinkula were enjoying their most-anticipated meal of their Central Coast honeymoon on a recent weekday at Hidden Kitchen.

“We used to live in SLO, and just got recommended this place,” Powley said of discovering Hidden Kitchen a few years back. “… This is one of the first stops we wanted to come back to.”

“I always get the waffle,” Vinkula said. “I love it.”

“They’re fluffy and they’re not too sweet,” Powley chimed in.

“Not too savory either,” Vinkula continued. “It’s the blue corn – the first time we went, I was like, ‘I don’t know,’ but the combo is great, not too savory or grainy or anything. It’s just right.”

The blue corn specialty is one of six waffles on offer. Though there are fancy additions – like free-range eggs, Niman Ranch bacon ends and avocado drizzled in house sauce – it’s the $12 Cambria Classic (butter, maple syrup and powdered sugar) that keeps me coming back to the delightfully light, circular blue marvel.

A line cook at Hidden Kitchen restaurant in Cayucos, Calif., scoops the batter for one of its famous blue corn waffles.  (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

A line cook at Hidden Kitchen restaurant in Cayucos, Calif., scoops the batter for one of its famous blue corn waffles. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Alex Nelson, a line cook at the Hidden Kitchen in Cayucos and the manager at the Cambria location, sat down for a minute to describe what’s kept him coming back here to work for a little over two and a half years. Born and raised in San Jose, he said he found his way down to the Central Coast and, like many before him, “ended up staying.”

“I worked a few jobs at wineries and other random stuff,” he told SFGATE. “I found it here, saw what they did and that was it. … It was the vibe. I just loved the food. Simple. Everything was just tasty. That’s why I’ve been spending five days a week here for almost the past three years.”

And he too, deferred to the star of the show, the waffle: “Blue corn, gluten-free. It’s just different enough to be adventurous, but still brings the comfort food [feelings].”

Amanecer Eizner, second from the left, and some of her staff at Hidden Kitchen show off retail bags of the blue cornmeal, the key ingredient to the restaurant's most famous dish, blue corn waffles.  (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Amanecer Eizner, second from the left, and some of her staff at Hidden Kitchen show off retail bags of the blue cornmeal, the key ingredient to the restaurant’s most famous dish, blue corn waffles. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Ryan Kasper, who grew up in Cambria and recently moved back to the Central Coast, said he felt the embrace of the Hidden Kitchen staff, whom he first came to know working there in high school, right away when he returned.

“The environment is super nice,” he said. “I’m freshly back and everyone welcomed me back in. The food’s obviously good; everyone who comes in is always pretty happy to be here.”

He acknowledged that the place here is “not like many other restaurants, or businesses.”

That too, is by design, owner Eizner said: “I think just being a part of a community and, knowing how much everyone can come together, many hands making light work,” she explained.

Hidden Kitchen owner Amanecer Eizner, right, with her husband, Wes Cooke. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

Hidden Kitchen owner Amanecer Eizner, right, with her husband, Wes Cooke. (Photo Courtesy Amanecer Eizner)

All of this, her upbringing at Esalen, working restaurant jobs and learning what not to do, discovering a culinary unicorn and calling on her found community to help make it happen, is all a part of a narrative that those who find themselves standing in line at Hidden Kitchen may or may not know about.

But one thing is for certain, as soon as they cross that threshold, or get that first plate of food dropped in front of them, at some point, they’ll know, Eizner said. They’ll feel it.

“I think it’s just fueled almost by external energy, people walk through the door, it’s like Disneyland,” she concluded. “They’re waiting for the experience in line, they’re waiting for the food to come out. It’s epic. It’s beautiful. And the staff is excited to deliver it.”

Hidden Kitchen, 113 North Ocean Ave., Cayucos, open daily, 9 a.m.-3 p.m.; 2164 Center St., Cambria, open Saturday and Sunday, 9 a.m.-2 p.m.

More Central Coast

– Central Valley commuter city can’t stop megadevelopment
– California’s first carbon capture facility raises fears
– Massive pod of dolphins sighted cavorting off Calif. coast
– Calif. farmers bulldoze apple trees after Martinelli’s ends contracts

Get SFGATE’s top stories sent to your inbox by signing up for The Daily newsletter here.

This article originally published at Raised at Esalen, this California restaurateur now has a cult following of her own.