SAN JOSE — An appellate court reversed murder convictions in a deadly 2019 drug deal ambush in San Jose after finding that a prosecutor’s pit bull analogy during jury selection and subsequent animal-oriented “predator” remarks at trial — involving Black and Latino defendants — violated the state’s Racial Justice Act.
In a ruling issued Friday, the 6th District Court of Appeal overturned life-without-parole sentences for Ricardo Diaz, 31, and Alexander Jose Toledo, 35, and a 13-year sentence for 31-year-old Keonte Jordun Ray Smith.
The three Stockton men were convicted four years ago in the fatal Aug. 15, 2019, shooting of 21-year-old Brian Castro, in what authorities described as a setup by the defendants to rob Castro and a friend during a reputed $4,000 marijuana deal outside a San Jose minimart. Diaz and Toledo were found guilty of murder, robbery and assault, and Smith was found guilty of the latter two crimes.
Justice Cynthia Lie, who led a unanimous three-judge panel and wrote the ruling, described how during jury selection in 2022, a prospective juror voiced hesitance about being able to stay impartial in a case involving a drug deal and guns.
Deputy District Attorney Sulaiman Tokhi responded by giving an analogy about how when he was in law school, he was asked to watch a friend’s pit bull and was initially nervous that the animal might hurt him based on what he had read about the breed, but that the dog ended up being compliant and affable. Lie viewed the analogy as an apparent effort to convince the candidate that she was similarly capable of overcoming her preconceived notions about the defendants and serve on the jury.
During the exchange, a different jury candidate openly decried what he called a comparison of the defendants to an animal, but both Tokhi and Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Deborah Ryan disagreed with the accusation. The candidate who criticized the analogy was dismissed after the prosecutor objected to the implication of prejudice, and the initial prospective juror was also later dismissed from the jury pool.
In her ruling, Lie asserted that “an objective observer would view the prosecutor’s analogy as problematic,” even as she gave grace to Tokhi in presuming he was not intentionally running afoul of the Racial Justice Act. The landmark California law, which was enacted in 2021 and originated in the South Bay, provides relief for criminal defendants who can show they were prejudiced by explicit or systemic racial bias in their charges, convictions or sentences.
“We presume that the prosecutor’s analogy sprang from his lived experience … and not from any intention to skirt the letter of the new prohibition on animal tropes contrary to RJA’s purpose and intent. The prosecutor may have had innocuous reasons for employing the analogy,” Lie wrote. “But the prosecutor here chose a pit bull as his focus, specifically citing the breed’s reputation for viciousness, when countless other analogies could have similarly addressed bias without reinforcing it by reference to animals or animalistic behavior.”
She added, “Under the RJA, we examine the language employed by the prosecutor, not his intent or apparent good faith.”
Vanessa Place, the attorney who represented Smith in the appeal, emphasized that the reversed convictions are not a judgment on the severity of the charged offenses, but a recognition that defendants are “entitled to a trial free of implicit bias as much as humanly possible.”
“Yes, these are serious crimes, and particularly with crimes of violence, prosecutors and all attorneys have to be very careful they’re not defaulting to things that predispose a jury to look at a defendant a certain way,” she said. “We want people being convicted based upon what they’ve done, not who they are.”
The District Attorney’s Office deferred comment about the 6th District opinion to the state Attorney General’s Office, which represented them in the appeal and did not respond to a request for comment.
The ruling also scrutinized Tokhi’s remarks in opening and closing arguments at trial, zeroing in on a characterization of the drug trade as an oceanic “food chain,” in which the shooting victims were “potential prey for predators” like the defendants. He also called the shooting trial “a case about the food chain on the street where you have three subjects: Mr. Toledo, Mr. Diaz, and Mr. Smith, preying on the drug dealers.”
Lie wrote that “this imagery of a predatory ocean species devouring its prey in turn reinforced the prosecutor’s earlier expressed fears of being mauled by a vicious pit bull,” and that “the impact of the pit bull analogy was compounded by the … language of ‘predator and prey’ in the context of a ‘food chain’ among ocean wildlife.”
Randy Kravis, the appellate attorney who represented Diaz, lauded the ruling for its “thoughtfulness and the attention the justices on the Court of Appeal gave,” and Toledo appellate attorney Michael Sampson echoed the sentiment.
“The Racial Justice Act was enacted to ensure that racial bias, whether intentional or unintentional, has no place in California’s criminal justice system,” Sampson said. “The Court of Appeal recognized that comparing defendants to animals can improperly appeal to racial bias and thus undermine the fairness of a trial.”
As a result of the 6th District ruling, the defendants’ convictions and sentences were vacated and the case was remanded back to trial court in Santa Clara County, where it will be overseen by a different judge, as Ryan has since retired. Lie and the judicial panel were clear in stating that the defendants were not entitled to double-jeopardy protections given the evidence against them, making a retrial or new plea negotiations among the possible next steps in the case. Additionally, the appellate opinion was unpublished, a court classification indicating that that it cannot be cited as precedent.
Diaz, Toledo and Smith, all of whom are in state prison custody, are expected to be transferred to local jail custody once the case returns to Superior Court.