In an early August email, sent as teachers and administrators were preparing to welcome students back to school, Oakland Unified School District made a surprising announcement: this year, OUSD added only six new principals. It was the lowest number of new school leaders in years. In 2022, coming out of COVID remote schooling, the district had to fill 18 principal vacancies.
Every single principal in OUSD’s middle schools and high schools returned to their roles this year, the email said.
Principals, as one told The Oaklandside, are basically mayors of small towns that take up a city block. They need to be experts in instruction, while supporting diverse students and staff, overseeing their school facilities, and responding to emergencies.
Consistency and stability in the principal’s office is crucial to building a cohesive school culture and vision, which can take years, several principals told The Oaklandside. Clifford Hong, who oversees middle school principals and their sites for the district, said laying out a proper vision is vital to delivering on each schools’ promise of delivering a solid education.
“It takes years for a principal to master skills but also to understand their school community and to build relationships and trust,” Hong said. “When you have principal turnover, it disrupts the ability to create that trust and to understand the nuances of that community. Anytime you have a new leader, you have to start that process all over again and it leads that community to lose focus.”
Severe headwinds threaten to reverse those gains. With the district facing $100 million in budget cuts for the next school year, principals worry their jobs could get far harder as staff are laid off or there are fewer resources to go around.
At the federal level, the Trump Administration has been gutting the Department of Education, which provides crucial funding, training, and support, especially for vulnerable student groups that Oakland serves. Moves to restrict what educators can or can’t cover in the classroom also promise to make school governance harder.
A ‘joy’ in the mission
Hong is in his sixth year as the middle schools network superintendent; before that he served as the principal of Roosevelt Middle School for 10 years. When he asked his principals what keeps them in their jobs, many of them said it was their commitment to seeing their vision through — and their commitment to Oakland and its values.
Cary Kaufman is the president of United Administrators for Oakland Schools, which represents principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles. He said that despite the challenges of serving in the role in Oakland, school principals here value the district’s commitment to social justice.
“OUSD is a tough district to work within,” Kaufman told The Oaklandside. “However, it’s also unique. As an extremely diverse district that has always fought for equity and supporting the most marginalized of people, there’s a level of joy in that mission and in that work that we don’t always see in other districts.”
For Alykhan Boolani, the principal of Life Academy, a small school teaching grades six to 12 in Fruitvale, what’s most rewarding about his role is working alongside educators who share those values.
“I think Oakland’s filled with educators who are filled by a sense of justice and wanting to do right by kids,” Boolani said.
Faris Jabbar, principal at La Escuelita Elementary School, greets a student on the first day of school in August 2025. Credit: Jungho Kim for The Oaklandside
At the same time, their efforts to provide a strong academic program and institutional stability have been undermined by year after year of budget cuts. Hong, the network superintendent, said principals struggle to navigate the reality of having to fundraise for supplies that the school budget could previously pay for, losing staff roles, or facing the threat of a school closure or merger.
Last year, the school board put Life Academy on a list to be merged. Though the board ultimately backed off of the plan in the face of community opposition, Boolani said experiences like that breed uncertainty, which leads to instability. As a leader, he said, he chooses to operate as if the school will exist forever.
“I have to spend time on my side ensuring my staff feels like there’s something worth pursuing here,” he said. “If I were to just engage with a lack of vision this would be an incoherent program and it would not be worth anyone’s time.”
Boolani is the sole principal of Life Academy this year, for the first time in seven years. Last year, his co-principal, Aryn Bowman, stepped down another consequence of financial constraints. Though Bowman chose to step down, consolidating the co-principal structure at their small school was always a possibility, Boolani said.
The Oaklandside also spoke with Moyra Contreras, one of OUSD’s longest serving principals. She became the acting principal of what was then known as Melrose Elementary School in 1993 while the permanent principal was on maternity leave. That person never came back, and Contreras stayed until 2019, when she took a role overseeing high schools in the district’s central office.
“I thought I would stay a couple years. Two years turned into 27,” she said. “There was always more to do.”
She expressed disappointment at school board discussions that repeatedly revolve around making cuts. She’d like to see the district’s leaders first establish what basic resources students need and build from there.
“Instead of, ‘Let’s cut here and let’s cut there and see if we can get enough money to make it through the year,’” Contreras said, “we really have to have a better sense of where we’re going and what we’re trying to build together.”
Making the job ‘doable’
During her tenure as a principal, Contreras helped to found Melrose Leadership Academy, part of the small schools movement that took over Oakland in the early 2000s. She oversaw multiple campus moves as she worked with the community to redesign the institution as the bilingual K to 8 school that it is today. Melrose Leadership Academy remains one of OUSD’s most in-demand schools, consistently receiving more applications than seats for kindergarten and sixth grade.
After Contreras left MLA, she became executive director overseeing high schools for the district, but that position was cut after a single year on the job. Now Contreras serves as the executive director of United Administrators of Oakland Schools.
“The job was so big,” she said of the principal role. “I felt like administrators need and deserve to have somebody who understands their work and supports them and is also student-centered. What we need to do is make the job doable and joyful so that administrators can provide the best opportunities for kids.”
Fremont High School principal Nidya Baez hands out papers during class in April 2022. Credit: Amir Aziz/The Oaklandside
In that role she’s been able to get school leaders organized, support them in filing grievances — and deliver on some of the resources they need. In the last three years, the union has grown its membership, which is voluntary, by 35%, Contreras said. After the last round of negotiations with the district concluded last year, UAOS members earned a 21% salary bump. Still, principal pay in Oakland lags behind other school districts — elementary principals start at $120,000 and top out around $157,000. In California, average elementary principal pay in large districts is $157,000.
Tierre Mesa is in her seventh year as principal at Urban Promise Academy, and her 26th year with the district. She said the most difficult conversations she has with her community are about doing more with less.
“We’re now in our third year of cuts,” she told The Oaklandside. “When we talk to our community about budgeting, it’s not dreaming and visioning of what we can do with more, it’s what are we prioritizing, because we’re going to have to get rid of something. Those are really hard conversations to lead.”
This year Urban Promise lost its newcomer assistant, who worked with recent immigrant students who are learning English reading skills. About 15% of the school’s students are newcomers, Mesa said. While the loss is unrelated to the district’s budget issues — the position was funded by a state grant — the impact is the same, Mesa said: losing valuable services that were going toward supporting students who need the most help.
With $100 million in cuts on the table, the school board has focused so far on shrinking the central office in an effort to keep schools whole.
“The board has directed us to keep reductions as far from schools as possible and to focus first on central office operations,” Denise Saddler, the district’s interim superintendent, said in a message to the public this month. “That’s what I’ve asked every department to do: Protect classroom instruction, even when it means deeper cuts to support services.”
But Mesa said that may be a false tradeoff. Cuts to the central office would likely erode support for school site leaders, which could result in an increase in principal turnover, Mesa said. Cuts in the talent department, in particular, could make it hard to find qualified teacher candidates to fill vacancies. Losing staff from the English language learners department would mean less training for principals in how to support their newcomer students.
“There’s a lot about being a principal that can feel isolating, but to know that I have a community of support within the central office helps me navigate those challenges,” she said. “I’m worried that the cuts to central office will be done in a way that makes school leadership feel unsustainable.”
Consistency in the principal’s office, multiple school leaders said, can have ripple effects on a school’s stability. A long-term principal can make a school more desirable, leading to higher enrollment and, in turn, more funding. Laurel Elementary, where principal John Stangl is in his 15th year, has seen enrollment tick up recently — a trend Stangl attributes in part to his long tenure.
“I think that’s something that families look for — stability in leadership,” Stangl told The Oaklandside. “It suggests stability beyond just the principalship but also in terms of staff. There’s a certain momentum that a principal who has been in place for more than five years can build upon.”
“*” indicates required fields